DRAFT’ MINUTES OF PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING NO. 424

HELD ON TUESDAY, 17TH JANUARY 2023

1.         TO RECORD ATTENDANCE

Present:  Cllrs R Finnigan (Deputy Chair), R Bell and A Dalton.

Cllr T Leadley also attended the meeting.

2.         TO RECEIVE APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE GIVEN IN ADVANCE OF THE MEETING
Apologies were received from Cllr C Bell.
3.         TO CONSIDER THE APPROVAL OF REASONS GIVEN FOR ABSENCE
The reasons for absence were considered and approved.

4.         Declarations of Disclosable Pecuniary and Other Interests

Cllr R Finnigan declared an ‘other’ interest as a Leeds City Councillor.

5.         TO APPROVE MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON 15/11/22

The Minutes of the meeting held on 15/11/2022 were agreed as a true and correct record.

6.         CONSIDERATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS

Notation of Recommendations.
O = Objection
N = No Objection
NC = No Objection (with comments)
D = Deferred
RECEIVED 04/01/23

N         08358 TWO STOREY PART SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 2 MARINA CRESCENT(TEALE)

RECEIVED 09/01/23

N         00031 RETROSPECTIVE CHANGE OF USE FROM MIXED UNITS TO MICRO BEWERY WAREHOUSE:CITY MILLS PEEL STREET(CENTRAL)

RECEIVED 11/01/23

O         00081 TWO STOREY SIDE/REAR EXTENSION; SINGLE STOREY INFILL EXTENSION  WITH ROOF LIGHT TO REAR; DEMOLITION OF EXISTING GARAGE: 74 IBBETSON OVAL (CHURWELL).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of inadequate parking.

O         08471 TWO STOREY SIDE EXTENSION AND FIRST FLOOR SIDE EXTENSION:                      1 HIGHFIELD TINGLEY WAKEFIELD(WOODKIRK).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of inadequate parking.

N         08282 ALTERATIONS TO BUILDING FACADE INCLUDING REMOVAL AND INFILLING OF EXISTING ENTRANCE WITH GLAZING; A NEW MAIN ENTRANCE; NEW FIRE ESCAPE DOORS; REMOVAL OF EXISTING ENTRANCE PATH; AND NEW FOOTPATH:                 CAPITA WHITE ROSE OFFICE PARK(CHURWELL)

7.         TO NOTE PLANNING APPLICATIONS WITH DECISIONS MADE UNDER DELEGATED AUTHORITY TO TOWN CLERK – STANDING ORDER 15(c) (APPLICATIONS RECEIVED THAT DID NOT APPEAR ON 15/11/2022 AGENDA)

RECEIVED 15/11/22

N         07090  DEMOLITION OF EXISTING CONSERVATORY; SINGLE STOREY EXTENSION TO REAR: 20 PARTRIDGE CLOSE (TOPCLIFFE).

N         06776  CONVERSION OF GARAGE TO FORM HOME OFFICE; FIRST FLOOR SIDE EXTENSION: 2 TURNBERRY CLOSE (WOODKIRK).

N         04897  FIRST FLOOR EXTENSION TO SIDE ELEVATIONS; SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION; OUTBUILDING TO REAR; DEMOLITION OF CONSERVATORY:

DAFFIL COTTAGE CROSSLAND ROAD (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 17/11/22

N         07598  CONVERSION OF GARAGE TO HABITABLE ROOM; SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 10 BEDALE STREET (TOPCLIFFE).

N         07603  DEMOLISH GARAGE BLOCK, ERECTION OF BUNGALOW WITH OFF ROAD PARKING: LOCK UP GARAGE SITE REAR OF 26 AND 28 DAISY HILL AVENUE (SCATCHERD).

 

RECEIVED 21/11/22

N         07652  ALTERATIONS INCLUDING DEMOLITION OF CONSERVATORY TO REAR; CONSTRUCTION OF SINGLE STOREY REAR AND SIDE EXTENSION: 27 BRUNTCLIFFE DRIVE MORLEY (TEALE).

RECEIVED 29/11/22

O         07786  REMOVAL OF CONDITIONS 3 AND 4 (OPERATING HOURS AND OPERATIONS OF APPROVED USE) OF PREVIOUS APPROVAL 20/02692FU:  60 SPRINGFIELD ROAD (SCATCHERD)

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of the original conditions to protect the residential amenity in a residential area should remain to prevent 24 hour working because of noise and other business activity impact. We also request a site visit and panel decision.

 

N         TR/07942  T1 COMMON ASH – REMOVE AS THE TREE HAS BEEN DEAD FOR A NUMBER OF YEARS WITH ROOT-BASED FUNGUS LIKELY TO BE THE CAUSE OF IT’S DEMISE :37 PAWSON STREET (TEALE).

RECEIVED 5/12/22

O         07778  ERECTION OF ADDITIONAL STOREY TO EXISING OFFICE BUILDING TO FORM THREE FLATS. SUBDIVISION OF EXISTING WAREHOUSE AND OFFICE BUILDING TO FORM NEW OFFICE AND WAREHOUSE SPACE AND EXTERNAL WORKS INCLUDING EXTERNAL STEPS; SOLAR PANNELS TO ROOF: SAFTEY HOUSE ACKROYD STREET MORLEY (CENTRAL)

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of overdevelopment, impact on conservation area, inadequate need for additional one bedroom flats plus not accessible as no lift.

N         07976  EXTENSION TO FIRST FLOOR AT FRONT: 58 HARWILL APROACH CHRUWELL MORLEY (CHURWELL)

RECEIVED 8/12/22

N         08008 CHANGE OF USE OF SHOP TO DRINKING ESTABLISHMENT: 28 QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL)

RECEIVED 12/12/22

N         08058  VARIATION OF CONDITION 3 (MATERIALS) TO PREVIOUSLY APPROVED PLANNING APPLICATION 22/05293/FU: SEVEN HILLS PRIMARY SCHOOL APPLEBY WAY

N         05536  INSTALLATION OF GENERATOR WITHIN FENCED ENCLOSURE: NHS SHARED BUSINESS SERVICES 1 MUNROE COURT WHITE ROSE OFFICE PARK (TOPCLIFFE)

N         08070 CONERSION OF GARAGE TO FORM HABITABLE ROOMS WITH ALTERATIONS TO FRONT ELEVATION INCLUDING REPLACING GARAGE DOOR WITH WINDOWS AND BRICKWORK: 47A GRANNY AVENUE CHURWELL MORLEY (CHURWELL)

RECEIVED 19/12/22

N         08254 TWO STOREY SIDE EXTENSION AND INTRERNAL ALTERATIONS: 1 SCOTCHMAN CLOSE MORLEY LEEDS(ELMFIELD)

The above decisions made under Town Clerk’s delegated authority, were noted.

 

8.         MORLEY CONSERVATION AREA APPRAISAL AND MANAGEMENT PLAN

It was proposed and agreed that Standing Order 3(d) be invoked, as follows:-

Standing Order 3(d)

Meeting shall be open to the public unless their presence is prejudicial to the public interest by reason of the confidential nature of the business to be transacted or for other special reason’.  The public exclusion from part or all of a meeting shall be by a resolution which shall give reasons for the public’s exclusion.

Cllr Tom Leadley gave members a verbal report on the Morley Conservation Area Appraisal and Management Plan and answered questions from members.

 

It was then proposed and agreed to reinstate Standing Order 3(d)

Following the result of the vote Standing Order 3(d) was re-instated.

 

9.         TO RECEIVE ITEMS OF CORRESPONDENCE (items for information only)

a)         Email dated 16/12/22 from Martin Elliott, Head of Strategic Planning, Leeds City Council re. Site Allocations Plan Remittal

b)         Email dated 16/12/22 from Martin Elliott, Head of Strategic Planning, Leeds City Council re. Site Allocations Plan Remittal

The above items of correspondence were noted.

10.       DATE AND TIME OF NEXT MEETING

The next scheduled meeting will be held on Tuesday, 14th March 2023 at 7.00 pm.

 

 

 

 

 

MINUTES OF PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING NO. 423

 HELD ON TUESDAY, 15^TH NOVEMBER 2022

1.TO RECORD ATTENDANCE

Present:  Cllrs R Finnigan (Deputy Chair), C Bell, R Bell and C Taylor.

2.         TO RECEIVE APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE GIVEN IN ADVANCE OF THE MEETING

Apologies were received from Cllrs A Dalton and M Storey.

3.         TO CONSIDER THE APPROVAL OF REASONS GIVEN FOR ABSENCE

The reasons for absence were considered and approved.

 4.  DECLARATIONS OF DISCLOSABLE PECUNIARY AND OTHER INTERESTS

Cllr R Finnigan declared an ‘other’ interest as a Leeds City Councillor

5.TO APPROVE MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON 27/9/22

The Minutes of the meeting held on 27/9/2022 were agreed as a true and correct record.

 

6. CONSIDERATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS

Notation of Recommendations.

O = Objection

N = No Objection

NC = No Objection (with comments)

D = Deferred

RECEIVED 26/10/22

N         06857  SIDE EXTENSION TO EXISTING WAREHOUSE AND RESURFACING OF SERVICE YARD: HIGHCLIFFE HOUSE HIGHCLIFFE MILLS BRUNTCLIFFE LANE (TEALE).

O         06740  CHANGE OF USE OF COMMERCIAL PREMISES TO FORM TWO FLATS IN BASEMENT AND LOFT; ASSOCIATED ALTERATIONS INLUDING NEW DORMER WINDOWS TO SIDES AND CREATION OF NEW BASEMENT WINDOWS AND LIGHTWELLS: 2 HIGH STREET (CENTRAL).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of the overdevelopment of the site, inadequate parking, inadequate space standards and no need for more 1 bed units in the area.

 RECEIVED 31/10/2022

N         06993  INSTALLATION OF TWO NEW BATTERY UNITS; REMOVAL OF EXISTING GAS ENGINES: FORMER HOWDEN CLOUGH LANDFILL SITE HOWDEN CLOUGH ROAD (TEALE).

 RECEIVED 07/11/2022

N         07083  CHANGE OF USE TO A FLEXIBLE B2 (GENERAL INDUSTRIAL) AND/OR B8 (STORAGE/DISTRIBUTION) USE: PPG ARCHITECTUAL COATINGS WIDE LANE (TOPCLIFFE).

N         06641  NEW METAL FENCING AND ACCESS GATES TO PROPERTY ENTRANCE: PARK DENE 51 NEW PARK STREET (TEALE).

N         06870  DEMOLITION OF EXISTING SINGLE   WAREHOUSE; ERECTION OF NEW TWO STOREY WAREHOUSE; NEW GATED ACCESS TO SERVICE YARD:

HIGHCLIFFE MILLS HIGHCLIFFE HOUSE BRUNTCLIFFE LANE (TEALE).

 RECEIVED 8/11/2022

N         07318  DEMOLITION OF EXISTING EXTENSION TO SIDE; CONSTRUCTION OF SINGLE STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 9 HASLETT DRIVE (TEALE).

N         07306  ERECTION OF A TEMPORARY ICE RINK AND ASSOCIATED FACILITIES: WHITE ROSE SHOPPING CENTRE DEWSBURY ROAD (CHURWELL).

7. TO NOTE PLANNING APPLICATIONS WITH DECISIONS MADE UNDER DELEGATED AUTHORITY TO TOWN CLERK – STANDING ORDER 15(c) (APPLICATIONS RECEIVED THAT DID NOT APPEAR ON 27/9/2022 AGENDA)

RECEIVED 26/9/22

N         06329  ERECTION OF NEW OUTBUILDING FORMING HABITABLE ROOMS: 10 THE GALLOPS (WOODKIRK).

N         06214  INSTALLATION OF ONE NEW CCTV CAMERA: HSBC BANK PLC BANK CHAMBERS QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

N         06037  OUTBUILDING TO REAR: PARK HOUSE ELLAND ROAD (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 27/9/22

NC       06040  EXTERNAL GARDEN POD TO BE USED AS A BEAUTY BUSINESS: 5 SPRINGWOOD COURT (ELMFIELD).

MTC has no objection in principle to this application, however, members request a condition to be placed on the application for all vehicle parking to be on site.

O         05336  DEMOLITION OF EXISTING BUILDINGS AND CONSTRUCTION OF 9 DWELLING HOUSES ND ASSOCIATED EXTERNAL WORKS:

MORLEY BUDGET CARS HUNGER HILL (CENTRAL).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of over development of the site, negative impact on a conservation area and inadequate parking.

N         TR/06572  T1 SYCAMORE – REDUCE CANOPY BY 2M ALL AROUND AND CROWN LIFT TO A HEIGHT OF 5 M. THIS BY 25%: LIME HOUSE BRADSTOCK GARDENS (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 28/9/22

N         TR/06569  T2 ROWAN – REDUCE HEIGHT BY 1.5M AND SIDES BY 1M, T3 PISSARD PLUM – REDUCE HEIGHT BY 1.5M, T4 SILVER BIRCH – REMOVE DEAADWOOD AND REDUCE IN HEIGHT BY 3M, T5 APPLE – CANOPY LL ON ONE SIDE, REDUCE BY 1M, T6 HUNGARIAN OAK – SUPPRESSING SEVERAL OTHER TREES, REMOVE LOWEST LIMB BACK TO TRUNK,REDUCE CANOPY BY 3M, T8 SYCAMORE – REDUCE BRANCHES GARDEN SIDE BY 2M, THIN CANOPY BY 30%, T10 SYCAMORE – THIN BY 30% : 25 GLADSTONE TERRACE (TEALE).

RECEIVED 29/9/22

N         06215  LISTED BUILDING CONSENT FOR INSTALLATION OF ONE NEW CCTV CAMERA: HSBC BANK PLC BANK CHAMBERS QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 3/10/22

N         TR/06580  WEEPING WILLOW – A WINTER POLLARD HAS BEEN REQUESTED WHICH WOULD REDUCE THE CANOPY BY 2-3M ALL AROUND. LOCATED AT END OF GARDEN:47 NEW PARK STREEY (TEALE).

RECEIVED 10/10/22

N         06595  RETROSPECTIVE APPLICATION FOR ENLARGEMENT OF EXTRACTOR FLU; INSTALLATION OF ROLLER SHUTTER TO SHOP FRONT; CONSTRUCTION OF OUTBUILDING TO REAR: 16 SOUTH QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

N         06655  LOFT CONVERSION TO FORM HABITABLE ROOM WITH REAR DORMER WINDOW; NEW GROUND FLOOR DOOR TO SIDE: 28 REEDLING DRIVE (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 12/10/22

N         06765  DEMOLITION OF EXISTING REAR EXTENSION; SINGLE STOREY SIDE REAR EXTENSION; ALTERATION OF GROUND FLOOR WINDOW TO SIDE:

78 MANOR FARM DRIVE (CHURWELL).

N         06764  DEMOLITION OF EXISTING REAR CONSERVATORY; TWO STOREY SIDE EXTENSION; SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 6 IBBETSON DRIVE (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 17/10/22

N         06787  DEMOLITION OF SINGLE STOREY GARAGE TO SIDE; SINGLE AND TWO STOREY REAR EXTENSION; ROOFLIGHTS TO SIDE AND REAR; RE-ROOFING; CANOPY TO FRONT; INTERNAL ALTERATIONS AND ASSOCIATED LANDSCAPING WORKS INCLUDING RETAINING WALL: THE HOLLIES SCOTCHMAN LANE (ELMFIELD).

N         06825  FIRST FLOOR SIDE EXTENSION; SINGLE STOREY SIDE EXTENSION TO FORM GARAGE; ALTERATIONS INCLUDING NEW WINDOW TO REAR: 22 SCATCHERD LANE (TEALE).

N         TR/06512  A1 SYCAMORE, ELM AND LIME – TO CROWN LIFT ALL THE LARGER TREES TO BE A MINIMUM OF 5.5 METRES ABOVE THE HIGHWAY (THERE IS NO FOOTPATH ON THE SIDE WHGERE THE TREES STAND) AND THAT ALL TREES WILL BE DRAWN BACK TO SUITABLE GROWTH PATHS. OVERHANGING ONTO BRADSTOCK GARDENS THEY NEED TO BE LOPPED OR CUT BACK AS THE OVERHANG IS CAUSING ISSUES FOR LARGER VEHICLES GETTING DOWN THE ROAD: 2-18 CHESTNUT GARDENS (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 18/10/22

N         04313  SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 16 BRADFIELD AVENUE (TEALE).

RECEIVED 19/10/22

N         06914  TWO STOREY SIDE, SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION; CONVERSION OF LOFT AREA TO FORM TWO HABITABLE ROOMS: 41 DEANSWAY (SCATCHERD).

The above decisions made under Town Clerk’s delegated authority, were noted.

 TO RECEIVE ITEMS OF CORRESPONDENCE (items for information only)a) Letter dated 26/9/22 from Jonathan Carr, Head of Development Management, a) a)LCC re. appeal against refusal of planning application 22/04520/FU, Premier 27 Gillroyd Terrace Wide Lane (Topcliffe).

8. b) Email dated 4/11/22 from Julia Marshall, WHP Telecoms Ltd re. Pre Planning Consultation LDS23587.
9. c) Email dated 9/11/22 from Suzi Help, WHP Telecoms Ltd re. Pre Planning Consultation Cornerstone 10939732.

 The above items of correspondence were noted.

9. DATE AND TIME OF NEXT MEETING

The next scheduled meeting will be held on Tuesday, 17^th January 2023 at 7.00 pm.

 

MINUTES OF PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING NO. 422

HELD ON TUESDAY, 27TH SEPTEMBER 2022

1.         TO RECORD ATTENDANCE

Present:  Cllrs R Finnigan (Deputy Chair), M Storey and A Dalton.

2.         TO RECEIVE APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE GIVEN IN ADVANCE OF THE MEETING
Apologies were received from Cllrs C Bell, R Bell and C Taylor.
3.         TO CONSIDER THE APPROVAL OF REASONS GIVEN FOR ABSENCE
The reasons for absence were considered and approved.

4.         DECLARATIONS OF DISCLOSABLE PECUNIARY AND OTHER INTERESTS

Cllr R Finnigan declared an ‘other’ interest as a Leeds City Councillor and an ‘other’ interest re. planning application 5022 – Former Allotments off Bruntcliffe Road as he was involved in the discussions re. the allotments.

5.         TO APPROVE MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON 19/7/22

The Minutes of the meeting held on 19/7/2022 were agreed as a true and correct record.

6.         CONSIDERATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS

Notation of Recommendations.
O = Objection
N = No Objection
NC = No Objection (with comments)
D = Deferred
RECEIVED 7/9/22

N         05818  PART SINGLE STOREY, PART TWO STOREY SIDE ELEVATION; INCORPORATING GARAGE TO THE SIDE: 132 DEWSBURY ROAD (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 15/9/22

N         05197  SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 11 ARTHINGTON CLOSE TINGLEY (WOODKIRK).

NC       06145  TWO STOREY EXTENSION TO REAR: 9 KESTREL GARTH (TOPCLIFFE).

MTC has no objection in principle to this application, however, members would like a condition that the new brickwork should match with the majority of the original brickwork.

RECEIVED 20/922

N         05975  SINGLE STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 8 GRANGE PARK COURT (CHURWELL).

NC       06224  SINGLE STOREY SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION: 28 HARWILL RISE (CHURWELL).

MTC has no objection in principle to this application, however, members would like a condition that the curb should be dropped along the entire front of the property/driveway.

O         05221  OUTLINE APPLICATION TO CONSTRUCT INDUSTRIAL UNIT AND ASSOCIATED EXTERNAL WORKS (ACCESS, LAYOUT AND SCALE IS SOUGHT, RESERVING LANDSCAPING AND EXTERNAL APPEARANCE): LAND OFF TOPCLIFFE LANE (TOPCLIFFE).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of highways safety concerns, the significant impact on residential amenity and as this is an agrarian site this is inappropriate use of a greenfield site.

RECEIVED 21/9/22

N         06258 DEMOLITION OF EXISTING CONSERVATORY; SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION:

18 OAK ROAD (TEALE).

The above planning applications were considered by all members of the Planning Committee present.

It was agreed that any comments be submitted via ‘Public Access’.

7.         TO NOTE PLANNING APPLICATIONS WITH DECISIONS MADE UNDER DELEGATED AUTHORITY TO TOWN CLERK – STANDING ORDER 15(c) (APPLICATIONS RECEIVED THAT DID NOT APPEAR ON 19/7/2022 AGENDA)

RECEIVED 14/7/22

N         04316  ALTERATIONS INCLUDING SINGLE STOREY SIDE/REAR EXTENSION; GARAGE CONVERSION TO HABITABLE ROOM SPACE WITH SMALLER WINDOW REPLACING GARAGE DOOR TO FRONT; NEW FENCE FROM SIDE/REAR AND EXTENSION OF EXISTING DROPPED CURB: 1 IBBETSON DRIVE (CHURWELL).

N         04291  RETROSPECTIVE APPLICATIONFOR ENCLOSED PERGOLA TO FRONT:                28-30 QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 15/7/22

N         04515  CHANGE OF USE OF HAIR SALON TO A WINBE BAR AND REPLACEMENT SIGNAGE: 127 QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

N         04382  NEW CANOPY TO SIDE:  CITY MILLS PEEL STREET (CENTRAL).

N         04520  INSTALLATION OF 2NO. CONTAINERS TO REAR OF PREMIER SHOP FOR USE AS STORAGE SPACE:  PREMIER 27 GILLROYD TERRACE, WIDE LANE (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 20/7/22

N         TR/04956  T1 CHERRY – REMOVE FAIL BRANCH. T2 WHITE BEAM, T4 LIME, T5 SILVER BIRCH, T15 HORSE CHESTNUT – POLLARD TO PREVIOUS BY HALF. T3 YEW, T7 ROWAN – REMOVE. T6 MYROBALAM, T9 HOLLY, T12 HOLLY – REDUCE HEIGHT 3 METERS. T8 SYCAMORE – REMOVE. T10 SYCAMORE – REMOVE DUE TO CAVITY ON THE MAIN STEM LOTS OF DEAD THROUGHOUT THE CANOPY. T11 SYCAMORE – REMOVE DUE TO BAD PREVIOUS WORK,DEAD THROUGHOUT THE CANOPY- LOTS OF FALLING DEAD BRANCHES. T13 WHITEBEAM – POLLARD TO PREVIOUS AND REMOVE 1X SMALLER STEM TOWARDS THE GARDEN SO THE HOLLY HAS ROOM TO GROW. T14 ASH – POLLARD TO PREVIOUS AND REMOVE DED WOOD. COULD BE PROBLEMATIC IN THE FUTURE: 49 EAST PARK STREET (TEALE).

RECEIVED 25/7/22

N         04744  SINGLE SIDE STOREY EXTENSION:  92 DENSHAW GROVE (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 28/7/22

N         02635  CONVERSION OF GARAGE TO HABITABLE ROOM SPACE WITH WINDOWS REPLACING THE GARAGE DOOR TO THE FRONT:  33 ALDEN AVENUE (ELMFIELD).

O         04889  SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION:  57 HEPWORTH AVENUE (CHURWELL).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of the impact on the street scene.

RECEIVED 29/7/22

N         04883  TWO STOREY AND SINGLE STOREY SIDE/REAR EXTENSION INCLUDING CANOPY TO FRONT ELEVATION:  8 SUNNYSIDE DEWSBURY ROAD (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 1/8/22

N         04645  SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION:  6 THE OAKS (CHURWELL).

N         04795  DEMOLITION OF EXISTING PORCH TO REAR OF BUILDING TO ACCOMMODATE NEW SINGLE STOREY EXTENSION:  14 CROFT HOUSE CLOSE (SCATCHERD).

N         04401  RETROSPECTIVE APPLICATION FOR GARDEN SHED TO REAR:  10 TOPCLIFFE MEWS (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 2/8/22

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of concerns regarding Highways access and over development of the site.

RECEIVED 3/8/22

O         04935  PART TWO STOREY SIDE. PART SINGLE STOREY SIDE/REAR EXTENSION; NEW VEHICULAR ACCESS:  3 PERRY MEWS (TEALE).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of concerns regarding inadequate parking, the impact on the street scene and the overdevelopment of a small site.

RECEIVED 4/8/22

N         04954  FIRST FLOOR EXTENSION; GARAGE TO THE SIDE OF THE PROPERTY: 22 SCATCHERD LANE (TEALE).

RECEIVED 5/8/22

O         05000  REMOVAL OF CONDITION 27 (UNCONTROLLED CROSSING POINT) OF APPROVAL:

LAND ADJACENT TO WHITE ROSE OFFICE PARK (CHURWELL).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of road safety due to leaving an uncontrolled crossing instead of replacing it with a controlled crossing.

RECEIVED 9/8/22

N         05046  VARIATION OF CONDITIONS 2 AND 3 (APPROVED PLANS AND CYCLE PARKING FACILITIES) OF APPROVAL 22/03139/FU TO ALLOW FOR AMENDMENTS TO THE BASEMENT SHOWER FACILITIES AND DRAWINGS:  3 WHITE ROSE OFFICE PARK (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 11/8/22

NC       05022  OUTLINE FOR 51 DWELLINGS (ACCESS, LAYOUT & LANDSCAPING)

FORMER ALLOTMENTS OFF BRUNTCLIFFE ROAD (TEALE).

MTC no comment as has been involved with the negotiations for the new allotment site.

RECEIVED 15/08/2022

N         05110  ALTERATIONS INCLUDING A SINGLE STOREY EXTENSION TO SIDE AND REAR INCLUDING RAMPED ACCESS AND LEVEL ACCESS PLATFORM: 36 DENSHAW GROVE (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 16/08/2022

N         05176  PART SINGLE PART TWO STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 98 ALBERT ROAD (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 17/08/2022

N         04941  ALTERATIONS TO FORM NEW SHOP FRONT: 129 DFS FURNITURE ONLINE LTD: QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

N         05309  SINGLE STOREY SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION; DETACHED GARAGE TO FRONT: THE BROW BAGHILL ROAD (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 22/08/2022

N         05177  ONE NEW DETACHED GARAGE OUTBUILDING AND ONE NEW DETACHED OUTBUILDING TO THE REAR OF THE PROPERTY FORMING GYM/STUDIO AND PLAYROOM; DEMOLITION OF EXISTING STABLES OUTBUILDING TO REAR; RAISED TERRACE TO FRONT OF PROPERTY: THE TOWERS BRIDLEWAY (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 23/08/2022

N         05359  DEMOLITION OF EXISTING SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION; CONSTRUCTION OF SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 11 ST MARYS CLOSE (WOODKIRK).

N         05029  CHANGE OF USE APPLICATION FROM A RESIDENTIAL DWELLING (USE CLASS C3) TO A SPECIALIST CHILDRENS CARE FACILITY (USE CLASS 2):                       58A BRIDGE STREET (ELMFIELD).

RECEIVED 24/08/2022

N         04510  RETROSPECTIVE APPLICATION FOR ALTERATIONS AND PITCHED ROOF TO EXISTING CONSERVATORY: 3 ARKWRIGHT WALK (SCATCHERD).

N         05483  FIRST FLOOR EXTENSION TO FRONT: 27 HARWILL APPROACH (CHURWELL).

N         05530  PART SINGLE STOREY PART TWO STOREY SIDE EXTENSION AND REAR EXTENSION; HIP TO GABLE EXTENSION INCORPORATING DORMER TO REAR: 17 SUNNYSIDE AVENUE (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 30/08/2022

O         05544  OUTLINE PLANNING APPLICATION FOR THREE DWELLING HOUSES: LAND ADJACENT TO CRNK COTTAGE STATION ROAD (CENTRAL).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of highways grounds due to access to the site being off Albert Road.

N         TR/05936 T1-T7 SYCAMORE – FELL. THESE TRES ARE ON A STONE RETAINING WALL, IMPACTING ON THE WALL AND ALSO OVERHANGING NEIGHBOURING GARAGE ROOFS. T8 – ASPEN – FELL AS TREE IS DEAD. T9 SYCAMORE – FELL AS TREE IS DYING. T10,T11 & T12 PUSSY WILLOW – FELL, AS TREES ARE DEAD. T13 & T14 ASPEN – FELL AS TREES ARE DYING: QUARRY LANE (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 31/08/2022

N         05553  SINGLE STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 29 SHIRE ROAD (ELMFIELD).

N         05596  ALTERATIONS INCLUDING LOWERING OF EXISTING SINGLE STOREY FRONT EXTENSION ROOF AND REMOVAL OF WINDOW; NEW DORMER WINDOW AND NEW ROOFLIGHTS TO FRONT; NEW/REPLACEMENT WINDOWS AND DOORS; DEMOLITION OF EXISTING SINGLE PART TWO STOREY SIDE EXTENSION:161 SCOTCHMAN LANE (ELMFIELD).

N         05293  INSTALLATION OF SOLAR PANELS TO CAR PORT :SEVEN HILLS PRIMARY SCHOOL APPLEBY WAY (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 06/09/2022

N         05692  RETROSPECTIVE APPLICTION FOR INSTALLATION OF AN EXTRACTOR FLUE TO HOT FOOD TAKE AWAY: 34 CHAPEL HILL (SCATCHERD)

O         05742  FIRST FLOOR SIDE EXTENSION; SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION ; ALTERATIONS TO WINDOWS: 37 GRANGE PARK ROAD (CHURWELL).                                MTC objects to this application on the grounds of insufficient parking as there is no room for 2 parking spaces

RECEIVED 07/09/2022

N         06136/TR  T1 SYCAMORE FELL. TOO BIG FOR LOCATION AND IS IN CLOSE PROXIMITY TO THE HOUSE AND STONE BOUNDARY WALL. REPLACE WITH A NEW TREE AWAY FROM THE BUNGALOW AND WALL. G1 SYCAMORE TO N/E END OF GROUP – FELL AS TREE HAS A SPLIT TRUNK AND WAS ALSO IDENTIFIED IN THE PAST AS BEING TOO BIG FOR IT’S LOCATION. AGAIN CLOSE PROXIMITY TO HOUSE, NEIGHBOURING HOUSES AND STONE BOUNDARY WALL. AGAIN REPLACE WITH TREE NOT TOO CLOSE TO HOUSE AND WALL: OAKDENE ST ANDREWS AVENUE (TEALE).

The above decisions made under Town Clerk’s delegated authority, were noted.

8.         TO RECEIVE ITEMS OF CORRESPONDENCE (items for information only)

a)         Email dated 27/5/22 from Martin Elliot, Head of Strategic Planning, LCC re. Leeds Local Plan Update Placemaking – 20min Neighbourhoods Research.  Research period 27/5/22 to 17/6/22.

b)         Letter dated 9/6/22 from Jonathan Carr, Head of Development Management, LCC re. appeal notice, planning number 22/01717/FU, 116 Fountain Street (Teale).

c)         Letter dated 27/6/22 from Jonathan Carr, Head of Development Management, LCC re. appeal notice, planning number 22/01692/ADV, 3 High Street (Central).

The above items of correspondence were noted.

9.         DATE AND TIME OF NEXT MEETING

The next scheduled meeting will be held on Tuesday, 15th November 2022 at 7.00 pm.

 

MINUTES OF PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING NO. 421

HELD ON TUESDAY, 19TH JULY 2022

1.         TO RECORD ATTENDANCE

Present:  Cllrs H Evans (Chairman), C Bell, R Bell, C Taylor, M Storey and Cllr R Finnigan who minuted the meeting.

2.         TO RECEIVE APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE GIVEN IN ADVANCE OF THE MEETING
Apologies were received from Cllr A Dalton.
3.         TO CONSIDER THE APPROVAL OF REASONS GIVEN FOR ABSENCE
The reasons for absence were considered and approved.

 

4.        DECLARATIONS OF DISCLOSABLE PECUNIARY AND OTHER INTERESTS

Cllr R Finnigan declared an ‘other’ interest as a Leeds City Councillor.

5.         TO APPROVE MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON 17/5/22

The Minutes of the meeting held on 17/5/2022 were agreed as a true and correct record.

6.         CONSIDERATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS

Notation of Recommendations.
O = Objection
N = No Objection
NC = No Objection (with comments)
D = Deferred
RECEIVED 4/7/22

N         04038  FOUR STORAGE CONTAINERS TO CAR PARK: FOUNTAIN COURT,

BRUNTCLIFFE WAY (TEALE).

O         04276  TWO STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 1 HARLINGTON COURT (ELMFIELD). MTC objects to this application on the grounds of lack of provision of 2 car parking spaces within the property’s redline area.

RECEIVED 7/7/22

N         04177  RETROSPECTIVE APPLICATION FOR SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION:

14 WEST LEA CRESCENT (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 8/7/22

N         04380  SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION WITH PITCHED ROOF: DELMUIR, DEWSBURY ROAD (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 13/7/22

N         03825  ALTERATIONS INCLUDING WIDENING OF ENTRANCE INTO SITE WITH NEW FENCE AND GATE; NEW HARD STANDING AREAS, WIDEN EXISTING FOOTPATH WITH NEW EXTERNAL STEPS: BRUNTCLIFFE ACADEMY, BRUNTCLIFFE LANE (TEALE).

The above planning applications were considered by all members of the Planning Committee present.

It was agreed that any comments be submitted via ‘Public Access’.

7.  TO NOTE PLANNING APPLICATIONS WITH DECISIONS MADE UNDER DELEGATED AUTHORITY TO TOWN CLERK – STANDING ORDER 15(c) (APPLICATIONS RECEIVED THAT DID NOT APPEAR ON 17/5/2022 AGENDA)

RECEIVED 13/5/22

N         03139  SINGLE STOREY EXTENSION TO UPPER GROUND FLOOR WITH ROOF TERRACE ABOVE AND NEW CYCLE FACILITIES TO EXISTING BASEMENT: 3 WHITE ROSE OFFICE PARK, MILLSHAW PARK LANE (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 17/5/22

N         02690  SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 21 FINCHLEY WAY (ELMFIELD).

RECEIVED 18/5/22

N         03268  FIRST FLOOR EXTENSION TO THE REAR; ALTERATIONS TO WINDOWS: 139 SPRINGFIELD ROAD (SCATCHERD).

N         02999 COVERED CANOPY TO SIDE AND REAR: LITTLE BUTTONS NURSERY ELLAND ROAD (CHURWELL).

N         03273  CHANGE OF USE FROM OFFICE (CLASS E) TO DRINKING/RESTAURANT ESTABLISHMENT (SUI GENERIS): 25-27 QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

N         02826  SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 19 OAK GROVE (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 19/5/22

N         03206  ALTERATIONS TO EXISTING CLUBHOUSE INCLUDING NEW RAMP ACCESS TO FRONT AND NEW STAIRS AND REAR ACCESS, WITH INSTALLATION OF CRICKET NETS: MORLEY CRICKET AND SPORTS CLUB: SCATCHERD LANE (TEALE).

RECEIVED 20/5/22

N         02955  SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 8 RYDAL CRESCENT (TOPCLIFFE).

O         03372  NEW DETACHED DWELLING WITH GARAGE: LAND ADJACENT TO HIGHFIELD HOUSE, BRUNSWICK STREET (TEALE).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of concerns regarding Highways safety, inappropriate development and over development of the site.

RECEIVED 23/5/22

N         03374  SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 58 IBBETSON OVAL (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 26/5/22

N         03622/TR  A – HOLLY – CROWN LIFT TO 3 METRE FROM FLOOR LEVEL; CLEAR DEAD BRANCHES AND LEAVES: B – BEECH – CROWN THINNING TO 30%; CROWN REDUCTION 3 METRE HEIGHT AND 1.5 METRE RADIUS: C1 – SYCAMORE – CROWN THINNING 30%; CROWN REDUCTION 3 METRE HEIGHT AND 1 METRE RADIUS: C2 – SYCAMORE – CROWN THINNING 30%; CROWN REDUCTION 3 METRE HEIGHT AND 1 METRE RADIUS:

3 BEACON LODGE, TEXAS STREET (TOPCLIFFE).

N         03510  DETACHED GARDEN ROOM TO REAR: MEADOWCROFT, 3 MANOR GRANGE (WOODKIRK).

N         03371  NEW TWO STOREY BUILDING FORMING SEVEN B2/B3 INDUSTRIAL UNITS; DEMOLITION OF EXISTING STRUCTURES: PPG ARCHITECTURAL COATINGS, WIDE LANE (TOPCLIFFE).

N         03444  ALTERATIONS INCLUDING HIP TO GABLE ROOF EXTENSION AND TWO STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 21 HARWILL AVENUE (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 31/5/22

N         02822  ALTERATIONS INCLUDING RAISED RIDGE HEIGHT INCORPORATING LOFT CONVERSION TO FORM NEW FIRST FLOOR; PART SINGLE STOREY PART THREE STOREY REAR EXTENSION WITH FEATURE GLAZING; EXTENDED ACCESS DRIVE AND PARKING SPACES WITH ASSOCIATED LANDSCAPING: THE HOLLIES, SCOTCHMAN LANE (TEALE).

N         03453  SINGLE STOREY REAR, SIDE AND FRONT EXTENSIONS:  11 THE ROUNDWAY (TEALE).

N         03161  INSTALLATION OF COMPOSITE DECKING AREA WITH RAISED STEPS, GLASS SCREEN AND TWO NEW FENCE PANELS TO REAR: 17 WEST LEA DRIVE (TINGLEY).

RECEIVED 6/6/22

N         03592  ALTERATIONS INCLUDING NEW FIRST FLOOR INCORPORATING RAISED RIDGE HEIGHT, DORMER WINDOW AND ROOFLIGHTS TO SIDES; SINGLE STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 10 KING GEORGE AVENUE (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 8/6/22

N         03997/TR  T1 SYCAMORE – TO REMOVE TO GROUND LEVEL AS CAUSING EXTENSIVE DAMAGE TO DRIVE AND OUTGROWN SITUATION: ASHGARTH, BRUNTCLIFFE ROAD (ELMFIELD).

RECEIVED 13/6/22

N         03492  TWO STOREY SIDE EXTENSION AND ALTERATIONS TO EXISTING CONSERVATORY TO REAR: 69 IBBETSON OVAL (CHURWELL).

N         03493  SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 71 WOODCROSS FOLD (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 15/6/22

N         03785  RESERVED MATTERS APPLICATION FOR LAYOUT, ACCESS, SCALE, APPEARANCE AND LANDSCAPING TO APPLICATION 20/08071/OT: LAND TO REAR OF

1-3 SPRINGFIELD CRESCENT (SCATCHERD)

RECEIVED 23/6/22

N         04078  SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 5 MILLSIDE WALK (TOPCLIFFE)

RECEIVED 24/6/22

N         04012  RECONFIGURATION OF MEZZANINE FLOORSPACE: UNITS MSU3,

18 & 20 WHITE ROSE SHOPPING CENTRE, DEWSBURY ROAD (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 28/6/22

N         04176  PORCH TO FRONT, FIRST FLOOR SIDE EXTENSION AND ALTERATIONS TO CONSERVATORY AT REAR:  4 FARM HILL ROAD (SCATCHERD).

N         03871  TWO STOREY SIDE EXTENSION; DEMOLITION OF EXISTING OUTHOUSES:

24 DEANSWAY (SCATCHERD).

The above decisions made under Town Clerk’s delegated authority, were noted.

8.         TO RECEIVE ITEMS OF CORRESPONDENCE (items for information only)

a)         Email dated 27/5/22 from Martin Elliot, Head of Strategic Planning, LCC re. Leeds Local Plan Update Placemaking – 20min Neighbourhoods Research.  Research period 27/5/22 to 17/6/22.

b)         Letter dated 9/6/22 from Jonathan Carr, Head of Development Management, LCC re. appeal notice, planning number 22/01717/FU, 116 Fountain Street (Teale).

c)         Letter dated 27/6/22 from Jonathan Carr, Head of Development Management, LCC re. appeal notice, planning number 22/01692/ADV, 3 High Street (Central).

The above items of correspondence were noted.

9.         DATE AND TIME OF NEXT MEETING

The next scheduled meeting will be held on Tuesday, 20th September 2022 at 7.00 pm.

 

MINUTES OF PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING NO. 420

HELD ON TUESDAY, 17TH MAY 2022

 

 

1.         TO RECORD ATTENDANCE

Present:  Cllrs H Evans (Chairman), C Bell, R Bell and M Storey.

W Maynard-Light (Deputy Town Clerk) also attended.

 

2.         TO RECEIVE APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE GIVEN IN ADVANCE OF THE MEETING
Apologies were received from Cllrs R Finnigan and A Dalton.
3.         TO CONSIDER THE APPROVAL OF REASONS GIVEN FOR ABSENCE
The reasons for absence were considered and approved.

 

4.         DECLARATIONS OF DISCLOSABLE PECUNIARY AND OTHER INTERESTS

There were no interests declared.

 

5.         TO APPROVE MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON 15/3/22

The Minutes of the meeting held on 15/3/2022 were agreed as a true and correct record.

 

6.         CONSIDERATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS

Notation of Recommendations.
O = Objection
N = No Objection
NC = No Objection (with comments)
D = Deferred
RECEIVED 28/4/22

 

N         02629  LISTED BUILDING APPLICATION FOR REPLACEMENT OF EXTERNAL AUTOMATED TELLER MACHINE (ATM), REPLACEMENT OF EXISTING EXTERNAL ATM HEADER SIGN, REPLACEMENT OF TWO EXISTING INTERNAL SELF-SERVICE MACHINES AND REMOVAL OF TWO EXISTING INTERNAL SELF-SERVICE MACHINES WITH ASSOCIATED WORKS: HSBC BANK PLC, BANK CHAMBERS, QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

 

RECEIVED 3/5/22

 

N         02734  REPLACEMENT OF EXISTING LIGHT INDUSTRIAL UNIT INCLUDING ADDITIONAL MEZZANINE LEVEL: ASCENDI FURNITURE, VICTORIA BUILDINGS, BANK AVENUE (SCATCHERD.

 

RECEIVED 5/5/22

 

N         02851  UPGRADE TO EXISTING ROOFTOP TELECOMMUNICATIONS INSTALLATION: LEEDS HIGH POINT HOUSE, QUEEN STREET, HIGH POINT ESTATED LTD, HIGH POINT HOUSE, 88 QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

 

RECEIVED 10/5/22

 

N         02871  CHANGE OF USE OF OFFICE (CLASS E) TO FORM DWELLING (CLASS C); ASSOCIATED ALTERATIONS INCLUDING ALTERATIONS TO FENESTRATION:

24 KING STREET (CENTRAL).

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

RECEIVED 11/5/22

 

N         03021  ONE DETACHED GARAGE OUTBUILDING AND ONE TWO-STOREY STUDIO/OFFICE OUTBUILDING TO THE REAR OF PROPERTY, DEMOLITION OF EXISTING STABLES OUTBUILDING; RAISED TERRACE TO FRONT OF PROPERTY: THE TOWERS, BRIDLEWAY (CHURWELL).

 

N         02774  PART SINGLE, PART TWO STOREY SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION’ ALTERATIONS TO SIDE FENESTRATION; NEW RENDER FINISH TO FRONT AND SIDE OF EXISTING HOUSE: 55 THE ROUNDWAY (TEALE).

 

The above planning applications were considered by all members of the Planning Committee present.

The paperwork for application 22/01243 was unavailable, therefore, members agreed to defer this application to the next agenda and be considered under Delegated Authority.

 

7.         TO NOTE PLANNING APPLICATIONS WITH DECISIONS MADE UNDER DELEGATED AUTHORITY TO TOWN CLERK – STANDING ORDER 15(c) (APPLICATIONS RECEIVED THAT DID NOT APPEAR ON 15/3/2022 AGENDA)

 

RECEIVED 8/3/22

 

N         01243  SINGLE STOREY SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION WITH RAMP AND RAISED PLATFORM TO REAR: 36 DENSHAW GROVE (TOPCLIFFE).

 

RECEIVED 14/3/22

 

O         01656  ALTERATIONS INCLUDING RAISED ROOF HEIGHT; SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION; DORMER WINDOW TO SIDE: 10 KING GEORGE AVENUE (SCATCHERD).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of overdevelopment of the site and the impact on the street scene.

 

RECEIVED 15/3/22

 

N         01712  SINGLE STOREY EXTENSION TO REAR: 55 DIGPAL ROAD (CHURWELL).

 

RECEIVED 16/3/22

 

N         01692  48-SHEET PAPER PASTE ADVERTISING DISPLAY:  3 HIGH STREET (CENTRAL).

 

NC       00228  CONVERSION OF SINGLE DWELLING TO TWO DWELLINGS: 56 ZOAR STREET (CENTRAL).

MTC has no objection to this application in principle, however, members would like a condition placed on the application that all cars are parked on the large hardstanding to the rear.

 

N         00964  SINGLE STOREY SIDE/REAR EXTENSION; RAISED PLATFORM AND STEPS WITH HANDRAIL TO REAR: 5 RYDAL DRIVE (TOPCLIFFE).

 

N         01717  DORMER WINDOW TO FRONT: 116 FOUNTAIN STREET (TEALE).

 

N         01444  EXTENSION ONTO SIDE OF EXISTING GARAGE: BEACON LODGE, TEXAS STREET

(TOPCLIFFE).

 

RECEIVED 17/3/22

 

N         01955/TR  T1 SYCAMORE – REMOVE THE FOUR LOWEST SMALL BRANCHES; T2 LIME – REDUCE THE SECOND LOWEST BRANCH OVER THE GARDEN BY 50%; T5 ELM – REMOVE THE TWO LOW BRANCHES OVER THE GARDEN: 51 ROOMS LANE (SCATCHERD).

 

 

 

 

 

RECEIVED 18/3/22

 

N         01761  DEMOLITION OF EXISTING CONVERVATORY; CONSTRUCTION OF NEW SINGLE STOREY EXTENSION TO REAR AND SIDE: 2 IBBETSON OVAL (CHURWELL).

 

RECEIVED 22/3/22

 

N         01718  SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 10 WILLIAM STREET (CHURWELL).

 

N         01838  ALTERATIONS INCLUDING NEW FIRST FLOOR INCORPORATING DORMER WINDOWS TO FRONT AND REAR; SINGLE STOREY EXTENSION WITH ROOFLIGHTS TO REAR; NEW WINDOW AT FIRST FLOOR TO SIDE: 32 WEST LEA CRESCENT (WOODKIRK).

 

N         01640  CHANGE OF USE OF WAREHOUSE TO MARTIAL ARTS CLUB: 5 OAK MILLS, TOPCLIFFE LANE (TOPCLIFFE).

 

RECEIVED 28/3/22

 

O         01504  OUTLINE PLANNING APPLICATION FOR THREE DWELLING HOUSES: LAND ADJACENT TO CRANK COTTAGE STATION ROAD (SCATCHERD).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of Highways safety, access onto Albert Road has poor sight lines.

 

RECEIVED 29/3/22

 

N         01943  PROVISION OF LENGTH OF SURFACE FOOTPATH INCLUDING EXCAVATION AND RE-GRADING TO ACHIEVE A SUITABLE GRADIENT AND ASSOCIATED LANDSCAPING: LAND WEST OF HOWLEY MILL LANE (ELMFIELD).

 

RECEIVED 30/3/22

 

N         02294/TR  T1 – REMOVE LOWEST 4 BRANCHES; T2 – REMOVE SMALL, LOW BRANCH OVER NEIGHBOURING GARDEN: THE SYCAMORES, ROOMS LANE (SCATCHERD).

 

N         01878  DETACHED GARAGE TO THE REAR; PORCH TO THE FRONT; WINDOW REPLACING REAR ACCESS DOOR; EXTERNAL STORAGE SHEDS; PERGOLA TO THE REAR: OAKLANDS, BRIDLEWAY (CHURWELL).

 

RECEIVED 4/4/22

 

N         01471  ALTERATIONS AND CHANGE OF USE OF RETAIL SHOP TO FORM ENLARGED DWELLING HOUSE INCORPORATING TWO STOREY EXTENSION, DETACHED DOUBLE GARAGE TO SIDE AND NEW PEDESTRIAN AND VEHICLE ACCESS TO FRONT:

19 SYKE ROAD (WOODKIRK).

 

N         02181  ALTERATIONS TO FAÇADE INCLUDING REDUCTION OF EXTERNAL WALL HEIGHT:

UNIT 10 MILLSHAW PARK AVENUE (CHURWELL).

 

N         02083  DORMER WINDOW TO REAR; SINGLE STOREY EXTENSION TO REAR:

20 CROFT HOUSE AVENUE (SCATCHERD).

 

N         01686  EXTENSION TO SIDE TO CREATE ADDITIONAL STORAGE AND LOADING FACILITIES WITH ASSOCIATED SERVICE/TRANSPORT YARD: HOWLEY PARK ROAD EAST (ELMFIELD).

 

RECEIVED 8/4/22

 

N         02306  ALTERATIONS TO TWO EXISTING BUILDINGS TO FORM SEVEN FLATS; SINGLE STORY SIDE EXTENSION; SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENTION: 65-69 HIGH STREET (ELMFIELD).

 

 

 

 

RECEIVED 12/4/22

 

N         02490  SINGLE STOREY SIDE EXTENSION; ALTERATIONS TO FIRST FLOOR SIDE FENESTRATION; DEMOLITION OF EXISTING GARAGE: 50 ROOM LANE (SCATCHERD).

 

RECEIVED 13/4/22

 

O         02424  RAISED RIDGE HEIGHT TO ROOF; TWO DORMER WINDOWS TO FRONT; DORMER WINDOW TO REAR; SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION WITH GLASS ROOF LANTERN:

40 McLAREN PLACE (TEALE).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of the impact on the street scene.

 

O         02460  VARIATION OF CONDITION NO. 13 (DELIVERY HOURS) TO PREVIOUSLY APPROVED PLANNING APPLICATION 20/00019/FU FOR ALTERATIONS TO THE DELIVERY TIMES MONDAY TO SUNDAY AND REMOVE BANK HOLIDAY RESTRICTIONS: CHARTISTS WAY (ELMFIELD).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of the impact on the residential amenity due to the noise impact.

 

RECEIVED 19/4/22

 

N         02513  SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 17 TURNBERRY GARDENS (WOODKIRK).

 

RECEIVED 20/4/22

 

N         02470  REMOVAL OF CONDITION 4 (PERMITTED DEVELOPMENT RIGHTS) TO PREVIOUSLY APPROVED PLANNING APPLICATION 10/00682/FU: 161 SCOTCHMAN LANE

(ELMFIELD).

 

RECEIVED 22/4/22

 

N         01691  STOCKPILING AND PROCESSING OF MATERIALS IN ASSOCIATION WITH LANDFILLING AND EXTRACTION OPERATIONS AT THE ADJACENT QUARRY.  PROCESSING TO INCLUDE SCREENING AND CRUSHING OF MINERAL AND EXCAVATION WASTE FROM THE ADJACENT QUARRY AND RECYCLING OF UP TO 10,000 TONNES PER YEAR OF IMPORTED INERT WASTE:  BOOTH VENTURES LTD, HOWLEY PARK ROAD EAST (ELMFIELD).

 

N         02566  INSTALLATION OF A VARIABLE REFIGERANT FLOW SYSTEM: 1 STERLING COURT (TOPCLIFFE).

 

RECEIVED 25/4/22

 

O         02646  CONVERSION OF GARAGE TO HABITABLE ROOMS: 8 WOODSIDE GARDENS (CHURWELL).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of insufficient off-street parking space for two vehicles.

 

RECEIVED 26/4/22

 

N         02664  SINGLE STOREY SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION: 6 POPLAR CRESCENT (ELMFIELD).

 

N         02630  REPLACEMENT OF AUTOMATED TELLER MACHINE (ATM):  HSBC PLC,

BANK CHAMBERS, QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

 

RECEIVED 27/4/22

 

N         02628  ALTERATIONS TO WAREHOUSE INCLUDING NEW AND REPLACEMENT CLADDING,             REPLACEMENT ROOF AND NEW ROLLER SHUTTERS AND DOORS TO FRONT AND SIDE:              JEWSON LIMITED REAR OF BARFIELD HOUSE, BRITANNIA ROAD (ELMFIELD).

 

 

 

 

RECEIVED 5/5/22

 

N         03115/TR  T1 SORBUS SP – WE WOULD LIKE TO CARRY OUT A 1.24 M CROWN REDUCTION AND A 20% CROWN THIN TO ALLOW CROSSING BRANCHES AND BRANCHES OF POOR FORM TO BE REMOVED.  THE PROPOSED WORKS WILL REDUCE THE LIKELIHOOD OF FUTRE STRUCTURAL FAILYE AND KEEP IT TO A REASONABLE SIZE FOR ITS POSITION.  THIS TREET HAS PREVSIOULSY HAD A LARGE NUMBER OF CENTRAL BRANCHES REMOVED (TOPPED) RESULTING IN A GREATER BRANCH DENSITY ABOVE THIS POINT: 15 ST ANDREWS GROVE (TEALE).

 

RECEIVED 9/5/22

 

N         03014/TR  T1, T2 EUCALYPTUS – 4 METRE REDUCTION IN HEIGHT TO SUITABLE GROWTH POINTS; T3 WILLOW – CROWN LIFT TO 2-3 METRES FROM GROUND LEVEL; T4, T5 OAK – FELL PREVIOUSLY POLLARDED TREES WITH SIGNIFCANT BASAL BARK DAMAGE AND EXPOSED CAMBIUM: ROCKWOOD, SCOTCHMAN LANE (ELMFIELD).

 

The above decisions made under Town Clerk’s delegated authority, were noted.

 

8.         TO RECEIVE ITEMS OF CORRESPONDENCE (items for information only)

a)         Letter dated 26/4/22 from Jonathan Carr, Head of Development Management, LCC re. appeal against refusal of planning application 21/08386/DTM Magpie Lane – determination of telecommunication equipment for 16.0m Phase 8 Monopole C/W wrapround cabinet at base and associated ancillary works (Topcliffe).

 

The above items of correspondence were noted

9.         DATE AND TIME OF NEXT MEETING

The next scheduled meeting will be held on Tuesday, 19th July 2022 at 7.00 pm.

MINUTES OF PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING NO. 419

 HELD ON TUESDAY, 15TH MARCH 2022

1.         TO RECORD ATTENDANCE

Present:  Cllrs H Evans (Chairman), A Dalton and R Finnigan.

R Pickles (Town Clerk) also attended.

2.         TO RECEIVE APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE GIVEN IN ADVANCE OF THE MEETING
Apologies were received from Cllrs R Bell and C Taylor.

3.         TO CONSIDER THE APPROVAL OF REASONS GIVEN FOR ABSENCE
The reasons for absence were considered and approved.

 4.         Declarations of Disclosable Pecuniary and Other Interests

Cllr R Finnigan declared an ‘other’ interest as a Leeds City Councillor.

5.         TO APPROVE MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON 18/1/22

The Minutes of the meeting held on 18/1/2022 were agreed as a true and correct record.

6.         CONSIDERATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS

Notation of Recommendations.
O = Objection
N = No Objection
NC = No Objection (with comments)
D = Deferred
RECEIVED 28/2/22

N         22/00649  LISTED BUILDING APPLICATION FOR INSTALLATION OF ONE OVERHEAD ELECTRIC LINE EQUIPMENT PORTAL ON PIER 3 OF THE VIADUCT WITH ASSOCIATED WALL BRACKETS: RAILWAY VIADUCT MDL 1/40 ELLAND ROAD (CHURWELL)

RECEIVED 1/3/22

N         22/01302  RETENTION OF AN AUTOMATED TELLER MACHINE (ATM): 54 INGLE AVENUE (SCATCHERD)

N         22/00976  SINGLE STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: THE CROFT, DEWSBURY ROAD (WOODKIRK)

RECEIVED 2/3/22

N         22/01259  VARIATION OF CONDITION 22 (SITE RESTORATION) OF APPROVAL 15/05358/FU TO AMEND APPROVED RESTORATION PLANS IN PART OF QUARRY 3 ONLY: HOWLEY PARK QUARRY, QUARRY LANE (WOODKIRK)

RECEIVED 8/3/22

D         22/01243  SINGLE STOREY SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION WITH RAMP AND RAISED PLATFORM TO REAR: 36 DENSHAW GROVE (TOPCLIFFE).

The above planning applications were considered by all members of the Planning Committee present. The paperwork for application 22/01243 was unavailable so members agreed to defer this until the next meeting for decision to be considered under Delegated Authority.

7.         TO NOTE PLANNING APPLICATIONS WITH DECISIONS MADE UNDER DELEGATED AUTHORITY TO TOWN CLERK – STANDING ORDER 15(c) (APPLICATIONS RECEIVED THAT DID NOT APPEAR ON 18/1/2022 AGENDA)

RECEIVED 18/1/22

N         22/00324  SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 2A GRANGE PARK DRIVE (CHURWELL).

O         21/10197  RETROSPECTIVE APPLICATION FOR ALTERATIONS INCLUDING NEW FLAT ROOF WITH ROOF LIGHTS AND PATIO DOORS, EXTERNAL STEPS AND ENTRANCE DOOR TO CELLAR TO REAR: THE OLD BAKERY, BRITANNIA ROAD (ELMFIELD).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of the impact on the residential amenity, impact on lighting and overdevelopment of the site. Members request a site visit and a Plans Panel decision.

N         22/00380/TR  T1 ASH – CROWN LIFT TO 2.5 METRES OVER PLAYGROUND. DRAW BACK FROM BUILDING BY 1 METRE TO GIVE 2 METRE CLEARANCE. CLEAR TELEPHONE WIRES TO GIVE 0.5 METRE CLEARANCE: T2 SYCAMORE – CLEAR TELEPHONE WIRES TO GIVE 0.5 METRE CLEARANCE: T3 LIME – CROWN THIN BY 10% REMOVING EPICORNIC GROWTH AND DEAD WOOD: ALL SAINTS CHURCH, ELLAND ROAD (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 19/1/22

O         22/00060  TWO STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 1 HARLINGTON COURT (ELMFIELD).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of insufficient off-street parking space available.

RECEIVED 20/1/22

N         22/00365  RETROSPECTIVE PLANNING APPLICATION FOR NEW OUTBUILDING TO FRONT OF PROPERTY: 31 REIN ROAD (ELMFIELD).

RECEIVED 25/01/22

N         22/00502/TR  T1 SORBUS – REMOVE: 93 SPRINGFIELD ROAD (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 28/1/22

N         22/00474  TWO STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 11 MIDDLETON TERRACE (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 31/1/22

N         21/09988  RETROSPECTIVE PLANNING APPLICATION FOR CHANGES OF USE FROM PRIVATE HIRE OFFICE TO TYRE REPAIR AND REPLACEMENT SHOP: MORLEY TYRE ZONE, HUNGER HILL (CENTRAL).

N         22/00594  CHANGE OF USE FROM RESTAURANT AND ANCILLARY CIRCULATION SPACE TO A FLEXIBLE FOOD AND DRINK FOR CONSUMPTION ON THE PREMISES AND DRINKING ESTABLISHMENT WITH ANCILLARY STORAGE AREA AT BASEMENT LEVEL: UNIT RU11 WHITE ROSE SHOPPING CENTRE, DEWSBURY ROAD (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 1/2/22

N         21/09883  SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION AND MINOR FAÇADE RE-MODEL WORKS TO ACCOMMODATE NEW DDA COMPLIANT ACCESS LIFT: ALEXANDRA HOME, VICTORIA ROAD (SCATCHERD).

N         21/09289  CONVERSION OF GARAGE TO HABITABLE ROOM, INCLUDING SINGLE STOREY LEAN TO AT REAR: 4 KESTEL GARTH (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 3/2/22

N         22/00688/TR   T5 LIME – CROWN LIFT TO 2.4M. T6 LOMBARDY POPLAR – REMOVE HANGING LIMB, DEADWOOD. T8 SUGAR MAPLE – CROWN LIFT TO 2.4M. T9 COMMON LIME – CROWN LIFT TO 2.4M. T17 COMMON LIME – CROWN LIFT TO 2.4M AND REMOVE DEADWOOD. T18 SMALL LEAVED LIME – CROWN LIFT TO 2.4M. T26 PURPLE SYCAMORE – CROWN LIFT TO 2.4M. T27 COMMON ASH – CROWN LIFT TO 2.4M T31 NORWAY MAPLE – CROWN LIFT TO 2.4M. T32 COMMON ASH – FELL TO GROUND LEVEL. T33 ENGLISH OAK – FELL TO GROUND LEVEL. T46 FIELD MAPLE – REMOVAL BASAL/EPICORMIC GROWTH. T65 FASTIGIATE LIME – YOUNG TREE MAINTENANCE,REMOVE BROKEN BRANCH. T71 LONDON PLANE – CROWN LIFT TO 3M, PRUNE BACK FROM STREET TO CLEAR LAMP BY 0.5-1M. T77 COMMON ASH – CROWN LIFT TO 2.4M. T79 GOAT WILLOW – CROWN LIFT TO 2.4M (PATH SIDE ONLY). T82 GOLDEN SYCAMORE – PRUNE BACK FROM STREET TO CLEAR LAMP BY 0.5-1M. T83 AND T84 PINK JAPANESE CHERRY – CROWN LIFT TO 2.4M (OVER FOOTPATH ONLY). T92 SMALL LEAVED LIME – CROWN LIFT TO 2.4M (OVER FOOTPATH ONLY). T95 CHERRY – PRUNE BACK FROM STREET TO CLEAR LAMP BY 0.5-1M. T100 SMALL LEAVED LIME – PRUNE BACK FROM STREET TO CLEAR LAMP BY 0.5-1M AND REDUCE CROWN BY 2M OR NEAREST BRANCHING POINT TO CLEAR SIGN ONLY. T101 CHERRY – CROWN LIFT TO 2.4M (OVER PATH ONLY): MORLEY LEISURE CENTRE, QUEENSWAY (TEALE).

RECEIVED 7/2/22

N         22/00714/TR  T1 AND T2 SILVER BIRCH – EXTREMELY TALL NOW AND ALL I WISH TO DO IS REDUCE THEM TO THE APPROX HEIGHT OF THE HOUSE WHICH IS CIRCA 5-6M BEFORE THEY GET UNMANAGEABLE. THEY ARE CURRENTLY CIRCA 10/11M:           3 CHESTNUT GARDENS (SCATCHERD).

N         22/00791  DEMOLITION OF DETACHED SINGLE GARAGE; PROPOSED OUTBUILDING AND NEW HARDSTANDING TO REAR: 64 CORPORATION STREET (TEALE).

O         22/00427  CONVERSION OF INTEGRATED GARAGE TO STUDIO/HOME OFFICE WITH NEW WINDOW TO EXTERNAL WALL: 76 ALBERT DRIVE (TOPCLIFFE).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of insufficient off-street parking space available.

RECEIVED 8/2/22

N         22/00823  SINGLE STOREY SIDE/REAR EXTENSION AND CONVERSION OF GARAGE TO HABITABLE ROOM SPACE: 15 TURNBERRY GARDENS (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 14/2/22

O         22/00487  SINGLE STOREY SIDE/FRONT EXTENSION; RAISED STEPS AND TERRACE AREA TO FRONT AND DORMER WINDOWS WITH ROOF LIGHTS TO FRONT AND REAR: THE CHASE, BRADSTOCK GARDENS (SCATCHERD).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of the negative impact the dormers would have on the residential amenity and street scene.

RECEIVED 15/2/22

N         22/00998  ALTERATIONS INCLUDING SINGLE STOREY SIDE EXTENSION:

25 WINTERBOURNE AVENUE (SCATCHERD).

O         21/10179/FU  TWO STOREY SIDE EXTENSION – REVISED PLANS: 29 IBBETSON OVAL (CHURWELL).

MTC objects to these revised plans on the grounds of the impact on the street scene and reduction of neighbours’ residential amenity.

RECEIVED 16/2/22

N         22/00772  ALTERATIONS TO TWO EXISTING DWELLINGS INCLUDING A TWO STOREY REAR EXTENSION; DEMOLITION OF EXISTING GARAGE AND OUTHOUSE AND CONSTRUCTION OF DOUBLE GARAGE TO REAR: 116 AND 118 VICTORIA ROAD (SCATCHERD).

N         22/00996  SINGLE STOREY INFILL EXTENSION TO FRONT; SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 23 ROOMS FOLD (SCATCHERD).

N         22/01059  OUTBUILDING TO REAR: 17 HESKETH LANE (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 17/2/22

N         22/01086  SINGLE STOREY SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION; PART FIRST FLOOR OVER;

BI-FOLDING DOORS TO REAR; DORMER WINDOW TO REAR: THE BROW, BAGHILL ROAD (WOODKIRK).

N         22/00884  TWO STOREY SIDE EXTENSION, TWO STOREY FRONT EXTENSION WITH DORMER WINDOWS TO REAR: 161 SCOTCHMAN LANE (ELMFIELD).

O         21/06913  RETROSPECTIVE APPLICATION FOR CHANGE OF USE OF VACANT LAND TO DOMESTIC GARDEN INCLUDING NEW BOUNDARY WALL TO FRONT AND SIDE:

LAND ADJACENT 6 BEECH GROVE (TEALE).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of the impact the street scene and the impact on the Conversation Area.

RECEIVED 21/2/22

N         22/01127  SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 29 PEREGRINE AVENUE (TOPCLIFFE).

The above decisions made under Town Clerk’s delegated authority, were noted.

8.         TO RECEIVE ITEMS OF CORRESPONDENCE (items for information only)

a)         Letter dated 19/1/2022 from Jonathan Carr, Head of Development Management, LCC re. appeal against refusal of planning application 21/07416/FU, 65 Birk Lane (Teale)

b)         Email dated 8/3/22 from Amanda Stone, Senior Planner, LCC re. planning application 21/10197/FU, The Old Bakery, Britannia Road, Morley response to request the application be referred to Plans Panel.

c)         Email dated 8/3/22 from Martin Elliot, Head of Strategic Planning, LCC re. Statement of Community Involvement Consultation.  Public consultation closes 19/4/22.

The above items of correspondence were noted

9.         DATE AND TIME OF NEXT MEETING

The next scheduled meeting will be agreed at the Annual Meeting to be held on Wednesday, 4th May 2022.

 

 

 MINUTES OF PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING NO. 418

 HELD ON TUESDAY, 18^TH JANUARY 2022 

1. TO RECORD ATTENDANCE

            Present:  Cllrs H Evans (Chairman), C Taylor, A Dalton and A Rhodes.

R Pickles (Town Clerk) and W Maynard-Light (Deputy Town Clerk) also attended.

2.         TO RECEIVE APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE GIVEN IN ADVANCE OF THE MEETING

Apologies were received from Cllrs R Finnigan and R Bell.

3.         TO CONSIDER THE APPROVAL OF REASONS GIVEN FOR ABSENCE

The reasons for absence were considered and approved.         

4. DECLARATIONS OF DISCLOSABLE PECUNIARY AND OTHER INTERESTS

Cllr A Rhodes declared an ‘other’ interest re. planning application 9871 – The Old School House, Ackroyd Street as he knows the applicant.

5. TO APPROVE MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON 16/11/21

The Minutes of the meeting held on 16/11/2021 were agreed as a true and correct record.

6. CONSIDERATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS

Notation of Recommendations.

O = Objection

N = No Objection

NC = No Objection (with comments)

D = Deferred

RECEIVED 5/1/22

NC       10190  SINGLE STOREY FRONT EXTENSION; PART TWO STOREY PART SINGLE STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 8 KING GEORGE CROFT (SCATCHERD).

MTC has no objection in principle to this application, however, members requested a condition be placed on the application for space to be available for two vehicles be parked off-road.

N         10220  SINGLE STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 5 PENTLAND WAY (ELMFIELD).

N         10261  TWO STOREY SIDE PART SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 23 IBBETSON DRIVE (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 6/1/22

N         10218  REPLACE FOLDING DOORS WITH SECTIONAL DOORS AND NEW ENTRANCE DOOR TO NORTH EAST ELEVATION; NEW ACCESS DOOR TO FLAT ROOF AREA, CONDENSING UNITS, VENTS AND EXTERNAL PLANT ELEMENTS OF PROCESSING EQUIPMENT AND HANDRAIL TO EXISTING FLAT ROOF: 21 MELBOURNE STREET (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 10/1/22

O         10301  CHANGE OF USE OF GARAGE TO DOG GROOMING BUSINES: 31 HESKETH LANE (WOODKIRK).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of inappropriate business use in a residential area, close proximity to school entrance and children’s playground together with parking issues of customers vehicles on the highway.

RECEIVED 11/1/21

N         22/00088  DETACHED SINGLE STOREY TRIPLE GARAGE TO SIDE: 170 REIN ROAD (WOODKIRK).

The above planning applications were considered by all members of the Planning Committee present.

It was agreed that any comments be submitted via ‘Public Access’.

7. TO NOTE PLANNING APPLICATIONS WITH DECISIONS MADE UNDER DELEGATED AUTHORITY TO TOWN CLERK – STANDING ORDER 15(c) (APPLICATIONS RECEIVED THAT DID NOT APPEAR ON 17/11/2020 AGENDA)

RECEIVED 16/11/21

N         8822  VARIATION OF CONDITIONS 2 NO. (APPROVAL PLANS) AND 22 NO. (SOFT LANDSCAPING) O PREVIOUSLY APPROVED PLANNING APPLICATION 18/00251/FU FOR ALTERATIONS TO THE APPROVED PLANS AND AMENDMENTS TO PLOTS: LAND AT SNITTLES FARM, GELDERD ROAD (WORTLEY).

RECEIVED 18/11/21

N         9076  REMOVAL OF WINDOW TO FRONT ELEVATION: 23 TROY ROAD (CENTRAL).

N         8994  SINGLE STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 40 PAWSON STREET (TEALE).

NC       8584  SINGLE STOREY FRONT EXTENSION; DORMER TO FRONT;DETACHED OUTBUILDING TO FRONT; NEW BOUNDARY TREATMENT TO SIDE: 3 KITSON STREET (WOODKIRK)

MTC has no objection in principle to this application, however, members would asked that a condition be placed on application for two car parking space off-road.

O         8999  CONVERSION AND EXTENSION TO EXISTING OUTBUILDING TO FORM ONE NEW DWELLING WITH ASSOCIATED WORKS: 1 REIN ROAD (ELMFIELD).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of overdevelopment of the site.

N         9127  FIRST FLOOR SIDE EXTENSION: 7 SEVEN HILL WAY (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 19/11/21

N         9097  SINGLE STOREY SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION: THE CROFT, DEWSBURY ROAD (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 22/11/21

O         9150  FRONT AND REAR DORMER WINDOWS: NBEW DOOR AND WINDOWS TO SIDE; SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 20 CROFT HOUSE AVENUE (SCATCHERD).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of the impact on the street scene of the front dormer.

N         9181  SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION : 29 CROFT HOUSE WAY (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 24/11/21

O         8887  CHANGE OF USE OF UPPER FLOORS TO FORM ONE FLAT, BLOCK UP DOOR AND NEW WINDOW TO FIRST FLOOR SIDE ELEVATION:  110 QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of no parking for a two- bedroomed flat.

N         7648  REBUILD OF EXISTING BUILDING ON SAME FOOTPRINT, WITH ADDITIONAL MEZZANINE LEVEL: VICTORIA BUILDINGS, BANK AVENUE (SCATCHERD).

N         9546/TR  T1-LIME – CROWN LIFT TO 5.5 METRES OVER THE HIGHWAY, CROWN THIN TO 15-20% TO HELP ALLOW SOME LIGHT INTO NEIGHBOURING PROPERTIES: MONTACUTE, ST ANDREWS AVENUE (TEALE).

RECEIVED 29/11/2021

O         9299  PART TWO STOREY, PART SINGLE STOREY SIDE/REAR EXTENSION: HILLTHORPE, ELLAND ROAD (CHURWELL).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of the impact on the heritage of the building and the impact on the trees.

N         8927  RETROSPECTIVE APPLICATION FOR A FENCE TO FRONT ELEVATION:

89  SCOTCHMAN LANE (ELMFIELD).

N         9292  ERECTION OF DETACHED RETAIL UNIT: ASDA, HOWLEY PARK ROAD (ELMFIELD).

RECEIVED 30/11/2021

N         9356  FIRST FLOOR SIDE EXTENSION AND TWO STOREY REAR EXTENSION:

5 MALLARD WAY (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 1/12/2021

N         9347  SINGLE STOREY FRONT EXTENSION; FIRST FLOOR REAR EXTENSION; INCREASE IN ROOF HEIGHT: 1 BRUNTCLIFFE CLOSE (TEALE).

N         8331  TWO STOREY SIDE EXTENSION, WITH ROOFLIGHT TO REAR: 69 IBBETSON OVAL (CHURWELL).

N         9456  CHANGE OF USE OF EXISTING DWELLING HOUSE TO TWO SELF CONTAINED FLATS; CYCLE STORE TO REAR: 16 BRUNSWICK STREET (TEALE).

N         9475  TWO STOREY EXTENSION TO SIDE; ALTERATIONS TO PORCH AT REAR:

9 DEWSBURY ROAD (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 2/12/2021

N         9470  TEMPORARY CHANGE OF USE TO EDUCATION USE WITH ASSOCIATED  PUBLIC/EXHIBITION SPACE (CLASS F1 (a), (e)): UNIT 63 WHITE ROSE SHOPPING CENTRE, DEWBURY ROAD (CHURWELL).

O         9418  ALTERATIONS INCLUDING SINGLE STOREY FRONT, SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION;   PART TWO STOREY, PART SINGLE STOREY SIDE EXTENSION; BALCONY TO REAR WITH GLASS BALUSTRADE: 55 THE ROUNDWAY (TEALE).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of the over-development of the site and the impact on the street scene.

RECEIVED 9/12/21

N         9703  TWO STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 21 HARWILL AVENUE (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 13/12/21

N         9706  CHANGE OF USE OF OFFICES TO TWO FLATS: THE CHAPEL, FOSTER CLOSE (TEALE).

N         9786  PART SINGLE PART TWO STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 61 NEWLANDS CRESCENT (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 20/12/21

O         9871  ALTERATIONS TO EXISTING FLATS TO CREATE 1 NO TWO BEDROOM BASEMENT APARTMENT WITH NEW ACCESS TO LOWER GROUND, CREAGTION OF ADDITIONAL CAR PARK SPACE: THE OLD SCHOOL HOUSE, ACKROYD STREET (CENTRAL).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of over-development of the site and the lack of available parking.

RECEIVED 22/12/21

N         10082  SINGLE STOREY SIDE EXTENSION; SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION WITH RAISED DECKING: 16 IBBETSON OVAL (CHURWELL).

N         10058  TWO STOREY FRONT EXTENSION WITH PITCHED ROOF AND SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 24 SHIRE ROAD (ELMFIELD).

RECEIVED 23/12/21

N         09494  OUTBUILDING TO REAR: 2 SYKE AVENUE (WOODKIRK).

O         10179  ALTERATIONS INCLUDING SINGLE STOREY SIDE EXTENSION; DORMER WINDOW TO REAR:  29 IBBETSON OVAL (CHURWELL).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of the impact on the residential amenity of the properties to the rear.

N         10160  SINGLE STOREY SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION; 2 METRE HIGH FENCED ENCLOSURE TO SIDE: 8 MILLSIDE WALK (TOPCLIFFE).

The above decisions made under Town Clerk’s delegated authority, were noted.

8. TO RECEIVE ITEMS OF CORRESPONDENCE (items for information only)
9. a) Letter dated 29/11/21 from Jonathan Carr, Head of Development Management, LCC re. appeal against refusal of planning application 21/05533/FU, 6 Flexbury Avenue (Elmfield).
10. b) Letter dated 01/12/21 from Jonathan Carr, Head of Development Management, LCC re. appeal against refusal of planning application 21/07593/DTM, High Street (Elmfield).
11. c) Letter dated 3/12/21 from Shell Kelly, WHP Telecoms Ltd re. pre-planning consultation letter re. proposed 5G telecommunications installation from H3G UK, Britannia Road Streetworks, Britannia Road, LS27 0EN (Elmfield).
12. d) Email dated 20/12/21 from Martin Elliot, LCC Planning re. Leeds Site Allocations Plan consultation on the Inspector’s Proposed Main Modifications to the Remitted part of the Site Allocations Plan.
13. e) Email dated 21/12/21 from Mathias Franklin, Head of Planning Department, Kirklees Council re. notification of Kirklees Council Decision on the making (bringing into force) of the Holme Valley Neighbourhood Development Plant (Made Plan) December 2021.
14. f) Letter dated 11/1/21 from Jonathan Carr, Head of Development Management, LCC re. appeal against refusal of planning application 21/05937/FU, 56 Springfield Road (Scatcherd).

The above items of correspondence were noted

9. DATE AND TIME OF NEXT MEETING

The next scheduled meeting will be held on Tuesday, 15^th March 2022 at 7.00 pm.

 

MINUTES OF PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING NO. 417

HELD ON TUESDAY, 16TH NOVEMBER 2021

1.         TO RECORD ATTENDANCE

Present:  Cllrs R Finnigan (Deputy Chairman), C Taylor and M Storey.

R Pickles (Town Clerk) and W Maynard-Light (Deputy Town Clerk) also attended.

2.         TO RECEIVE APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE GIVEN IN ADVANCE OF THE MEETING
Apologies were received from Cllrs A Dalton, A Rhodes and R Bell.

3.         TO CONSIDER THE APPROVAL OF REASONS GIVEN FOR ABSENCE
The reasons for absence were considered and approved.

4.         DECLARATIONS OF DISCLOSABLE PECUNIARY AND OTHER INTERESTS

Cllr R Finnigan declared an ‘other’ interest as a Leeds City Councillor.

5.         TO APPROVE MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON 21/9/21

The Minutes of the meeting held on 21/9/2021 were agreed as a true and correct record.

6.         CONSIDERATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS

Notation of Recommendations.
O = Objection
N = No Objection
NC = No Objection (with comments)
D = Deferred

RECEIVED 29/10/21

NC       8350  OUTLINE APPLICATION FOR ERECTION OF 6 DWELLING WITH ASSOCIATED LANDSCAPE AND ENTRANCE: WOODLAND COTTAGE, WIDE LANE (TOPCLIFFE).

MTC has no objection in principle to this application, however, members commented on the uninspiring design of the dwellings.

RECEIVED 1/11/21

N         8451  VARIATION OF CONDITION 2 NO (APPROVED PLANS) TO PREVIOUSLY APPROVED PLANNING APPLICATION 20/02562/FU FOR ALTERATIONS TO THE APPROVED PLANS PARKING ARRANGEMENT: LAND OFF CHAPEL HILL/CHRUCH STREE/BANK AVENUE. (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 2/11/21

N         8338  ALTERATIONS INCLUDING TWO STOREY SIDE EXTENSION WITH LOFT CONVERSION AND TWO DORMERS TO REAR; NEW WINDOW AT FIRST FLOOR TO SIDE; ROOFLIGHTS TO FRONT: 85 CROFT HOUSE WAY (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 8/11/21

N         8598  SINGLE STOREY SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION, TWO STOREY REAR EXTENSION:

9 BITTERN RISE (TOPCLIFFE).

N         8322  SINGLE STOREY SIDE EXTENSION TO EXISTING GARAGE/OUTBUILDING; ASSOCIATED HARD LANDSCAPING, ENLARGED DROPPED KERB: 1 BRIGHTON AVENUE (TEALE).

The above planning applications were considered by all members of the Planning Committee present.

It was agreed that any comments be submitted via ‘Public Access’.

7.         TO NOTE PLANNING APPLICATIONS WITH DECISIONS MADE UNDER DELEGATED AUTHORITY TO TOWN CLERK – STANDING ORDER 15(c) (APPLICATIONS RECEIVED THAT DID NOT APPEAR ON 17/11/2020 AGENDA)

RECEIVED 16/9/21

N         7060  DORMER WINDOW TO FRONT: 2 WEST LEA CRESCENT (WOODKIRK).

N         7026  FIRST FLOOR REAR EXTENSION: 37 THE ROUNDWAY (TEALE).

RECEIVED 17/9/21

O         7204  PART TWO STOREY AND PART SINGLE STOREY EXTENSION TO SIDE WITH DORMER WINDOW TO THE REAR AND ROOFLIGHTS TO FRONT: 11 DEWSBURY ROAD (WOODKIRK).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of the impact on the street scene and the over-development of the site.

RECEIVED 20/9/21

N         7783/TR  T1 SYCAMORE – TO REMOVE TO GROUND LEVEL AS TREE IS GROWING OUT OF THE WALL TOP AND DAMAGING THE WALL: 89 QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

N         6954  BOUNDARY RETAINING WALL, CAR PORT TO SIDE AND SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 14 MARSHALL CRESCENT (ELMFIELD).

RECEIVED 21/9/21

O         6860  TWO STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 35 VICTORIA ROAD (CHURWELL).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of the impact on the street scene.

N         7241  CONVERSION OF GARAGE TO HABITABLE ACCOMMODATION: 34 BRADFIELD AVENUE (TEALE).

RECEIVED 23/9/21

O         7305  ALTERATION INCLUDING TWO STOREY EXTENSION TO SIDE; PART TWO STOREY PART SINGLE STOREY EXTENSION WITH ROOFLIGHTS TO REAR; NEW STEPS TO REAR GARDEN: 44 MCLAREN PLACE (TEALE).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds there would be no realistic second parking space available.

RECEIVED 27/09/2021

O         7416  SINGLE STOREY SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION: 65 BIRK LANE (TEALE).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds there would be no realistic second parking space available.

RECEIVED 28/9/21

N         7117  RAISING THE HEIGHT OF THE EXISTING WORKSHOP ROOF: ARCHBOLD CARSHOP LTD, PROSPECT GARAGE, CHURCH STREET (SCATCHERD).

N         5208  REMOVAL OF CONDITION 4 (NUMBER OF VEHICLES ON SITE AT ANY ONE TIME) TO PREVIOUSLY APPROVED APPLICATION 14/06880/FU TO ALLOW OPEN PARKING: 8 HIGH MILL BUSINESS PARK, MILL STREET (ELMFIELD).

RECEIVED 29/9/21

N         7343  SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 29 ROOMS LANE (SCATCHERD).

O         6079  CHANGE OF USE OF DWELLING TO SOLICITORS’ OFFICES (CLASS E (C) (II)): 9 KIRKSTONE TERRACE, ROOMS LANE (SCATCHERD).

MTC objects to this application for Change of Use on the grounds this would create problematic parking as there is no off-road parking for business users.

RECEIVED 30/9/21

O         7614  SINGLE STOREY SIDE/REAR EXTENSION: 18 EARLSMERE DRIVE (SCATCHERD).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds there would be no realistic second parking space available.

RECEIVED 11/10/21

N         8024  CONTINUATION OF DEVELOPMENT WITHOUT COMPLIANCE WITH CONDITION 2 (APPROVED PLANS) PREVIOUSLY ATTACHED TO APPROVAL 19/07911/FU, MINOR AMENDMENTS ARE SOUGHT TO THE ORIENTATION OF THE EASTERN STATION BUILDING AND OTHER MINOR DESIGN AMENDMENTS AND REALIGNMENT OF THE WESTERN ACCESS ROAD: LAND ADJACENT TO WHITE ROSE OFFICE PARK AND MILLSHAW INDUSTRIAL PARK, MILLSHAW PARK LANE (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 12/10/21

O         8386  DETERMINATION OF TELECOMMUNICATION EQUIPMENT FOR 20.0M PHASE 8 MONOPOLE C/W WRAPROUND CABINET AT BASE AND ASSOCIATED ANCILLARY WORKS: MAGPIE LANE (TOPCLIFFE).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of the impact on the residential amenity.

N         8267/TR  3 x LIME TREES – PRUNE BACK VERTICAL AND LATERAL BY APPROXIMATELY 3 METRES: CROFT LODGE, HIGH STREET (ELMFIELD).

RECEIVED 13/10/21

N         7919  DEMOLITION OF GARAGE. CONSTRUCT SINGLE STOREY SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION: 20 THORNFIELD CRESCENT (WOODKIRK).

N         8011  GARAGE CONVERSION WITH SECOND STOREY EXTENSION ABOVE AND ASSOCIATED ROOF WORKS: 9 TURNBERRY DRIVE (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 14/10/21

N         7947  SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION AND ALTERATIONS TO PART OF INTEGRAL GARAGE TO FORM A HABITABLE ROOM: 2 GRANGE PARK MEWS (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 15/10/21

N         8057  RAISED PATIO AREA TO REAR; BALCOMY TO FIRST FLOOR REAR WITH BALUSTRADE: 28 DIGPAL ROAD (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 20/10/21

N         8174  SINGLE STOREY FRONT EXTENSION; SINGE STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 11 THE ROUNDWAY (TEALE).

N         8034  CHANGE OF USE OF VACANT WAREHOUSE, GYM AND PUBLIC HOUSE TO TWELVE SUPPORTED LIVING APARTMENTS TOGETHER WITH ANCILLARY STAFF AREA AND CAR PARKING: 23-25 MORLEY MILL, COMMERCIAL STREET (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 22/10/21

N         8142  FIRST FLOOR FRONT EXTENSION; SINGLE SOTREY REAR EXTENSION:

22 TINGLEY CRESCENT (WOODKIRK).

N         8193  SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 1 MILLERS DAM (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 28/10/21

O         8807/TR  T2 AND T3 – FELL BECAUSE THE TREE CREATES EXCESSIVE SHADING, IT WOULD NOT HAVE A SIGNIFICANT IMPACT ON THE LOCAL LANDSCAPE OR PUBLIC. IT HAS NO ADVANTAGE AND IS GETTING QUITE LARGE AND IS VERY CLOSE TO THE HOURSES BEHIND WHICH WOULD HAVE A SIGNIFICANT IMPACT IN SEVERE WEATHER CONDITIONS: T9 SYCAMORE – FELL, THIS TREE IS EXTREMELY CLOSE TO THE HOUSE IN FRONT AND CLOSE TO THEIR DRIVEWAY. IT IS VERY TALL AND AGAIN IN SEVERE WEATHER CONDITIONS COULD CAUSE DAMAGE: WE HAVE HAD THIS APPLICATION PREVIOSULY PARTLY REFUSED, WE HAD A TREE SURGEON HAVE A LOOK WHO ADVISED THAT REMOVING ONLY THINNING TO A MAXIMUM OF 20% WOULD CAUSE FURTHER AND THICKER RE. GROWTH. WE PROPOSE TO REPLAT 2 SYCAMORE TREES ON THE WOODLAND AREA TO THE LEFT OF THE DRIVE: THE CHASE, BRADSTOCK GARDENS (SCATCHERD).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds there is no good reason for removal of the trees.

N         8839/TR  T1 LIME – 30% CROWN REDUCTION IN HEIGHT TO A FINAL HEIGHT OF 14 METRES AND A 15% REDUCTION OF OVEREXTENDED LIMBS TO A FINAL WIDTH OF 10.2 METRES. THIS WILL BE ACHIEVED BY PRUNING TO FROWTH POINTS A TOTAL REDUCTION OF 90CM TO ALL SIDES AND 6M IN HEIGHT.  OUR CLIENT HAS RAISED CONCERNS ABOUT THE WINDSAIL IN THE HEIGHT OF THIS TREE AS IT HAS NO SHELTER BELT TO PROTECT IT FROM EASTERLY WINDS THAT BLOW TOWARDS THE HOUSE: PARK HOUSE, ELLAND ROAD (CHURWELL).

The above decisions made under Town Clerk’s delegated authority, were noted.

8.         TO DISCUSS AND AGREE PLANNING COMMITTEE BUDGET SUBMISSION FOR

2022/23 (for referral to the Finance, GP & Strategic Committee).

Following a short discussion, it was proposed and agreed and budget for 2022/23 financial year of £1,000.

9.         TO RECEIVE ITEMS OF CORRESPONDENCE (items for information only)

a)         Email dated 8/10/21 from Shelley Kelly, WHP Telecoms Ltd re. Preplanning consultation LDS12211, proposed 5G telecommunications installation for H3G UK at Magpie Lane Streetworks, LS27 8GQ (Topcliffe).

10.       DATE AND TIME OF NEXT MEETING

The next scheduled meeting will be held on Tuesday, 18th January 2022 at 7.00 pm.

 

MINUTES OF PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING NO. 416

 HELD ON TUESDAY, 21^ST SEPTEMBER 2021 

1. TO RECORD ATTENDANCE

            Present:  Cllrs H Evans (Chairman), A Rhodes, C Taylor, R Bell, R Finnigan, M Storey and A Dalton.

W Maynard-Light (Deputy Town Clerk) also attended.

2.         TO RECEIVE APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE GIVEN IN ADVANCE OF THE MEETING

There were no apologies received.

3.         TO CONSIDER THE APPROVAL OF REASONS GIVEN FOR ABSENCE

None.          

4.   DECLARATIONS OF DISCLOSABLE PECUNIARY AND OTHER INTERESTS

Cllr R Finnigan declared an ‘other’ interest as a Leeds City Councillor.

5. TO APPROVE MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON 20/7/2021

The Minutes of the meeting held on 20/7/2021 were agreed as a true and correct record.

6. CONSIDERATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS

Notation of Recommendations.

O = Objection

N = No Objection

NC = No Objection (with comments)

D = Deferred

RECEIVED 2/9/21

N         6087  FENCING TO FRONT, SIDE AND REAR; EXTERNAL DINING AREA TO SIDE AND REAR: KASA ROSA, TOWN END, FOUNTAIN STREET (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 3/9/21

N         6573  ALTERATIONS TO FRONT VEHICLE ENTRANCE INCLUDING DROP DOWN VEHICLE BARRIER; RAISED BOLLARDS AND NEW SECURITY GATES: DEPUY INTERNATIONAL LTD, UNIT 1 CAPITOL BOULEVARD (TOPCLIFFE).

N         06636  DEMOLITION OF EXISTING DETACHED GARAGE: NEW SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION WITH RAISED PATIO: 37 HARWILL ROAD (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 6/9/21

N         6635  USE OF EXISTING VEHICLE RECOVERY OPERATION AS A 24 HOUR 7 DAYS A WEEK SERVICE: VICTORIA WORKS, BRITANNIA ROAD (ELMFIELD).

O         06740  PART TWO STOREY AND PART SINGLE STOREY EXTENSION TO SIDE:

93 DENSHAW GROVE (TOPCLIFFE).

MTC objected to this application on the grounds of over-development of the site and the impact on the street scene.

RECEIVED 7/9/21

N         6560  THREE NEW DWELLINGS: THE OLD CHAPEL, NEW BANK STREET (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 14/9/21

N         6850  ALTERATIONS INCLUDING GABLE ROOF EXTENSION AND RAISED ROOF HEIGHT TO FORM ROOMS IN LOFT AREA, SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION; DORMER WINDOW TO FRONT; DETACHED GARAGE TO FRONT; EXTENDING HARDSTANDING AT FRONT: THE BROW, BAGHILL ROAD (WOODKIRK).

N         6925  DORMER WINDOW TO FRONT: 116 FOUNTAIN STREET (TEALE).

N         6981  CONSTRUCT NEW MEZZANINE FLOOR WITHIN EXISTING UNIT; NEW EXTERNAL FIRE ESCAPE STAIR, INSTALL NEW WINDOWS AT FIRST FLOOR : COLLEGE OF ANIMAL WELFARE, UNIT 401, CAPITAL PARK EAST, TOPCLIFFE CLOSE (TOPCLIFFE).

The above planning applications were considered by all members of the Planning Committee present.

It was agreed that any comments be submitted via ‘Public Access’.

7. TO NOTE PLANNING APPLICATIONS WITH DECISIONS MADE UNDER DELEGATED AUTHORITY TO TOWN CLERK – STANDING ORDER 15(c) (APPLICATIONS RECEIVED THAT DID NOT APPEAR ON 17/11/2020 AGENDA)

 RECEIVED 16/7/21

N         05582  SINGLE STOREY SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION: 65 BIRK LANE (TEALE).

RECEIVED 19/7/21

N         06184/TR  T1 ASH – RE-POLLARD BACK TO THE OLD POLLARD POINTS TO ALLOW MORE LIGHT INTO THE SMALL NEIGHBOURING GARDEN, THE TREE WAS POLLARDED MANY YEARS AGO: MONTACUTE, ST ANDREWS AVENUE (TEALE).

RECEIVED 21/7/21

N         06098  DETERMINATION OF TELECOMMUNICATION EQUIPMENT FOR 20.0M PHASE 8 MONOPOLE C/W WRAP ROUND CABINET AT BASE AND ASSOCATED ANCILLARY WORKS: BRUNTCLIFFE LANE (TEALE).

RECEIVED 23/7/21

N         05690  REMOVAL OF INDIVIDUAL LETTER SIGNAGE, PROJECTING SIGNAGE AND EXISTING ATM; INSERTION OF GLAZING PANEL TO REPLACE ATM: BARCLAYS BANK, QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

N         05691  LISTED BUILDING APPLICATION FOR REMOVAL OF INDIVIDUAL LETTER SIGNAGE, PROJECTING SIGNAGE AND EXISTING ATM; INSERTION OF GLAZING PANEL TO REPLACE ATM: 89 QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 27/7/21

N         06304/TR  T1 CHERRY BLOSSOM – CROWN REDUCTION IN HEIGHT FROM 10 METRES TO 7 METRES AND WIDTH FROM 6 METRES TO 4 METRES AS IT IS GETTING QUITE LARGE FOR THE AREA IT IS IN AND IS SPREADING TO A NEIGHBOURING PROPERTY AND ALLOTMENT BEHIND: 10 ZOAR STREET (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 28/7/21

O         03792  FENCE TO SIDE AND FRONT: 8 APPLEYARD LANE (CENTRAL).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of the impact on the street scene and it is noted that no other properties have fences on this section.  The estate is open plan.

RECEIVED 29/7/21

N         05466  VARIATION OF CONDITION 2 OF PLANNING APPLICATION 21/02331/FU – INSTALLATION OF SOLAR PANELS: CHURWELL PRIMARY SCHOOL, WESTWOODSIDE (CHURWELL).

N         05657  SINGLE STOREY SUMMER HOUSE TO REAR: 68 WOODCROSS (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 4/8/21

N         06587/TR  T1 HYBRID POPLAR – FELL WEST STEM (CO-DOMINANT STEM). WEST STEM LEANING TOWARDS HOUSE AND OVER FOOTPATH. RECENT LIMB FAILURE PRESENT, SIGNIFICANT RISK OF FAILURE; T2 HORSE CHESTNUT – CROWN LIFT TO 2.5M. LOW CANOPY INTERFERRING WITH PEDESTRIANS ON FOOTPATH: LAND ADJACENT TO 16 WATERING MEADOWS (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 6/8/21

N         05937  TWO STOREY AND SINGLE STOREY SIDE/REAR EXTENSION INCORPORATING GABLE WALL SIDE EXTENSION AND JULIET BALCONY AT REAR; EXTEND DRIVEWAY TO FRONT: 56 SPRINGFIELD ROAD (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 11/8/21

O         06075  DEMOLITION OF OUTBUILDING TO SIDE; PART TWO STOREY, PART SINGLE STOREY FRONT, SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION: 33 BRAMBLING MEWS (TOPCLIFFE).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of overdevelopment of the site, inadequate space available for two vehicles to be parked off-road and the removal of a tree not covered by the application.

N         05845  SINGLE STOREY EXTENSION WITH ROOFLIGHTS TO REAR: 41 BIRK LANE (TEALE).

N         06110  SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION WITH ROOFLIGHTS: 52 WOODCROSS FOLD (SCATCHERD).

N         06051  DETACHED GARDEN ROOM AT REAR: 3 MANOR GRANGE (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 16/8/21

N         0/6100  ERECTION OF SMALL INDUSTRIAL UNIT ON VACANT EXISTING YEARD: LAND AND PREMISES, HOWLEY PARK ROAD EAST (ELMFIELD).

N         06168  PART TWO STOREY PART FIRST FLOOR SIDE EXTENSION: 8 THE OAKS (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 18/8/21

N         06217  REMOVAL OF EXTERNAL SIGNAGE AND ATM: 44 QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 23/8/21

N         06095  RETROPSECTIVE APPLICATION FOR A TWO STOREY REAR EXTENSION:

10 HARWILL CROFT (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 1/9/21

N         06582  COVERED TIMBER FRAMED PERGOLA TO REAR: NEEDLESS INN, SCOTCHMAN LANE (TEALE).

N         06559  SINGLE STOREY SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION: 46 PAWSON STREET (TEALE).

RECEIVED 6/9/21

N         07409/TR  T1, T2, T3, T4 OAK – FELL AND TREAT.  THE WORKS ARE PROPOSED AS A REMEDY OF THE DIFFERENTIAL FOUNDATION MOVEMENT AT THE INSURED PROPERTY AND TO ENSURE THE LONGER-TERM STABILITY OF THE FOUNDATIONS. THE WORKS ARE PROPOSED TO LIMIT THE EXTENT AND THE NEED FOR EXPENSIVE AND DISTRUPTIVE ENGINEERING REPAIR WORKS.  INSURERS UNDERSTAND THE REQUIREMENTS TO OFFER REPLACEMENT PLANTING IN THE EVENT CONSENT TO FELL IS GRANTED: BRIAR KNOLL, SCOTCHMAN LANE (TEALE).

RECEIVED 8/9/21

N         07493/TR  T1 SILVER BIRTH – REMOVAL DUE TO DRIVEWAY AND BOUNDARY WALL SUBSIDENCE (RED CIRCLE ON THE MAP); T2 – SYCAMORE – REMOVAL DUE TO DRIVEWAY AND BOUNDARY WALL SUBSIDENCE (BLUE CIRCLE ON MAP): 56A SCATCHERED LANE (TEALE).

RECEIVED 14/9/21

N         07546/TR  ALDER (T1) – REDUCTION BY APPROXIMATELY 20 FT DEPENDENT UPON SUITABLE GROWTH POINTS, TO ALLOW MORE LIGHT PENETRATION TO PROPERTY; SYCAMORE (T2) – REDUCTION BY APPROXIMATELY 16 FT DEPENDENT UPON SUITABLE GROWTH POINTS, TO ALLOW MORE LIGHT PENETRATION TO PROPERTY; ALDER (T3) – FELL DUE TO POOR DEVELOPMENT FROM OVERCROWING AND COMPETITION FOR LIGHT, CAUSING A HEAVY LEAN TOWARDS PROPERTY (THE CARRIERS ARMS PUB) BELOW ON GLEN ROAD. REPLANT WITH MOUNTAIN ASH. ALL WORK CARRIED OUT IN ACCORDANCE WITH BE3998: 23 BRIDGE COURT (ELMFIELD).

N         07590/TR  T1, T2 PEAR TREES IN POOR CONDITION. REMOVE; T3, T4, T5 ROWANS – REDUCE CANOPIES IN HEIGHT ONLY BY 4M (CANOPY HAS BOLTED UPWARDS SEARCHING FOR LIGHT AND ARE UNUSUALLY TALL FOR SPECIES; T7 WHITEBEAM TOTALLY OVERWHELMED BY NEIGHBOURING TREES AND TOUCHING NEXT DOOR BUILDING – REMOVE TO ALLOW NEIGHBOURING TREES TO GET MORE SPACE; T8 CHERRY – REDUCE REAR BRANCHES BY 2M AWAY FROM NEIGHBOURING BUILDINGS; T9 GOAT WILLOW – MULTISTEMMED AND FAR SPREADING – REDUCE BACK BRANCHES AWAY FROM NEIGHBOURING BUILDINGS BY 3M: 96B QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

The above decisions made under Town Clerk’s delegated authority, were noted.

8. TO RECEIVE ITEMS OF CORRESPONDENCE (items for information only)
9. a) Email dated 17/8/21 from Steven Wright, Planning Policy and Strategy Group Leader, Kirklees re: Netherton and South Crosland Neighbourhood Forum.
10. b) Email dated 24/8/21 from Nada Tariq, Edward Architecture re. public consultation statement – proposal on land off Bank Avenue, Morley.
11. c) Email dated 8/9/21 from Jonathan Carr, Head of Development Management, LCC re. appeal planning application 21/03461/FU, 64 Watson Street (Elmfield).
12. d) Email dated 7/9/21 from Eve Wyke, WHP Telecoms re. pre-planning consultation letter and drawings for site LDS19101proposed 5G telecommunications installation for H3G UK, High Street (Elmfield).

The above items of correspondence were noted.

10. DATE AND TIME OF NEXT MEETING

The next scheduled meeting will be held on Tuesday, 16^th November 2021 at 7.00 pm

 

MINUTES OF PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING NO. 415

HELD ON TUESDAY, 20TH JULY  2021

1.         TO RECORD ATTENDANCE

Present:  Cllrs H Evans (Chairman), M Storey and A Dalton.

W Maynard-Light (Deputy Town Clerk) also attended.

2.         TO RECEIVE APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE GIVEN IN ADVANCE OF THE MEETING
Apologies were received from Cllr C Taylor and R Finnigan.

3.         TO CONSIDER THE APPROVAL OF REASONS GIVEN FOR ABSENCE
The reason for absence were agreed and approved.

4.         DECLARATIONS OF DISCLOSABLE PECUNIARY AND OTHER INTERESTS

There were no declarations of interest.

5.         TO APPROVE MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON 18/5/2021

The Minutes of the meeting held on 18/5/2021 were agreed as a true and correct record.

6.         CONSIDERATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS

Notation of Recommendations.
O = Objection
N = No Objection
NC = No Objection (wi
th comments)
D = Deferred

RECEIVED 1/7/21

O         05231  ALTERATIONS INCLUDING TWO STOREY, PART SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION; SINGLE STOREY FRONT EXTENSION; NEW DRIVEWAY AND DROPPED KERB VEHICULAR ACCESS: 1 BRUNTCLIFFE CLOSE (TEALE).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of over-development of the site and the impact on the neighbouring amenities.

N         05151  DEMOLITION OF EXISTING GARAGE AND CONSTRUCTION OF NEW GARAGE AND ANNEX WITH PITCH ROOF: 8 SYKE ROAD (WOODKIRK).

N         05148  CHANGE OF USE OF ONE DWELLING HOUSE TO TWO DWELLING HOUSES AND ALTERATIONS INVOLVING EXISTING GROUND FLOOR OPENING IN PARTY WALL TO BE WALLED UP: 2 ROOMS FOLD (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 5/7/21

N         05331  SINGLE STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: HESKETH HOUSE, 6 HESKETH LANE (WOODKIRK).

N         05222  RETROSPECTIVE APPLICATION FOR DECKING THAT IS OVER 30CM FROM GROUND LEVEL AND A FENCE PANEL THAT IS 0.5FT OVER ALLOWANCE: 81 CLOUGH STREET (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 8/7/21

N         05153  TWO STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 20 HARWILL CROFT (CHURWELL).

O         05446  SINGLE STOREY FRONT EXTENSION; LOFT CONVERSION WITH REAR DORMER:

6 TEAL DRIVE (TOPCLIFFE).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of the impact the rear dormer will have on the street scene and residential amenities of the neighbourhood.  There are no other dormers on the estate.

RECEIVED 13/7/21

N         05472  CONVERSTION OF GARAGE TO HABITABLE ROOMS; NEW BAY WINDOW TO FRONT; SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 11 MALLARD WAY (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 14/7/21

N         05595  ALTERATIONS TO ENTRANCE INCLUDING FOOTPATH REMODELLING AND REPLACEMENT DOORS WINDOWS AND FASCIA WITH NEW RENDER TO FRONT: THE MORLEY ACADEMY, FOUNTAIN STREET (CENTRAL).

The above planning applications were considered by all members of the Planning Committee present.

It was agreed that any comments be submitted via ‘Public Access’.

7.         TO NOTE PLANNING APPLICATIONS WITH DECISIONS MADE UNDER DELEGATED AUTHORITY TO TOWN CLERK – STANDING ORDER 15(c) (APPLICATIONS RECEIVED THAT DID NOT APPEAR ON 17/11/2020 AGENDA)

RECEIVED 10/5/21

N         21/03461  ALTERATIONS INCLUDING RAISED ROOF HEIGHT AND LOFT CONVERSION:

64 WATSON STREET (ELMFIELD).

RECEIVED 13/5/21

N         21/03494  RETROSPECTIVE APPLICATION FOR A SINGLE OUTBUILDING TO REAR:

6 CHESTNUT VIEW (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 14/5/21

O         21/03576  TWO STOREY SIDE EXTENSION; NEW FENCE TO FRONT AND SIDE BOUNDARY: 12 BRIGHTON AVENUE (TEALE).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of the impact this development would have on the street scene.

RECEIVED 17/5/21

N         21/03463  SUN LOUNGE TO REAR; PORCH TO FRONT: 160 ALBERT ROAD (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 19/5/21

N         21/04372/TR  T1 – BEECH – REDUCE HEIGHT AND CROWN WIDTH BY 4 METRES BECAUSE GAUODEMA LIPSIESE HAS BEEN IDENTIFIED AT THE SOIL/STEM INTERFACE:  HIGHWAY VERGE ADJACENT TO SPRINGFIELD MILL PARK, SPRINGFIELD LANE (SCATCHERD).

O         21/03365  SINGLE STOREY FRONT EXTENSION: 17 CLOUGH STREET (CENTRAL).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of the impact on the street scene.

RECEIVED 26/5/21

N         21/03886  INSTALLATION OF PARTITION WALL TO EXISTING COUNTER POSITIONS/REPLACEMENT OF SMALL SECTION OF VINYL AND CARPET: HSBC BANK PLC, BANK CHAMBERS, QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

N         21/03881  NEW FRONTAGES TO COMMERCIAL UNITS AT LOWER GROUND FLOOR:  QUEENS HOUSE, HIGH STREET (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 28/5/21

N         21/03205 FIRST FLOOR EXTENSION AND REMOVAL OF ROOF FEATURE TO FRONT:

99 IBBETSON OVAL (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 2/6/21

N         21/04113  PART TWO STOREY, PART FIRST FLOOR SIDE EXTENSION: 10 WOODCROSS END (CHURWELL)

RECEIVED 3/6/21

N         21/03480  INSTALLATION OF RAISED DECKING TO REAR GARDEN: 61 MOZART WAY (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 4/6/21

N         21/04288  PART TWO STOREY, PART SINGLE STOREY SIDE EXTENSION; ROOFLIGHTS TO REAR, DECKING TO REAR: 27 OWL RIDGE (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 8/6/21

N         21/04329  PART SINGLE STOREY, PART TWO STOREY SIDE EXTENSION; SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 8 ROSEATE GREEN (TOPCLIFFE).

N         21/04254  EXTERNAL ALTERATIONS TO UNIT D1 INCLUDING NEW GLAZED FRONTAGE AND DOORS, HARD AND SOFT LANDSCAPING WORKS, RECONFIGURATION OF THE CAR PARK LAYOUT, ERECTION OF TROLLEY BAYS AND ASSOCIATED WORKS: UNIT D1, CAR PARK 3 AND CAR PARK 4, WHITE ROSE SHOPPING CENTRE (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 9/6/21

N         21/04447  INSTALLATION OF FREESTANDING CANOPY STRUCTURE TO DOOR SEATING AREA, 4 METRES X 4 METRES: ELLIOT HUDSON COLLEGE, WHITE ROSE OFFICE PARK, MILLSHAW PARK LANE (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 14/6/21

N         21/04564  PART SINGLE STOREY, PART TWO STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 22 DEWSBURY ROAD (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 15/6/21

N         21/04593  SINGLE STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 11 EARLSMERE DRIVE (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 16/6/21

O         21/02533  CHANGE OF USE OF LAND TO USE AS DOMESTIC GARDEN AND I        NSTALLATION OF SUMMERHOUSE: 10 LEYBURN AVENUE (TOPCLIFFE).

MTC objects to this retrospective application on the grounds of the incursion onto the Greenbelt buffer zone.  Therefore, members recommend an objection as there are no special reasons to flex on Greenbelt for this development.

RECEIVED 17/6/21

O         21/04792  GARAGE CONVERSION TO HABITABLE ROOM SPACE WITH A SINGLE STOREY EXTENSION TO EXISTING FRONT: 7 IBBETSON CLOSE (CHURWELL).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds the removal of the garage will create one off-street parking space in a cul-de-sac.

O         21/04258  SINGLE STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 12 HARWILL ROAD (CHURWELL).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds the extension will create only one off-street parking space.

RECEIVED 18/6/21

N         21/04403  TWO STOREY AND SINGLE STOREY SIDE/REAR EXTENSION INCORPORATING GABLE WALL SIDE EXTENSION WITH DORMER WINDOW TO REAR: 17 SUNNYSIDE AVENUE (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 21/6/21

NC      21/04929  TIMBER FRAMED PERGOLA COMPLETE WITH SHINGLE FELT ROOF TILES, FESTOON LIGHTING AND HEAT LAMPS COMPLETED WITH ADDITIONAL PAVING SLABS TO FRONT PATIO AREA: COMMERICAL INN, 78 ELLAND ROAD (CHURWELL).

MTC has no objection in principle to this application.  However, would request a condition of no use of the area after 10pm every night.

RECEIVED 22/6/21

N         21/04946  TWO STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 12 CAMBRIDGE COURT (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 23/6/21

NC      21/04913  SINGLE STOREY SIDE/REAR EXTENSION WITH RAMP TO FRONT:

14 PENTLAND WAY (ELMFIELD).

MTC has no objection in principle to this application.  However, would request a condition be placed on the application vehicles should be parked on the property/off-street.

RECEIVED 24/6/21

NC      21/04547  CHANGE OF USE OF RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY TO BAR AND RESTAURANT:

3 BRUNSWICK STREET (TEALE).

MTC has no objection in principle to this application.  However, would request a condition be placed on the application regarding the siting of the bins be on the property, as this cannot be seen on the plans.

RECEIVED 28/6/21

O         21/04911  SINGLE STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 31 REIN ROAD (ELMFIELD).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of the impact on the residential amenity and overdevelopment of the site.

The above decisions made under Town Clerk’s delegated authority, were noted.

8.         TO RECEIVE ITEMS OF CORRESPONDENCE (items for information only)

a)         Email dated 11/6/21 from Suzi Help, WHP Telecoms Ltd re. pre-consultation letter proposed base station installation upgrade at Cornerstone 112893, Tef 18475, Morley Daisy Hill, Sims Metal Management, Leeds LS27 8RU, NER: E;427085, N;428162.

b)         Email dated 14/6/21 from Suzi Help, WHP Telecoms Ltd re. pre-consultation letter proposed base station installation upgrade at Cornerstone 111531, Tef 68052, William Caldwell Ltd, William Tankers Ltd, Howley Park Industrial Estate, Howley Park Road East, Morley, Leeds LS27 0SW, NER: E:426452, E:426102.

c)         Email dated 29/6/21 from Jonathan Carr, Head of Development Management, LCC re. reserved matters application 19/01988, Laneside Farm, Victoria Road.

d)         Email dated 30/6/21 from Suzi Help, WHP Telecoms Ltd re. pre-consultation letter proposed base station installation upgrade at Cornerstone 11374, Tef 68055, land off Scott Lane, Morley, Leeds, Phoenix Whirlpools LS27 0NQ, NGR: E: 424930, N: 427212.

e)         Email dated 2/7/21 from Suzi Help, WHP Telecoms Ltd re. proposed 5G telecommunications installation for H3G UK at Bruntcliffe Lane Streetworks, Morley LS27 0JG

The above items of correspondence were noted.

10.       DATE AND TIME OF NEXT MEETING

The next scheduled meeting will be held on Tuesday, 21st September 2021 at 7.00 pm.

 

MINUTES OF PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING NO. 414

HELD ON TUESDAY, 15TH MAY  2021

1.         TO RECORD ATTENDANCE

Present:  Cllrs H Evans (Chairman), R Finnigan, R Bell, C Taylor, M Storey and A Dalton.

W Maynard-Light (Deputy Town Clerk) also attended.

2.         TO RECEIVE APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE GIVEN IN ADVANCE OF THE MEETING
There were no apologies.

3.         TO CONSIDER THE APPROVAL OF REASONS GIVEN FOR ABSENCE
None.

4.         DECLARATIONS OF DISCLOSABLE PECUNIARY AND OTHER INTERESTS

Cllr R Finnigan declared an ‘other’ interest in any relevant items, as he is a member of LCC Plans Panels.

5.         TO APPROVE MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON 16/3/2021

The Minutes of the meeting held on 16/3/2021 were agreed as a true and correct record.

6.         CONSIDERATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS
Notation of Recommendations.
O = Objection
N = No Objection
NC = No Objection (with comments)
D = Deferred

RECEIVED 28/4/21

NC       21/02880  DEMOLITION OF FORMER PUBLIC HOUSE BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION OF RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT COMPRISING 11 DWELLINGS: FORMER THE ARKLE PUBLIC HOUSE, 105 SPRINGFIELD AVENUE (SCATCHERD).

MTC has no objections in principle to this planning application.  Members would, however, wish to make the comment that rather than dormers being of the box design they would rather them be either pitched roof or velux windows.

N         21/03130  TWO STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 6 POPLAR CRESCENT (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 29/4/21

N         21/03155  PART TWO STOREY PART SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 12 EYRIE APPROACH (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 4/5/21

NC       21/03131  CHANGE OF USE FROM OFFICES (CLASS E) TO DRINKING ESTABLISHMENT (SUI GENERIES): 25-27 QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

MTC has no objection in principle to this application.  However, members would like to see the original frontage of the premises retained.

N         21/03170  INSTALLATION OF 2 NO. AIR SOURCE HEAT PUMPS TO GARAGE ROOF: KNOWLE MANOR AGED PERSONS HOME, TENNYSON TERRACE (CENTRAL).

N         21/02147  WOODEN CHILDREN PLAYHOUSE TO REAR: 1 SCATCHERD MEWS (TOPCLIFFE).

N         21/03223  RETROSPECTIVE CHANGE OF USE OF VACANT LAND TO GARDEN AREA AND ERECTION OF DETACHED GARAGE: LAND AND PREMISES ADJACENT ALLOTMENT GARDENS, BRITANNIA ROAD (ELMFIELD).

O         21/03159  SINGLE STOREY REAR/SIDE EXTENSION: 87 ALBERT ROAD (TOPCLIFFE).

MTC objects to this planning application on the grounds of the impact on the street scene, reduction of car parking space to one vehicle only and over-development of the site.

RECEIVED 5/5/21

O         21/03185  CONVERSION OF DWELLING HOUSE INTO TWO DWELLING HOUSES:  2 OXFORD STREET (ELMFIELD).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of over-development of the site and in adequate car parking space available with the property being change from one dwelling into two.

RECEIVED 10/5/21

N         21/03428  PART TWO STOREY, PART SINGLE STOREY SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION:  56 SPRINGFIELD ROAD (SCATCHERD).

N         21/03250  SINGLE STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 37 TINGLEY CRESCENT (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 11/5/21

N         21/03485  INSTALLATION OF TWO AIR SOURCE HEAT PUMPS: CHURWELL PRIMARY SCHOOL, WESTWOODSIDE (CHURWELL).

The above planning applications were considered by all members of the Planning Committee present.

It was agreed that any comments be submitted via ‘Public Access’.

7.         TO NOTE PLANNING APPLICATIONS WITH DECISIONS MADE UNDER DELEGATED AUTHORITY TO TOWN CLERK – STANDING ORDER 15(c) (APPLICATIONS RECEIVED THAT DID NOT APPEAR ON 17/11/2020 AGENDA)

RECEIVED 10/3/21

N         21/01652  SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 95 BIRK LANE (TEALE).

N         21/01753  SINGLE-STOREY SIDE EXTENSION TO BOTH SIDES: 35A REIN ROAD (ELMFIELD).

N         21/01759  REPLACEMENT OF CLADDING AND WINDOWS: BRUNTCLIFFE ACADEMY, BRUNTCLIFFE LANE (TEALE).

RECEIVED 16/3/21

O         21/01624  ALTERATIONS INCLUDING NEW ENTRANCE AND VEHICLE ACCESS TO FRONT; TWO-STOREY EXTENSION TO SIDE FORMING NEW FIRST FLOOR; DORMER WINDOWS TO FRONT AND REAR: 51 BRIGHTON AVENUE (TEALE).

MTC objects to the application on the grounds of overdevelopment of the site and the impact on the street scene with no similar dormers in the adjacent neighbourhood.

RECEIVED 17/3/21

N         21/01894 SINGLE-STOREY SIDE EXTENSION, WORKS TO INCREASE PITCH OF EXISTING SIDE AND FRONT EXTENSION, ROOF WINDOWS TO SINGLE-STOREY ELEMENTS, NEW BOUNDARY FENCING/WALL AND GATES: DEAN HALL FARM, FARM HILL ROAD (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 19/3/21

O         21/01889  ERECTION OF SINGLE DWELLING: LAND OFF GRANNY PLACE (CHURWELL).

MTC objected to this application due to proposed materials to be used, i.e. corrugated steel and detrimental impact on the street scene.  In principle, could possibly support one house on this site, using appropriate materials.

RECEIVED 23/3/21

O         21/02023  SINGLE-STOREY SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION: 24 McLAREN PLACE (TEALE).

MTC objected to this application due to loss of one parking space.

RECEIVED 25/3/21

N         21/02072  SINGLE-STOREY EXTENSION TO FRONT: 18 KING GEORGE CROFT (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 26/3/21

N         21/02194  NEW RENDER TO REAR/SIDE ELEVATION: FELICITAS HOUSE, 51 ROOMS LANE (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 29/3/21

N         21/02123  FIRST-FLOOR EXTENSION INCORPORATING DORMERS TO FRONT & REAR:

39 MANOR FARM DRIVE (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 30/3/21

N         21/02299  SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 20 PETREL WAY (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 31/3/21

N         21/02161  ALTERATIONS INCLUDING SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION; NEW GATE TO SIDE: 49 VICTORIA ROAD (SCATCHERD).

N         21/01860  SINGLE-STOREY DETACHED OFFICE/GARDEN ROOM TO REAR: 44 FIELDING WAY (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 6/4/21

N         21/02310  AMENDMENT TO PLANNING APPLICATION 20/02312/FU (CONVERTING ONE FLAT INTO TWO FLATS) FOR ALTERATIONS INVOLVING INSTALLATION OF TWO NEW WINDOW OPENINGS TO PROPOSED FLATS: 1 JUBILEE COURT, MARSHALL STREET (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 7/4/21

O         21/02115  OUTBUILDING TO REAR: 51 ROOMS LANE (SCATCHERD).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of the impact on the residential amenity.  Members request this application go to LCC Plans Panel.

RECEIVED 8/4/21

O         21/02404  FIRST-FLOOR SIDE EXTENSION ABOVE EXISTING GARAGE AND SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION WITH ROOF TERRACE ABOVE: 23 WOODCROSS GARTH (CHURWELL).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds the conversion of the garage to living space will reduce the available off-street parking from two to one vehicle.

RECEIVED 9/4/21

N         21/01481  CHANGE OF USE FROM RETAIL TO BAR/RESTAURANT: 13-15 FOUNTAIN STREET (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 12/4/21

N         21/02402  VARIATION OF CONDITION 3 (PLANS SCHEDULE) OF PREVIOUSLY APPROVED APPLICATION 18/03320/OT FOR MINOR MATERIAL AMENDMENTS TO THE APPROVED LAYOUT: 4A SYKE ROAD (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 13/04/21

N         21/03043/TR  T1 POPLAR – REMOVE TREE THAT HAS FALLEN: LAND REAR OF

111 DEWSBURY ROAD (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 15/4/21

O         21/02604  TWO-STOREY SIDE EXTENSION AND SINGLE-STOREY SIDE EXTENSION TO THE OTHER SIDE: 3 DAFFIL AVENUE (CHURWELL).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of overdevelopment of a small site.

RECEIVED 19/4/21

O         21/02712  TWO-STOREY SIDE EXTENSION AND SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION:

11 ASQUITH DRIVE (SCATCHERD).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of the impact on the street scene.

N         21/02689  SINGLE-STOREY EXTENSION TO REAR: 3 STATION VIEW (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 21/4/21

N         21/02563/TR  WILLOW – CROWN REDUCTION OF 3 METRES WHICH WOULD BRING IT FROM 12 METRES TO 9. CROWN LIFT 2.5 METRES FROM THE FLOOR: 16 ZOAR STREET (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 26/4/21

N         21/02910  REPOSITIONING OF FRONT ENTRANCE: PIZZA HUT: 2 SOUTH QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 26/4/21

NC       21/03058 CHANGE OF USE OF GROUND-FLOOR OFFICE TO TAKEAWAY; INSTALLATION OF REAR FLUE: 16 SOUTH QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

MTC has no objection in principle to this application but would comment on the cumulative effect the change of use to takeaway will have on the surrounding area and parking.

RECEIVED 6/5/21

N         21/03975/TR  T16 SYCAMORE – TO LIFT CROWN TO 5 METRES GROUND CLEARANCE AND CUT BACK BRANCHES TO 3 METRES FROM 1 RHODES GARDENS:  T17, G18 AND G19 SYCAMORE – TO REMOVE AS THEY ARE CAUSING DAMAGE TO BOUNDARY WALL. ALL TREES WERE PREVIOUSLY GRANTED TO BE REMOVED BUT HAVE NOT:  THERE ARE SAPLINGS THAT ARE TOO CLOSE TO THE BOUNDARY WALL AND BRANCHES EXTEND OVER 3-4 METRES ONTO THE ROOF OF RHODES GARDENS: LAND TO THE REAR OF RHODES GARDEN, HIGH STREET (CENTRAL).

The above decisions made under Town Clerk’s delegated authority, were noted.

8.         TO RECEIVE ITEMS OF CORRESPONDENCE (items for information only)

(a)        Letter dated 11/5/21 from Jonathan Carr, Head of Development Management, LCC re. appeal against refusal of planning application 20/06158/FU, 1 Farm Hill Mews (Scatcherd).

The above item of correspondence was noted.

10.       DATE AND TIME OF NEXT MEETING

The next scheduled meeting will be held on Tuesday, 20/7/2021 at 7.00 pm.

 

DRAFT MINUTES OF PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING NO. 413

 HELD ‘REMOTELY’ ON TUESDAY, 16^TH MARCH  2021 

1. TO RECORD ATTENDANCE                                                                                                                          Present:  Cllrs R Finnigan (Deputy Chairman), R Bell, C Taylor, M Storey, J Sanders and

A Dalton.

One member of the public and W Maynard-Light (Deputy Town Clerk) also attended.

2.         TO RECEIVE APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE GIVEN IN ADVANCE OF THE MEETING

There were no apologies.

 

3.         TO CONSIDER THE APPROVAL OF REASONS GIVEN FOR ABSENCE

None.           

4. DECLARATIONS OF DISCLOSABLE PECUNIARY AND OTHER INTERESTS

Cllr R Finnigan declared an ‘other’ interest in any relevant items, as he is a member of LCC Plans Panels.

5. TO APPROVE MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON 19/1/2021

The Minutes of the meeting held on 19/1/2021 were agreed as a true and correct record.

6. CONSIDERATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS

Notation of Recommendations.

O = Objection

N = No Objection

NC = No Objection (with comments)

D = Deferred

RECEIVED 1/3/21

N         21/01031  SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 8 ASTELL WAY (ELMFIELD).

N         21/01432  SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 7 ROSEATE GREEN (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 2/3/21

N         21/01285  SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION AND PORCH TO FRONT: 471 WESTERTON ROAD (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 9/3/21

N         21/01625  TWO-STOREY SIDE, SINGLE-STOREY SIDE/REAR EXTENSIONS INCLUDING ROOFLIGHTS: THE CROFT, DEWSBURY ROAD (WOODKIRK).

N         21/01678  TWO-STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 30 ARTHINGTON CLOSE (WOODKIRK).

The above planning applications were considered by all members of the Planning Committee present.

It was agreed that any comments be submitted via ‘Public Access’.

7. TO NOTE PLANNING APPLICATIONS WITH DECISIONS MADE UNDER DELEGATED AUTHORITY TO TOWN CLERK – STANDING ORDER 15(c) (APPLICATIONS RECEIVED THAT DID NOT APPEAR ON 17/11/2020 AGENDA) 

RECEIVED 13/1/21

N         20/08427  VARIATION OF CONDITION 1 (APPROVED PLANS) OF APPROVED 23/520/02/FU FOR MINOR MATERIAL AMENDMENT TO REVISE THE ORIGINAL APPROVED DRAWINGS: QUEENS HOUSE, 1 HIGH STREET (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 15/1/21

N         21/00149  SINGLE-STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 27 CROFT HOUSE VIEW (SCATCHERD).

N         21/00054  SINGLE-STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 196 WIDE LANE (TOPCLIFFE).

N         20/08596  SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION AND EXTENSION TO EXISTING GARAGE WITH NEW FIRST FLOOR TO EXISTING GARAGE WITH STEPS TO SIDE:  LANESIDE HOUSE, LANESIDE (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 18/1/21

N         20/08444  RETROSPECTIVE APPLICATION FOR EXISTING ACCESS GATE: LAND OFF THE GALLOPS (ELMFIELD).

N         21/00177  SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 14 IBBETSON CROFT (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 19/1/21

N         21/00147  SINGLE-STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 6 PEREGRINE AVENUE (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 21/1/21

N         21/00080  SINGLE-STOREY EXTENSION TO EXISTING GARGE: THORNFIELD, DEWSBURY ROAD (WOODKIRK).

N         21/00184  SINGLE-STOREY EXTENSION INCLUDING NEW PATIO AREA WITH STEPS AND RETAINING WALLS TO REAR, ALTERATIONS TO INTEGRAL GARAGE TO FORM HABITABLE ROOM: 12 THE OAKS (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 25/1/21

N         20/08263  ALTERATIONS INCLUDING TWO-STOREY AND SINGLE-STOREY FRONT, SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION INCLUDING DORMER WINDOWS TO SIDE AND REAR, CANOPY AND ROOF LIGHT TO FRONT: 74 SCOTCHMAN LANE (TEALE).

RECEIVED 26/1/21

N         21/00408  RESERVED MATTERS APPLICATION FOR ONE DWELLING HOUSE: LAND ADJOINING 4A SYKE ROAD (WOODKIRK).

N         21/00396  PART SINGLE-STOREY PART TWO-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 8 IBBETSON CLOSE (CHURWELL).

N         21/00451  ALTERATIONS INCLUDING CONVERSION OF GARAGE TO HABITABLE ROOM TO INCLUDE NEW ENTRANCE DOOR: 14 TEAL DRIVE (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 28/1/21

N         21/00479  DEMOLITION OF EXISTING DETACHED GARAGE AND CONSTRUCTION OF A SINGLE-STOREY SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION; NEW DECKING TO SIDE: 10 BANTAM CLOSE (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 1/2/21

N         21/00021  REPLACEMENT SHOP FRONT: 62 QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL)

N         21/00586  PART TWO-STOREY PART SINGLE-STOREY SIDE/REAR EXTENSION:

61 VICTORIA ROAD (SCATCHERD).

N         21/00480  CHANGE OF USE OF TAXI OFFICES TO BAKERY; INSTALLATION OF EXTRACTOR FAN TO EXISTING WINDOW: 51B COMMERCIAL STREET (CENTRAL).

21/00815/TR  T1 SYCAMORE – PULL LATERAL BRANCHES BACK TO GIVE 4 METRES CLEARANCE FROM THE PROPERTY. NUISANCE AND LIGHT ISSUES: T2 SYCAMORE TREE – REDUCTION OF UP TO A MAXIMUM OF 3 METRES IS RECOMMENDED LEAVING A BALANCED AND EVEN-SHAPED CROWN. LATERAL REDUCTION OF THE CROWN IS CARRIED OUT TO REDUCE THE LENGTH OF LIMBS AND REDUCE THE WEIGHT. THIS WILL ALSO REDUCE THE SAIL OF THE TREE’S CROWN REDUCING PRESSURE ON BRANCH UNIONS IN STRONG WINDS: 2 LANESIDE MEWS (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 2/2/21

N         20/08482  TWO NEW SEMI-DETACHED DWELLINGS: BUTTERWORTH HALL, 25 HIGH STREET (ELMFIELD).

RECEIVED 4/2/21

O         21/00265  DEMOLISH GARAGE BLOCK, ERECTION OF BUNGALOW WITH OFF ROAD PARKING: LOCK UP GARAGE SITE, REAR OF 26 AND 28 DAISY HILL AVENUE (SCATCHERD).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of inappropriate development in the Greenbelt.

RECEIVED 9/2/21

N         21/00898/TR  T1 – BLACK POPLAR: LARGE MATURE STEM, HAS BEEN POLLARDED AT LEAST TWICE, TREE CAUSES MASSIVE SHADING FOR NUMEROUS PROPERTIES. CLIENT DOES NOT WANT TO REMOVE TREE, SO PROPOSED WORKS ARE TO RETURN TREE TO PREVIOUS POLLARD CUTS: 36 TROY ROAD (CENTRAL).

N         21/00827  FIRST-FLOOR FRONT EXTENSION: 33 HARWILL APPROACH (CHURWELL).

O         21/00083  HOME HAIRDRESSING SALON WITH ONE WORKSTATION: 2 WEAVER GARDENS (TOPCLIFFE).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of insufficient information on the application form to make an informed decision, together with insufficient parking spaces.  The applicant is relying on the space available at the adjacent apartment block.  Also the lack of clarity on the hand drawn design, with no indication where the workstation will be situated.

RECEIVED 10/2/21

N         21/00325  INSTALLATION OF A NEW TIMBER PERGOLA TO AN EXISTING EXTERNAL DRINKING AREA 3 NUMBER TIMBER POSTS WITH FESTOON LIGHTING ON TENSILE WIRES: NEEDLESS INN, SCOTCHMAN LANE (TEALE).

RECEIVED 11/2/21

N         21/00954  ALTERATIONS INCLUDING SINGLE-STOREY EXTENSION TO FRONT; NEW ROOF AND ALTERATIONS  TO FORM GARAGE; FIRST-FLOOR EXTENSION TO SIDE; CONVERSION OF LOFT TO HABITABLE ROOMS INCLUDING ROOF LIGHTS TO REAR; NEW DOORS TO SIDE AND REAR ELEVATIONS: 132 DEWSBURY ROAD (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 12/2/21

N         21/00929  SINGLE-STOREY SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION AND PORCH TO FRONT:

59 RYEDALE WAY (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 16/2/21

N         21/00953  TWO-STOREY SIDE EXTENSION WITH DORMER WINDOWS TO FRONT AND REAR, INCORPORATING A NEW GARAGE: 7 HARWILL RISE (CHURWELL).

O         21/01043  PART SINGLE-STOREY, PART TWO-STOREY REAR EXTENSION; NEW WINDOW TO FIRST-FLOOR FRONT ELEVATION, RAISED ROOF INCORPORATING DORMER TO REAR: 15 SCARBOROUGH STREET (WOODKIRK).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of over-development of the site, impact on the street scene and residential amenity.

RECEIVED 19/2/21

N         21/01056  PART GROUND-FLOOR EXTENSION AND FIRST-FLOOR EXTENSION: UNIT 1, HOWLEY PARK CLOSE (TEALE).

RECEIVED 23/2/21

O         21/01156  REPLACEMENT OF DORMER TO FRONT: 10 LONSDALE RISE, TINGLEY (WOODKIRK).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of impact on the street scene.

RECEIVED 2/3/21

N         21/01732/TR  T1 ROWAN – REMOVAL INCLUDING STUMP AND RE-PLANTING OF TWO BETULA JACQUEMONTII STANDARD SIZE: 18A REIN ROAD (ELMFIELD).

RECEIVED 3/3/21

N         21/00834/TR  T1 & T2 – SYCAMORE AT FRONT OF HOUSE. REDUCE CANOPY BY 30% (4M) DUE TO EXCESSIVE SHADING AND RISK OF BRANCHES DROPPING ONTO ROOF. REQUEST IS ALL ROUND REDUCTION TO KEEP BALANCE OF TREES.  T3 & T4 – SYCAMORE AT BACK. REDUCE CANOPY BY 30% (4M) DUE TO EXCESSIVE SHADING AND RISK OF BRANCHES DROPPING ONTO ROOF. BRANCHES ARE HANGING HIGH OVER ROOF OF PROPERTY. REQUEST IS ALL ROUND REDUCTION TO KEEP BALANCE OF TREES: THE OAKS, ROOMS LANE (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 9/3/21

N         21/01947/TR  G1 SELF SEEDED SYCAMORE – REMOVE AS OVER SHADING PROPERTIES AT 16 & 18 BANTAM VIEW GROVE; G2 SELF SEEDED SYCAMORES – REDUCE IN HEIGHT TO 4 METRES; T1, T2 MATURE SYCAMORES – REDUCING IN HEIGHT BY 4 METRES AND CROWN LIFT BOTH T1 AND T2 UP TO 2 METRES: 16 BANTAM GROVE VIEW (TOPCLIFFE).

The above decisions made under Town Clerk’s delegated authority, were noted.

8. TO NOTE CONTENT OF PRE-CONSULTATION EMAIL FROM M ELLIOT, HEAD OF STRATEGIC PLANNING, LCC, RE. HMO, PBSA AND CO-LIVING AMENITY STANDARDS SPD (CLOSING DATE 1/3/21)

            This item was noted. 

9. TO RECEIVE ITEMS OF CORRESPONDENCE (items for information only)

(a)        Letter dated 19/1/21 from J Carr, Head of Development Management, LCC, re. appeal against refusal of planning application 20/05527/FU Land at New Bank Street (Scatcherd).

(b)        Email dated 25/1/21 from YLCA, regarding ‘The Right to Regenerate’.

(c)        Email dated 29/1/21 from Kirklees Council re. ‘Kirklees Community Infrastructure Levy (CIL) Update’.

(d)        Letter dated 23/2/21 from Planning Services, LCC, re. Appeal against refusal, AP/N4720/W/21/3267217 – G           ardeners Arms, Wide Lane.

All of the above items of correspondence were noted.

10. DATE AND TIME OF NEXT MEETING                                                                                                                 The next scheduled meeting date will be determined at the Annual Meeting to be held on 5^th May 2021.

 

MINUTES OF EXTRAORDINARY PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING NO. 412

HELD ‘REMOTELY’ ON THURSDAY, 18TH FEBRUARY 2021

1. TO RECORD ATTENDANCE

Present:  Cllrs H Evans (Chairman), R Finnigan, R Bell, C Taylor, M Storey and J Sanders.

W Maynard-Light (Deputy Town Clerk) also attended.

2.         TO RECEIVE APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE GIVEN IN ADVANCE OF THE MEETING

There were no apologies.

3.         TO CONSIDER THE APPROVAL OF REASONS GIVEN FOR ABSENCE

None.

4. Declarations of Disclosable Pecuniary and Other Interests

Cllr R Finnigan declared an ‘other’ interest in any relevant items, as he is a member of LCC Plans Panel.

5. TO CONSIDER AND APPROVE FINANCIAL CONTRIBUTION OF £500 TO CHIDSWELL ACTION GROUP TOWARDS LEGAL COSTS

Cllr Finnigan gave a verbal overview of the history behind the Chidswell Action Group’s challenge through the legal process against Kirklees Council’s plans to build 1,550 houses and an industrial unit on a section of Green Belt.  The completion of this would have serious implications on the highways, in particular A643 and J28/M62, together with demands on the infrastructure of Morley impacting on the already over-subscribed schools, doctors and dentists.  It was proposed and agreed to approve Chidswell Action Group’s request for £500 contribution to assist with legal costs.

 

DRAFT MINUTES OF PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING NO. 411

HELD ‘REMOTELY’ ON TUESDAY, 19TH JANUARY 2021

1.         TO RECORD ATTENDANCE

Present:  Cllrs H Evans (Chairman), R Finnigan, R Bell, C Taylor, M Storey and A Dalton.

K Oakley (Town Clerk) also attended.

2.         TO RECEIVE APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE GIVEN IN ADVANCE OF THE MEETING
There were no apologies.

3.         TO CONSIDER THE APPROVAL OF REASONS GIVEN FOR ABSENCE
None.

4.         DECLARATIONS OF DISCLOSABLE PECUNIARY AND OTHER INTERESTS

Cllr R Finnigan declared an ‘other’ interest in any relevant items, as he is a member of two LCC Plans Panels.

5.         TO APPROVE MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON 17/11/2020

The Minutes of the meeting held on 17/11/2020 were agreed as a true and correct record.

6.         CONSIDERATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS

Notation of Recommendations.
O = Objection
N = No Objection
NC = No Objection (with comments)
D = Deferred

RECEIVED 5/1/21

N         20/08510  REMOVAL OF CONDITION NO. 9 (LAY-BY PROVISION) TO PREVIOUSLY APPROVED PLANNING APPLICATION 23/520/02/FU TO LIMIT THE USE CLASS OF THE PROPOSED LOWER GROUND FLOOR RETAIL UNIT TO CLASS E(c), WHICH DOES NOT REQUIRE DELIVERIES AS PART OF THEIR BUSINESS: QUEENS HOUSE, 1 HIGH STREET (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 8/1/21

N         20/08532  VARIATION OF CONDITION 2 (APPROVED PLANS) OF APPROVAL 19/07911/FU FOR MINOR MATERIAL AMENDMENT TO AMEND APPROVED PLANNING DRAWINGS: LAND ADJACENT TO WHITE ROSE OFFICE PARK AND MILLSHAW INDUSTRIAL PARK, MILLSHAW LANE (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED  11/1/21

N         20/08577  SINGLE-STOREY SIDE/REAR EXTENSION: 33 SCATCHERD LANE (TEALE).

RECEIVED 12/1/21

N         21/00072  SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 46 IBBETSON OVAL (CHURWELL).

The above planning applicatiions were considered by all members of the Planning Committee present.

It was agreed that any comments be submitted via ‘Public Access’.

7.         TO NOTE PLANNING APPLICATIONS WITH DECISIONS MADE UNDER DELEGATED AUTHORITY TO TOWN CLERK – STANDING ORDER 15(c) (APPLICATIONS RECEIVED THAT DID NOT APPEAR ON 17/11/2020 AGENDA)

RECEIVED 16/11/20

N         07174  INSTALLATION OF 1 X ELECTRIC VEHICLE CHARGE POINT ALONGISDE EXISTING CAR-PARKING SPACE, WITH ANCILLARY BOLLARDS, POWER UNIT, FEEDER PILLAR AND SIGNAGE: SHELL WOODMAN SERVICE STATION, DEWSBURY ROAD (CHURWELL).

N         07239  SINGLE-STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 2 TURNBERRY GARDENS (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 17/11/20

N         06807  ALTERATIONS TO HARD-STANDING TO CREATE 15 NEW CAR PARKING SPACES: FUTURE EINSTEINS NURSERY, ALL SAINTS CHURCH, ELLAND ROAD (CHURWELL).

N         07226  SINGLE-STOREY FRONT EXTENSION; PART SINGLE-STOREY PART TWO-STOREY SIDE/REAR EXTENSION; DORMER WINDOW TO REAR: 23 WOODLANDS DRIVE (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 24/11/20

N         07452  SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION, INSERTION OF WINDOW TO SIDE: 19 PEREGRINE AVENUE (TOPCLIFFE).

N         07302  SINGLE-STOREY GARDEN STORE TO EXISTING FLATS: COLEMAN COURT, 70 HIGH STREET (ELMFIELD).

RECEIVED 26/11/20

O         07605  VARIATION OF CONDITION 7 (LANDSCAPE PLAN AND IMPLEMENTATION SCHEDULE) OF PREVIOUSLY APPROVED APPLICATION 18/01508/FU TO REQUEST THAT APPROVAL OF MATERIALS BE DELAYED UNTIL NEARER THE TIME AT WHICH THEY ARE REQUIRED: VAYNOL GATE, ROOMS LANE (SCATCHERD).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds the delay would exacerbate the negative impact on the neighbours adjacent to the development.  The previously agreed landscaping would mitigate the impact of the large houses of the development.

RECEIVED 30/11/20

N         07367  DRIVEWAY TO FRONT: 102 ELLAND ROAD (CHURWELL).

N         07901/TR  T1 – ROWAN – REDUCE AWAY FROM THE LAMP POST BACK TO THE MAIN STEM ROUGHLY 0.5 METRE: T2 – SILVER BIRCH – REDUCE FROM PROPERTY (TOUCHING THE ROOF) BACK TO STEM OR SUITABLE GROWTH POINT AROUND 2 METRE: T3 – BEECH – REDUCE THE CROWN BY 1-1.5 METRE: T4 – SILVER BIRTH – REDUCE IN HEIGHT BY 4-5 METRE: 9 HARGREAVES CLOSE (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 1/12/20

N         07738  TIMBER BIN STORE TO FRONT: TIMBER PERGOLA TO REAR: 54 WOODCROSS FOLD (CHURWELL).

N         07075  ERECTION OF A WIRE FENCE ON TOP OF AN EXISTING WALL: MORLEY CRICKET & SPORTS CLUB, SCATCHERD LANE (TEALE).

RECEIVED 2/12/20

O         07570  TWO-STOREY PART SINGLE-STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 33 BRIDGE COURT (ELMFIELD).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds the proposed extension removes the available off-street parking space on the property.

N         07786  SINGLE-STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 17 HARWILL CROFT (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 4/12/20

O         07805  DORMER WINDOW TO REAR: 16A KING STREET (CENTRAL).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of the impact on the street, as there are no other front dormers in the adjacent properties.

N         07811  DEMOLITION OF EXISTING GARAGE AND REPLACEMENT WITH OUTBUILDING TO REAR: 52 REIN ROAD (ELMFIELD).

N         07767  SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 1A WOODKIRK AVENUE (TINGLEY).

N         07870  NEW TILED ROOF TO CONSERVATORY TO REAR: 9 IBBETSON CROFT (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 9/12/20

N         07881  TWO-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: BANK HOUSE COTTAGE, BANK AVENUE (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 17/12/20

O         08185  CONVERSION AND SINGLE-STOREY EXTENSION TO GARAGE TO FORM HABITABLE ANNEXE WITH ROOFLIGHTS; SINGLE-STOREY LINK EXTENSION; NEW HARDSTANDING: 10 WINDERS DALE (SCATCHERD).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of overdevelopment of the site and insufficient parking for two vehicles.

RECEIVED 18/12/20

N         08071  DWELLING TO VACANT SITE: LAND TO REAR OF 1-3 SPRINGFIELD CRESENT (SCATCHERD).

N         08382/TR  T1 SYCAMORE – REMOVE, INDLUDING GRINDING OUT OF THE STUMP/ROOTS TO A DEPTH OF APPROX 300MM AND THE REPLANTING OF 1 NO. SYCAMORE IN A LOCATION TO BE AGREED IN CONJUNCTION WITH LCC AT A DISTANCE NOT LESS THAN 10 METRES FROM OUR EXISTING PROPERTY: CASTLE CROFT, 47 ROOMS LANE (SCATCHERD).

RECIVED 21/12/20

N         08242  RAISING ROOF HEIGHT FORMING A FIRST FLOOR; DORMER WINDOW TO REAR; NEW FIRST FLOOR WINDOW TO SIDE; SINGLE STOREY TO FRONT EXTENSION; SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION AND SINGLE STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 386 WESTERTON ROAD (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 22/12/20

N         08305  TWO-STOREY SIDE/REAR EXTENSION: 3 CAMBRIDGE CLOSE (CENTRAL).

O         08361  ONE NEW DWELLING: 2 HIGHCLIFFE ROAD (TEALE).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of overdevelopment of the site, concerns of safety on the highways and the proximity of the development to the school’s main entrance, together with the negative impact on the street scene.

RECEIVED 11/1/21

N         21/00113/TR  T1 – SYCAMORE – REDUCE BY 3 METRES AWAY FROM HOUSE ON THORNVILLE PLACE WHICH IT IS CURRENTLY TOUCHING AND ALSO 3 METRES FROM GARDEN SIDE TO REBALANCE THE CANOPY: T2 AND T3 LARGE ASH -SHOWING SIGNS OF STRESS WITH MUCH REACTION GROWTH ALONG ALL LIMBS AND OVER PRODUCTION OF ASH KEYS. SUSPECT FIRST SIGNS OF HYMENOSCYPHUS FRAXINEUS.  SUGGESTED COURSE OF ACTION FOR NOW WOULD BE THOROUGH DEADWOOD REMOVAL. DUE TO THE LOCATION OF THE TREE WHICH ARE TOWERING OVER THE TERRACED HOUESES ON THE STREETS BEHIND I WOULD SUGGEST THAT A SITE VISIT BY A TREE OFFICER MAY BE APPROPRIATE: 3 GRANGE PARK CLOSE (CHURWELL).

The above decisions made under Town Clerk’s delegated authority, were noted.

8.         TO DISCUSS CONTENT OF LETTER FROM HOLME VALLEY PARISH COUNCIL RE.  NOTIFICATION OF PUBLICITY (CONSULTATION) OF THE HOLME VALLEY NEIGHBOURHOOD DEVELOPMENT PLAN UNDER REGULATION 16 OF THE NEIGHBOURHOOD PLANNING (GENERAL) REGULATIONS 2012 (AS AMENDED) AND CONSIDER ANY RESPONSE .

The content of the above letter, was noted.

9.         TO DISCUSS CONTENT OF EMAIL FROM MARTIN ELLIOT, HEAD OF STRATEGIC PLANNING LCC RE. LEEDS SITE ALLOCATIONS PLAN – CONSULTATION ON LEEDS CITY COUNCIL’S PROPOSED MAIN MODIFICATION TO THE REMITTED PART OF THE SITE ALLOCATIONS PLAN .

The content of the above email, was noted.

10.       TO CONSIDER CONTENT OF PRE-CONSULTATION LETTER FROM JULIA MARSHALL, WHP TELECOM LTD RE. SITE CTIL 112893, TEF 18475, VF N/A – SIMS METAL MANAGEMENT, ALBERT ROAD (TOPCLIFFE).

The content of the above letter, was noted.

11.       TO RECEIVE ITEMS OF CORRESPONDENCE (items for information only)

(a)        Email dated 11/11/20 from J Marshall, WHP Telecoms Ltd, pre-consultation letter re. proposed base station installation upgrade at Williams Tankers Ltd, Howley Park Estate (Elmfield) – closing date 25/11/2020.

(b)        Email dated 23/11/20 from Mathias Franklin, Head of Planning and Development, Kirklees Council re. consultation on the Kirklees Council quality places supplementary planning documents – closing date 14/12/2020.

(c)        Email dated 24/11/20 with attachments from Catherine Britten, Sterling Capitol re. development proposals at Capitol Park, Leeds – online Public Consultation (Topcliffe).

(d)        Email dated 26/11/20 with attachments from Suzi Help, WHP Telecoms Ltd re. pre-planning consultation – proposed base station installation upgrade Sims Metal Management, 109 Albert Road (Topcliffe) – closing date 10/12/2020.

All of the above items of correspondence, were noted.

12.       DATE AND TIME OF NEXT MEETING

The next meeting is scheduled to be held on Tuesday, 16th March 2021 at 7pm.

 

MINUTES OF ‘REMOTE’ PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING NO. 410

HELD ON TUESDAY, 17TH NOVEMBER 2020

1.         TO RECORD ATTENDANCE

Present:  Councillors R Finnigan (Deputy Chairman), J Sanders, M Storey, C Taylor and

A Dalton.

W Maynard-Light (Deputy Town Clerk) also attended.

2.         TO RECEIVE AND NOTE APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE AND CONSIDER REASONS GIVEN FOR NON-ATTENDANCE
Apologies were received from Cllrs H Evans and the reason given for non-attendance were accepted.

3.         Declarations of Disclosable Pecuniary and Other Interests

Cllr R Finnigan declared an ‘other’ interest in any appropriate items, as he is a member of Leeds Plans Panel, LCC.

4.         TO APPROVE MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON 22/9/20

The minutes of the meeting held on 22/9/20 were agreed as a true and correct record.

5.         CONSIDERATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS

Notation of Recommendations.
O = Objection
N = No Objection
NC = No Objection (with comments)
D = Deferred

RECEIVED 28/10/20

N         06815  VARIATION OF CONDITION NO. 2 (APPROVED PLANS) TO PREVIOUSLY APPROVED PLANNING APPLICATION 18/01506/FU FOR ALTERATIONS TO THE APPROVED PLANS: VAYNOL GATE, ROOMS LANE (SCATCHERD).

O         05892  DEMOLITION OF EXISTING GARAGE AND CONSTRUCTION OF ONE PAIR OF SEMI-DETACHED DWELLING WITH PARKING AND ASSOCIATED WORKS: LAND OFF GRANNY PLACE (CHURWELL).

MTC objected to this application on the grounds of a significant overdevelopment of the site, limited parking space available for vehicles for two residences, inadequate garden space and the overall bedroom sizes not in line with current guidelines/regulations.

RECEIVED 29/10/20

N         06461  ALTERATIONS INCLUDING SINGLE STOREY SIDE/REAR EXTENSION INCORPORATING RAISED DECKING AREA, STEPS AND ACCESS RAMP WITH BALUSTRADE ABOVE: 18 REIN ROAD (ELMFIELD).

O         06731  SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION; CONVERSION OF GARAGE TO FORM A HABITABLE ROOM, CONVERSION OF SECOND FLOOR TO FORM HABITABLE ROOMS; DORMER WINDOW TO REAR: 15 SEVEN HILL CLOSE (SCATCHERD).

MTC objected to this application on the grounds of the impact on the street scene.

RECEIVED 4/11/20

N         06741  CHANGE OF USE FROM AMUSEMENT CENTRE TO RETAIL SHOP, INCORPORATING NEW SHOP FRONT: 93 QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

N         06469  ALTERATIONS INVOLVING CONVERSION OF DETACHED GARAGE TO HABITABLE ACCOMMODATION: 8 CURLEW RISE (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 6/11/20

N         07053  SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION; DORMER WINDOWS TO FRONT & REAR; ALTERATIONS TO WINDOWS AND DOORS TO SIDE: 32 MANOR FARM DRIVE (CHURWELL).

The above planning applications were considered by all members of the Planning Committee present.

It was agreed that any comments be submitted via ‘Public Access’.

6.         TO NOTE PLANNING APPLICATIONS WITH DECISIONS MADE UNDER DELEGATED AUTHORITY TO TOWN CLERK – STANDING ORDER 15(c) (APPLICATIONS RECEIVED THAT DID NOT APPEAR ON 18/2/2020 AGENDA)

RECEIVED 22/9/20

O         05625  ALTERATIONS TO FLAT ABOVE RETAIL SHOP UNIT TO FORM TWO STUDIO APARTMENTS: 24 CHAPEL HILL (SCATCHERD).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds there is no parking, over intensive development of the unit and one-bedroom flats encourages transient occupation.

O         05809  DORMER WINDOW TO REAR: 16A KING STREET (CENTRAL).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds there are no dormers on this stretch and the impact on the visible street scene to the rear.

RECEIVED 23/9/20

N         05805  SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 41 NEW PARK STREET (TEALE).

N         05799  SINGLE-STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 39 PAWSON STREET (TEALE).

N         06054  SINGLE-STOREY FRONT AND REAR EXTENSION: 1 KING GEORGE CROFT (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 24/9/20

NC       05849  TWO-STOREY SIDE AND SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION; NEW BAY WINDOW TO FRONT; JULIET BALCONY AND BALUSTRADE TO REAR; GARAGE TO FRONT: 56 SPRINGFIELD ROAD (SCATCHERD).

MTC has no objection in principle but would comment that the rear dormer box should be removed from the plan.

RECEIVED 28/9/20

O         05597  ONE NEW DWELLING: LAND AT 2 HIGHCLIFFE ROAD (TEALE).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of over-development of the site, the proposed four-bedroomed house on limited space, the impact on the street scene together with concerns about highway safety as it is felt it is too near a school’s main car park entrance.

RECEIVED 29/9/20

O         05876  ERECTION OF ONE DETACHED DWELLING: LAND ADJACENT 6 CROFT HOUSE ROAD (SCATCHERD).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds there are no front dormers in the vicinity, impact on the residential amenity and negative impact on the street scene.

RECEIVED 30/9/20

N         05612  ALTERATIONS INCLUDING NEW FEATURE ENTRANCE, TWO ESCAPE DOORS, ACCESS RAMPS, ROOF TOP PLANT AREA, WORKS TO PARKING AREA AND ASSOCIATED LANDSCAPING: ARLINGTON BUSINESS CENTRE, MILLSHAW PARK LANE (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 1/10/20

N         06096  SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 6 PARTRIDGE CLOSE (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 6/10/20

N         06158  RETROSPECTIVE APPLICATION FOR STORE TO FRONT: 1 FARM HILL MEWS (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 7/10/20

O         06232  TWO-STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 17 SCATCHERD LANE (TEALE).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds the extension would not leave sufficient space for parking of two vehicles.

N         06440/TR  T1 FIELD MAPLE – REDUCE THE TREE BY 1.5M LEAVING TREE APPROX 4M IN HEIGHT WITH A SPREAD OF 3.5M, INCLUDING A CROWN THIN BETWEEN 10-15%.   REASON BEHIND THE WORK REQUEST IS TO ALLOW MORE LIGHT IN TO THE GARDEN AND CLEAR AWAY FROM NEIGHBOUR’S GARAGE ROOF: 19 DARTMOUTH MEWS (TEALE).

N         06170  LOFT CONVERSION, ROOF LIGHTS TO FRONT AND REAR: 2 CROSS HALL MEWS (ELMFIELD).

NC       05871  RETROSPECTIVE APPLICATION FOR CHANGE OF USE OF SHOP TO CAFÉ/RESTAURANT, INSTALLATION OF RETRACTABLE CANOPIES TO SHOP FRONTS. EXTRACTOR DUCT TO THE REAR: MORLEY GROCERY AND POLISH SHOP, 30 QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

MTC has no objection in principle to this application, however, would suggest conditions be applied to include retraction of the canopies and confirmation from Environmental Health the extractor duct will not impact by noise or smell on the residents of Queens Court and adjacent businesses.

RECEIVED 8/10/20

N         06436/TR  T3 TILA X VULGARIS – REMOVAL OF DECAYING LIMB WITHIN CENTRAL CANOPY AND REDUCE REMAINING CANOPY BY 3 METRES TO RE-BALANCE AGAINST THE REMOVAL OF DECAYING LIMB; T5 TILIA X VULGARIS – LATERAL REDUCTION ON ROADSIDE OF 3 METRES TO REDUCE WEIGHT OF IMBALANCED CANOPY, REMOVAL OF DEAD WOOD: 58A BRIDGE STREET (ELMFIELD).

N         06293  SINGLE-STOREY SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION: 38 GRANGE PARK DRIVE (CHURWELL).

O         06095  CONVERSION OF GARAGE TO HABITABLE ROOM: 10 HAROLD GARDENS (TOPCLIFFE).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds the conversion will not leave parking space for two vehicles.

RECEIVED 12/10/20

N         06286  DEMOLITION OF EXISTING VACANT PUBLIC HOUSE AND THE ERECTION OF TWO PAIRS OF SEMI-DETACHED DWELLINGS:  FORMER SHOULDER OF MUTTON, HOWDEN CLOUGH ROAD (TEALE).

RECEIVED 13/10/20

NC       05997  DETACHED SHELTER: GARDENERS ARMS, WIDE LANE (TOPCLIFFE).

MTC has no objection in principle to this application, however, would like a condition to be applied for temporary permission to be granted for one year.

RECEIVED 16/10/20

NC       06591  TWO-STOREY AND SINGLE-STOREY FRONT, SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION: 19 EARLSMERE DRIVE (SCATCHERD).

MTC has no objection in principle, however, a condition should be applied for the frontage to be Tarmacked to make a formal second parking space.

N         06481  DORMER WINDOW TO REAR; RAISING OF RIDGE HEIGHT: 24 WHARFEDALE RISE (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 20/10/20

N         06642  ALTERATIONS INCLUDING SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION, CONVERSION OF GARAGE TO HABITABLE ROOM SPACE AND PORCH TO FRONT: 45 TOPCLIFFE GROVE (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 22/10/20

O         05725  CHANGE OF USE FROM DWELLING HOUSE TO A BASEMENT FLAT AND HOUSE OF MULTIPLE OCCUPATION ABOVE (HMO); EXTERNAL STAIRCASE WITH RAILING AND ACCESS DOOR TO BASEMENT TO BASEMENT FRONT AND SIDE: 14 ELLAND ROAD (CHURWELL).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of over-development of the site, inadequate parking for the number of flats (4), room size and lack of green space.

N         05394  GABLE END LOFT CONVERSION AND DORMER WINDOW TO REAR: 81 ELLAND ROAD (CHURWELL).

The above decisions made under Town Clerk’s delegated authority, were noted.

7.         TO DISCUSS AND AGREE PLANNING COMMITTEE BUDGET SUBMISSION FOR 2021/22 (for referral to the Finance, GP & Strategic Committee).

Following a discussion, it was proposed and agreed a budget for 2021/22 of £1,000.

8.         TO RECEIVE ITEMS OF CORRESPONDENCE (items for information only)

(a)        Letter dated 28/9/20 from Jonathan Carr, Head of Development Management, LCC re. appeal against refusal of planning application 20/01932/FU 19 South Queen Street (Central).

(b)        Updated key planning enforcement cases for Morley North and South Wards.

(c)        Email 21/10/20 from Head of Planning and Development, Kirklees Council, re. ‘Consultation on the Kirklees Council Quality Places Supplementary Planning Documents’.

(d)        Letter dated 21/10/20 from Jonathan Carr, Head of Development, LCC re. appeal against refusal of planning application 20/03783/FU 25a Harwill Avenue (Churwell).

(e)        Letter dated 21/10/20 from Steve Dobie, Compliance Officer, LCC re. possible breach of planning control, re. planning appn 20/01091/UHD3, 24 Chapel Hill (Scatcherd).

All the above items of correspondence were noted.

9.         DATE AND TIME OF NEXT MEETING

The next scheduled meeting will be held on Tuesday, 19th January 2021 at 7pm.

 

MINUTES OF PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING NO. 409

HELD ‘REMOTELY’ ON TUESDAY, 22^ND SEPTEMBER 2020 AT 7PM

1. TO ELECT DEPUTY CHAIRMAN FOR 2020/21

A nomination was made in respect of Cllr R Finnigan, this was seconded.  Cllr Finnigan was elected as Deputy Chairman for 2020/21.

2. TO RECORD ATTENDANCE

Present:  Cllrs H Evans (Chairman), R Finnigan, C Taylor, M Storey, J Sanders and A Dalton (late arrival).  K Oakley – Town Clerk also attended.

3.         TO RECEIVE AND NOTE APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE AND CONSIDER REASONS GIVEN FOR NON-ATTENDANCE

Apologies were received from Cllrs A Rhodes and R Bell and reasons given for non-attendance were approved.

4. Declarations of Disclosable Pecuniary and Other Interests

Cllr R Finnigan declared an ‘other’ interest in any relevant items as he is an LCC ward Member.

5. TO APPROVE MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON 4/8/2020

The Minutes of the Extraordinary Meeting held on 4/8/20 were approved as a true and correct record.

6. CONSIDERATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS

Notation of Recommendations.

O = Objection

N = No Objection

NC = No Objection (with comments)

D = Deferred

RECEIVED 3/9/20

N         05144  SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 15 CLARK SPRING RISE (CHURWELL).

Cllr A Dalton ‘remotely’ joined the meeting at this point.

O         05118  CONVERSION OF GARAGE TO HABITABLE ROOMS: 2 WIGEON APPROACH

(TOPCLIFFE).   MTC objected to this appn as it was felt there was insufficient parking space for 2 vehicles and this would be unsafe.

RECEIVED 8/9/20

N         05268  PART TWO-STOREY, PART SINGLE-STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 1 CLARK SPRING RISE (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 9/9/20

O         05334   TWO-STOREY FRONT AND SIDE EXTENSION AND SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 1 FARM HILL ROAD (SCATCHERD).  MTC objected to this appn as it was felt it was very close to over-development of the site, construction should be brick and not render and would have a negative impact on the street scene.

RECEIVED 10/9/20

N         05442  SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 91 SCOTCHMAN LANE (ELMFIELD).

N         05318  TWO-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 29 THE ROUNDWAY (TEALE).

RECEIVED 11/9/20

N         04103  RETROSPECTIVE APPLICATION FOR CHANGE OF USE OF PART OF GRASSED AREA TO MENAGE ARENA: HOWLEY PARK COTTAGE, HOWLEY MILL LANE (ELMFIELD).

RECEIVED 14/9/20

N         05489  VARIATION OF CONDITION 2 (APPOVED PLANS) AND CONDITION 4 (WINDOWS) OF PLANNING PERMISSION 18/01506/FU FOR REAR KITCHEN WINDOW IN PLACE OF BI-FOLD DOORS, SMALL WINDOW IN PLACE OF DOOR ON GABLE ELEVATION TO PLOT 2 AND CHANGE RENDER COLOUR TO GARDENIA FOR PLOT 1; PLOT 2 WINDOWS TO BE ANTHRACITE GREY AND CENTRAL GLAZING BAR REMOVED FROM ALL WINDOWS TO PLOTS 1 AND 2: VAYNOL GATE, ROOMS LANE (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 15/9/20

N         05536  SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 214 SCOTCHMAN LANE (ELMFIELD).

N         05550  SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 17 WILLIAM STREET (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 16/9/20

O         05527  FOUR TERRACED HOUSES: LAND AT NEW BANK STREET (SCATCHERD).  MTC objected to this appn due to over-development of the site, parking problems and quality of design.

7. TO NOTE PLANNING APPLICATIONS WITH DECISIONS MADE UNDER DELEGATED AUTHORITY TO TOWN CLERK – STANDING RDER 15(c) (APPLICATIONS RECEIVED THAT DID NOT APPEAR ON 4/8/2020 AGENDA)

RECEIVED 31/7/20

NC       04300  PART SINGLE-STOREY PART TWO-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 1 ALBERT DRIVE (TOPCLIFFE).  MTC has no objection in principle to this application.  However, it is suggested that a dropped kerb be installed for access to the property.

RECEIVED 5/8/20

N         04751/TR  T1 SILVER BIRCH  –  FELL AS TREE HAS OUTGROWN LOCATION, OWNERS WISHING TO LANDSCAPE GARDEN, LOW AMENITY VALUE: 7 NORTON WAY (SCATCHERD).

N         04827/TR  5-DAY NOTICE FOR TREE REMOVAL. 5 TREES IN CONSERVATION AREA CAUSING DAMAGE TO WALL: 77-85 QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 12/8/20

N         04587  PART TWO-STOREY, PART SINGLE-STOREY SIDE/REAR EXTENSION: SINGLE- STOREY FRONT EXTENSION WITH CANOPY: 13 SYKE ROAD (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 13/8/20

O         05014/TR  T2 – OAK, T3 – FIR, T4 – OAK, ALL FELL TO GROUND LEVEL. REASON – OVERHANGING/DANGEROUS BRANCHES POSING RISK TO CHILDREN, PETS AND CONSERVATORY AND HIGH AMOUNTS OF SAP AND BIRD DROPPINGS WHICH HAVE DAMAGED GARDEN FURNITURE AND ARTIFICIAL GRASS. REPLANT – ENGLISH OAK QUERCUS ROBUR IN THE SAME LOCATION:  CASTLE CROFT, 47 ROOMS LANE (SCATCHERD).  MTC objects to this application on the grounds there is no good reason to fell established trees.

NC       04652  SINGLE-STOREY FRONT, SIDE AND REAR EXTENSIONS: 386 WESTERTON ROAD (WOODKIRK).  MTC has no objection in principle to this application, however, a condition should  be applied to provide two parking spaces at the property.

RECEIVED 14/8/20

N         04679  CHANGE OF USE FROM OFFICE (OFFICE B1) TO RESIDENTIAL (CLASS B3): 29 HIGH STREET (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 17/8/20

N         04983/TR  3 TREES GROWING THROUGH PHONE LINES (T1 – LIME, T2 – SYCAMORE, T3 – ELM), CLEAR GROWTH AWAY FROM THE LINES.  I WON’T BE CUTTING ANYTHING BIGGER THAN 4 INCHES IN DIAMETER (100MM), WORKS WILL BE CARRIED OUT TO BS3998: ST PAUL’S CHURCH, KING STREET (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 19/8/20

O         04762  OUTBUILDING REAR: 51 ROOMS LANE (SCATCHERD).  MTC objects to this application on the grounds of too close to the boundary and the impact on the residential amenity of the adjacent properties.

N         04775  SINGLE-STOREY EXTENSION TO SIDE: MORLEY MANOR, BRUNSWICK STREET (TEALE).

N         04706  SINGLE-STOREY REAR AND SIDE EXTENSION: 82 INGLE AVENUE (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 20/8/20

N         04764  SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 10 POPLAR CRESENT (WOODKIRK).

N         04871  CARPORT WITH FIRST-FLOOR EXTENSION OVER SIDE, SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION; RAISED PATIO AREA TO REAR: 429 WESTERTON ROAD (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 21/8/20

N         03430  SECOND-FLOOR BALCONY WITH BALUSTRADE TO FRONT: SAGE LANDING, 3 HARRWOOD MEWS, 31A HIGH STREET (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 24/8/20

N         04972  FIRST-FLOOR SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION ABOVE EXISTING SINGLE-STOREY GARAGE: 3 BITTERN RISE (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 26/8/20

N         05352/TR  T1 – SILVER BIRCH – IN THE FRONT GARDEN – TO REDUCE BY 50%.  THE TREE IS MANY YEARS OLD IT IS NOW VERY LARGE AND IS CLOSE TO THE HOUSE AND OUR NEIGHBOUR’S HOUSE.  THE ROOTS OF THE TREE ARE VERY CLOSE TO THE HOUSE AND COULD CAUSE DAMAGE TO THE HOUSE.  SOME OF THE BRANCHES NEARLY TOUCH OUR BEDROOM WINDOW WHICH IS UNSAFE PARTICULARLY IN WINDY WEATHER.  IF THE TREE IS NOT CUT BACK THE BRANCHES WILL SOON TOUCH THE WINDOWS.  THE TREE IS NOW SO BIG IT MAKES THE ROOMS AT THE FRONT OF THE HOUSE DARK: WESTROYD, ST ANDREWS AVENUE (TEALE).

N         04944  SINGLE-STOREY AND TWO-STOREY SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION: 15 ALDEN AVENUE (ELMFIELD).

RECEIVED 28/8/20

N         05062  INSTALLATION OF 4 X ELECTRIC VEHICLE CHARGING BAYS/POINTS TO EXISTING PARKING BAYS WITH ASSOCIATED EQUIPMENT: MCDONALDS, WIDE LANE (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 1/9/20

NC       05092  CONVERSION OF FORMER AGRICULTURAL STORE TO DWELLING WITH BALCONY TO SIDE AND CONSTRUCTION OF DOUBLE GARAGE WITH GYM ABOVE: LANESIDE FARM, VICTORIA ROAD (SCATCHERD).  MTC had no objection in principle, however, it was noted that some works have already been carried out.

N         05127  SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 41 DEANSWAY (SCATCHERD).

N         04472  DOUBLE GARAGE TO REAR: 1143 DEWSBURY ROAD (WOODKIRK).

N         05089  DORMER WINDOW TO FRONT: 15 WEST LEA CRESCENT (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 3/9/20

N         05571/TR  TREE WORK IN A CONSERVATION AREA  NO TPO’S ARE IN PLACE.  CYPRESS TREES X 3 – T1, T2 & T3 (TRUNKS HAVE MERGED) REMOVAL, G10 – REMOVAL OF THESE TREES COMPLETELY.  T6 – SYCAMORE, REMOVAL OF THIS TREE COMPLETELY: 25 GLADSTONE TERRACE (TEALE).

RECEIVED 8/9/20

N         05666/TR  EMERGENCY TREE WORKS T1 – CHERRY – REMOVE: 11 WINDERS DALE (SCATCHERD).

N         05314/TR  DRAW BACK TREES TO BOUNDARY LINE: SPRINGFIELD MILL PARK, SPRINGFIELD LANE (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 14/9/20

N         05706/TR  T1 OAK – NEEDS TRIMMING BACK BY APPROX 4M AS DEBRIS FALLING OFF INTO PLAYGROUND AREA: MORLEY VICTORIA PRIMARY SCHOOL, VICTORIA ROAD (SCATCHERD).

8. TO DISCUSS CONTENT OF EMAIL 10/8/2020 FROM KIRKLEES COUNCIL RE. LETTER FROM KIRKLEES COUNCIL REGARDING APPLICATION NUMBER 2020/92331 AT LOCATION LAND EAST OF LEEDS ROAD, CHIDSWELL, SHAW CROSS, DEWSBURY – SEE ATTACHED COPY (NOTE: THIS ITEM IS FOR INFORMATION ONLY, AS RESPONSES WERE REQUIRED BY 28/8/20).

            The information contained was received and noted. 

9. TO RECEIVE AND NOTE CONTENTS OF 3 CONSULTATIONS ISSUED BY THE MINISTRY OF HOUSING, COMMUNITIES & LOCAL GOVERNMENT, AS FOLLOWS:-

            (i)         PC10-20 Changes to the Current Planning System (responses required by 17/9/20)

            (ii)        PC 11-20 White Paper: Planning for the Future (responses required by 15/10/20)

            (iii)       PC12-20 Transparency and Competition: Data and Land Control (responses

required by 16/10/20)

The information contained was received and noted. 

10. TO RECEIVE ITEMS OF CORRESPONDENCE (items for information only)

There were no items of correspondence.

11. DATE AND TIME OF NEXT MEETING

The next scheduled meeting will take place on Tuesday, 17^th November 2020 at 7pm.

 

MINUTES OF ‘REMOTE’ EXTRAORDINARY PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING NO. 408

HELD ON TUESDAY, 4TH AUGUST 2020

Due to the absence of Cllrs R Bell (Chairman) and H Evans (Deputy Chairman) the members proposed and agreed Cllr R Finnigan chair the meeting.

1.         TO RECORD ATTENDANCE

Present:  Councillors R Finnigan, J Sanders, A Rhodes, M Storey and A Dalton.  W Maynard-Light (Deputy Town Clerk) also attended.

2.         TO RECEIVE AND NOTE APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE AND CONSIDER REASONS GIVEN FOR NON-ATTENDANCE
Apologies were received from Cllrs R Bell and H Evans and the reasons given for non-attendance were accepted.

3.         Declarations of Disclosable Pecuniary and Other Interests

Cllr R Finnigan declared an ‘other’ interest in any appropriate items, as he is a member of Leeds Plans Panel, LCC.

4.         TO APPROVE MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON 18/2/20

The minutes of the meeting held on 18/2/20 were agreed as a true and correct record.

5.         CONSIDERATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS

Notation of Recommendations.
O = Objection
N = No Objection
NC = No Objection (with comments)
D = Deferred

RECEIVED 17/7/20

N         20/03836  SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION WITH STEPS AND BALUSTRADE ABOVE TO NUMBER 25 AND SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION WITH RAISED DECKING AREA, STEPS AND BALUSTRADE ABOVE TO NUMBER 27:  25 AND 27 HARWILL RISE (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 21/7/20

N         20/03760  BOUNDARY FENCE TO REAR:  183 WIDE LANE (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 22/7/20

O         20/04151  OUTLINE APPLICATION FOR TWO DWELLINGS:  LAND REAR OF 1/3 SPRINGFIELD CRESCENT (SCATCHERD).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of safety issues in relation to the highway with restrictive access to and from the property.  Also limited vehicle turning space within the site, which would necessitate vehicles possibly reversing onto the public highway.

RECEIVED 23/7/20

N         20/04058  SINGLE-STOREY REAR AND SIDE EXTENSIONS:  WILD ACRE, 2 MANOR GRANGE (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 27/7/20

N         20/04246  SINGLE-STOREY REAR/SIDE EXTENSION:  2 KESTREL GARTH (TOPCLIFFE).

N         20/04231  CHANGE OF USE OF UNIT RU15 FROM A3/A5 TO A FLEXIBLE A1 AND/OR A2 AND/OR A3 AND/OR A4 AND/OR A5 USE:  UNIT RU15, WHITE ROSE SHOPPING CENTRE (CHURWELL).

The above planning applications were considered by all members of the Planning Committee present.

It was agreed that any comments be submitted via ‘Public Access’.

6.         TO NOTE PLANNING APPLICATIONS WITH DECISIONS MADE UNDER DELEGATED AUTHORITY TO TOWN CLERK – STANDING ORDER 15(c) (APPLICATIONS RECEIVED THAT DID NOT APPEAR ON 18/2/2020 AGENDA)

RECEIVED 13/2/20

N         20/00782  VARIATION OF CONDITION 2 (APPROVED PLANS) AND CONDITION 4 (WINDOWS) OF PLANNING APPROVAL 18/01506/FU TO ENABLE DRAWINGS TO BE

ADDED TO SCHEDULE TO ACCOUNT FOR PLOT 3 AND WINDOWS TO BE SILVER GREY IN VARIATION TO THE OTHERS (WHITE):  VAYNOL GATE, ROOMS LANE (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 14/2/20

N         20/00918TR  T1 OAK – REMOVAL OF OVERHANGING BRANCHES BECAUSE OF EXCESSIVE SHADING AND POSSIBLE DAMAGE TO NEARBY SHED AND FENCE: THE TREE IS SITUATED TO THE REAR OF 15 LANESIDE FOLD ON LAND ADJACENT TO WESTWOODSIDE:  15 LANESIDE FOLD (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 17/2/20

N         20/00815  NEW WALL TO FORM AN ENCLOSURE FOR A GENERATOR:  1 WHITE ROSE OFFICE PARK, MILLSHAW PARK LANE (CHURWELL).

N         20/00799  SINGLE-STOREY SIDE EXTENSION, ALTERATIONS TO EXISTING GARAGE TO FORM HABITABLE ROOM:  22 IBBETSON DRIVE (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 18/2/20

NC       20/00910  STORAGE UNIT/OUTBUILDING TO FRONT:  MSS WORKSHOP LTD, GF01 GROUND FLOOR, CITY MILLS (CENTRAL).

MTC objects to this planning application on the grounds of the impact on the residential amenity.

RECEIVED 20/2/20

N         20/00923  SINGLE-STOREY EXTENSION TO REAR:  10 KINGFISHER MEWS (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 25/2/20

NC       20/00908  INSTALLATION OF HAND CAR WASH TO CAR PARK WITH CABIN, CANOPY AND ANPR CAMERA:  ASDA, HOWLEY PARK ROAD (ELMFIELD).

MTC has no objection in principle to this application.  It is recommended that a condition be applied regarding opening hours of the car wash which should mirror the Asda store opening hours on Sunday.

RECEIVED 2/3/20

O         20/00426  GARAGE CONVERSION TO HABITABLE ROOM SPACE AND ENCLOSING BIN STORAGE AREA:  37 VICTORIA MEWS (TEALE).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of the lack of appropriate parking provision.

RECEIVED 4/3/20

O         19/01988  RESERVED MATTERS APPLICATION FOR THE LAYOUT, SCALE, APPEARANCE AND LANDSCAPING FOR 486 DWELLINGS, PURSUANT TO OUTLINE APPLICATION 16/02988/OT:  LANE SIDE FARM, VICTORIA ROAD (SCATCHERD).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds the proposed development is not sustainable, the public open space situated under the electricity pylons is unacceptable for the safety of families, in particular children.  The increased traffic disruption to the local roads, together with the impact on the already congested inner ring road plus the number of vehicles accessing and exiting the proposed development which will be increased with the proposed two-entry primary school.

RECEIVED 5/3/20

O         20/01349  TWO STOREY SIDE EXTENSION:  6 GREENSHANK MEWS (TOPCLIFFE).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of the negative impact on the street scene, as there are no similar developments in the adjacent area.

N         20/01151  INTERNAL AND EXTERNAL ALTERATIONS TO PUBLIC HOUSE, FORMATION OF EXTENDED EXTERNAL EATING AREAS, CLADDING TO SIDE AND REAR:  NEEDLESS INN, SCOTCHMAN LANE (TEALE).

N         20/01016  DORMER WINDOWS TO FRONT AND REAR:  21 WEST LEA DRIVE (WOODKIRK).

N         20/01033  SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION:  10 IBBETSON COURT (CHURWELL).

N         20/01074/TR  T1 ACER – TO BE REMOVE. TO BE REPLACED WITH AN APPLE TREE IN THE GARDEN NOT ON THE COUNCIL LAND. T2, T3 AND T4 ACER – TO BE DRAWN BACK BY 2-3 METRES TO REMOVE OVERHANGING BRANCHES TO LET MORE LIGHT IN. T3, T4 – TREE TO BE DRAWN BACK:  REAR OF 41 WOODSIDE DRIVE (CHURWELL).

N         20/01446/TR  T1 – REMOVE.  TOWN END, FOUNTAIN STREET (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 9/3/20

O         20/01392  SINGLE STOREY EXTENSIONS TO SIDE AND TO REAR:  2B CHURCH LANE (WOODKIRK).

MTC objects to the application on the grounds the extension will create insufficient parking provision.

RECEIVED 10/3/20

N         20/01397  SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION:  15 TOPCLIFFE FOLD (TOPCLIFFE).

N         20/01292  RETROSPECTIVE APPLICATION FOR CHANGE OF USE FROM COMMERCIAL WORKSHOP TO RESIDENTIAL DWELLING (C3); ALTERATIONS TO WINDOWS AND DOORS:  OPTIMUM IMPRESSIONS LTD, 29A HIGH STREET (CENTRAL).

N         20/01237  ONE NEW TWO STOREY DWELLING:  LAND AT ROOMS WAY (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 11/3/20

N         20/01473  CONVERSION OF GARAGE TO HABITABLE ROOM:  1 LITTLE LANE (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 13/3/20

N         20/01516  SINGLE STOREY SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION:  47 BIRK LANE (TEALE).

N         19/07611  DEMOLITION OF REDUNDANT INDUSTRIAL BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION OF NINE DWELLINGS:  SCATCHERD WORKS, SCATCHERD LANE (TEALE).

RECEIVED 19/3/20

N         20/01692  TWO STOREY SIDE EXTENSION:  10 GRANGE PARK DRIVE (CHURWELL).

N         20/01668  SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION:  1 STATION VIEW (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 23/3/20

N         20/01170  SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION:  10 BITTERN RISE (TOPCLIFFE).

N         20/01606  SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION:  5 BEECH WORKS, WORRALL STREET (TEALE).

N         20/01608  SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION:  14 HARDY AVENUE (CHURWELL).

N         20/10576  SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION:  11 SCARBOROUGH LANE (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 25/3/20

O         20/01683  TWO STOREY SIDE EXTENSION, SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION; DORMER WINDOWS TO REAR ELEVATION AND EXTENDED PORCH TO FRONT:  23 WOODLANDS DRIVE (SCATCHERD).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of significant overdevelopment of the site and the impact on the location with a rear dormer, which does not have a pitched roof.

RECEIVED 30/3/20

N         20/01807  ALTERATIONS INCLUDING SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION TO FORM LINK  EXTENSION TO GARAGE TO FORM HABITABLE ROOM:  9 SCARBOROUGH LANE (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 31/3/20

NC       20/01753  CHANGE OF USE OF DANCE STUDIO (D2) TO BANQUETING SUITE (SUI GENERIS):  UNIT 1E 91A QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

MTC has no objection in principle to this application, however, members would comment on the closing times and suggest Monday-Thursday 9am to midnight; Friday and Saturday 9am to 1am; Sunday 9am to midnight, except when preceding a Bank Holiday then 1am.

RECEIVED 1/4/20

NC       20/01911  SINGLE STOREY SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION:  8 SCATCHERD GROVE

(TEALE).

MTC has no objection in principle to this application, however, assurances there would be sufficient provision on site for two vehicles to be parked off road.

RECEIVED 7/4/20

N         20/01915  TWO STOREY SIDE EXTENSION WITH DORMER WINDOWS TO REAR; DETACHED GARAGE TO REAR:  11 KING GEORGE AVENUE (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 9/4/20

N         20/02149/TR  T1 SYCAMORE, T2 SYCAMORE, T3 SYCAMORE, T6 LIME, T7 LIME, T8 CHERRY, T9 PINE – REDUCE HEIGHT BY 2 METRES AND WIDTH BY 1 METRE:  THE CHASE, BRADSTOCK GARDENS (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 14/4/20

N         20/02042  HIP TO GABLE ROOF EXTENSION INCLUDING CONVERSION OF LOFT AND FIRST FLOOR BALCONY TO REAR:  1155 DEWSBURY ROAD (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED15/4/20

N         20/02054  ALTERATIONS INVOLVING REPLACEMENT WINDOWS AND DOORS TO FLATS: VICTORIA COURT, VICTORIA MEWS (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 16/4/20

NC       19/07911  CONSTRUCTION OF A TWO-PLATFORM RAILWAY STATION, INCLUDING TWO STATION BUILDINGS, NEW VEHICULAR AND PEDESTRIAN ACCESS, ASSOCATED INFRASTRUCTURE, LANDSCAPING AND WORKS:  LAND ADJACENT TO WHITE ROSE OFFICE PARK AND MILLSHAW INDUSTRIAL PARK, MILLSHAW PARK LANE (BEESTON).

MTC has no objection in principle, however the materials on the Churwell side of the station must be sympathetic to the buildings closet and it should accommodate a stone element to such elevations.  We support the Ramblers Association objections and their proposals for improvements to the footpath network.  We request that a series of TROs are drawn up to accommodate concerns the station will have an impact on local residential streets and TROs should accommodate a ‘resident only’ parking scheme and a revenue stream to support an Enforcement Officer must be part of the planning condition.  The access road must be yellow lined and accompanied with a physical barrier to prevent parking off road and remove the potential for a ‘park and ride’ scheme.  We request this application is referred to Plans Panel for final decision.

N         20/02261/TR  T1, T2 OAK – NO ACTION; T3, T4, T5 OAK – DRAW BACK OVERHANG FROM THE MAIN ROAD BY UP TO 3 METRES TO PREVENT CONTACT WITH HIGH SIDED VEHCILES; T6, T7 PINE – NO ACTION; T8 BEECH, T11 CHERRY – CROWN THIN BY 20% TO REDUCE WIND SAIL; T9, T10, T12 OAK – NO ACTION:  BRIAR KNOLL, SCOTCHMAN LANE (ELMFIELD).

RECEIVED 28/4/20

NC       20/02245  CHANGE OF USE FROM HAULAGE YARD (SUI GENERIS) TO USE AS A CAR PARK:  BRUNTCLIFFE LANE (SCATCHERD).

MTC has no objections in principle to this application, however, a request for a condition be placed on the application with regard the operating times of the car park, not to be used prior to 7am and not after 9pm Monday to Saturday, 8am to 9pm on Sunday.

RECEIVED 30/4/20

N         20/02407  SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION:  6 GUILLEMOT APPROACH (TOPCLIFFE).

N         20/02312  CONVERTING ONE FLAT INTO TWO FLATS:  1 JUBILEE COURT, MARSHALL STREET (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 4/5/20

N         20/02319  CONVERSION OF GARAGE TO FORM HABITABLE ROOM INCLUDING NEW WINDOW TO SIDE ELEVATION:  9 KESTREL GARTH (TOPCLIFFE).

N         20/02427  SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION:  83 IBBETSON OVAL (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 5/5/20

O         20/02148  DORMER WINDOWS TO FRONT AND REAR, SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION:  49 OLD ROAD (CHURWELL).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of the impact on the street scene with no other similar developments in the adjacent area.

N         20/02412/TR  PROPOSE TO TRIM BACK THE LOWER OVERHANGING BRANCHES OF THE TREES ALONG THE HIGHLIGHTED STRETCH OF FENCING, RANGING FROM 2.5M – 4.0M.  THIS IS TO ALLOW HAULAGE VEHICLES TO REVERSE AND PARK CLOSER TO THE FENCE LINE:  ARCHBOLD HOUSE, ALBERT ROAD (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 7/5/20

O         20/02448  VARIATION OF CONDITION 2 (APPROVED PLANS) AND CONDITION 22 (SOFT LANDSCAPING TO BE RETAINED) OF APPROVAL 18/00251/FU TO AMEND APPROVED PLANS TO LAYOUT AND PLOT SUBSTITUTION (PLOTS 3-69 AND 77-87):  LAND AT SNITTLES FARM, GELDERD ROAD (HOLBECK).

MTC objects to this planning application on the following grounds, this is clearly an attempt to get around the bedroom size standards by claiming the third (or second) bedroom on the first floor is a “study”.  This approach, which breaches the new standards being adopted on house quality, is unacceptable and a refusal decision should be made.  We also object to the reduction on three bed properties and the implementation of one bed properties.  MTC requests this application be referred to Plans Panel should an approval decision be considered.

N         20/02495  DETERMINATION FOR TELECOMMUNICATIONS EQUIPMENT:  CROSSROADS SPRINGFIELD LANE/VICTORIA ROAD/BANK AVENUE/BANK SQUARE (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 11/5/20

NC       20/02469  DEMOLITION OF FORMER PUBLIC HOUSE AND RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT COMPRISING 13 HOUSES: FORMER ARKLE PUBLIC HOUSE,  105 SPRINGFIELD AVENUE (SCATCHERD).

MTC has no objection in principle to this application.  However, committee would object to the high number of four-bedroom properties, as focus should be on two or three bedroomed properties as family homes.

N         20/02558  CONSTRUCTION OF TEMPORARY CAR PARK FOR A FIVE-YEAR PERIOD:  LAND ADJACENT TO 1 CAPITOL HOUSE, CAPITOL CLOSE (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 12/5/20

N         20/02656/TR  REDUCE THE HEIGHT OF TREES BY 5 METRES:  15 BRIDGE COURT (ELMFIELD).

RECEIVED 13/5/20

O         20/01932  ROLLER SHUTTERS TO FRONT AND REAR OF PROPERTY:  19 SOUTH QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of the impact on the street scene as the property is in a residential street.

RECEIVED 18/5/20

O         20/02108  DEMOLITION OF OUTBUILDINGS TO REAR AND REBUILD TO FORM 2 FLATS:  3 WESTFIELD ROAD (CENTRAL).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of lack of parking provision at the proposed rebuilding will inevitably lead to on-street parking at a location where parking problems already exist.

N         20/02562  ASSISTED LIVING FACILITY CONSISTING 15 FLATS AND 1 HOUSE WITH ASSOCIATED EXTERNAL WORKS AND PARKING:  LAND OFF CHAPEL HILL/CHURCH STREET/BANK AVENUE (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 19/5/20

N         20/02692  ERECTION OF DENTAL LABORATORY FOR APPLICANT’S OWN USE NOT A CLINICAL SETTING; NEW DOORS TO REAR OF DWELLING:  60 SPRINGFIELD ROAD (SCATCHERD).

N         20/02608  ALTERATIONS INCLUDING RAISING LEVEL OF GARDEN AREA WITH NEW RETAINING WALL AND FENCE ABOVE; REPLACEMENT FENCING ON SIDE BOUNDARIES TO REAR:  26 DIGPAL ROAD (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 21/5/20

N         20/02531  SINGLE STOREY FRONT EXTENSION:  7 FAIRFIELD RISE (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 22/5/20

N         20/02611  VARIATION OF CONDITIONS 2 (APPROVED PLANS) AND 5 (ROOF LIGHTS HEIGHTS) TO PREVIOUSLY APPROVED PLANNING APPLICATION 15/07679/FU FOR AMENDMENTS TO THE APPROVED SCHEME:  EASTERGATE, ELLAND ROAD (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 27/5/20

NC       20/02741  ALTERATIONS INVOLVING RAISED ROOF RIDGE HEIGHT WITH DORMER WINDOWS TO FRONT AND REAR; ATTACHED GARAGE TO SIDE; SINGLE STOREY EXTENSION TO REAR AND PORCH TO FRONT:  6 CROFT HOUSE ROAD (SCATCHERD).

MTC has no objection in principle to the rear facing dormer as the rest of the Croft House estate has several such dormers to the rear.  However, we do object to the front dormer as the estate has resisted front dormers for many years.  It may be possible to overcome the significant impact on the street scene a front dormer would have if the dormer was made smaller and carried a pitched roof.

RECEIVED 1/6/20

N         20/03049/TR  T1 HAWTHORNE – REMOVE, TO ALLOW MORE LIGHT INTO GARDEN; T2 ELDERBERRY – REMOVE, TO ALLOW MORE LIGHT INTO GARDEN:  5 GLADSTONE TERRACE (TEALE).

RECEIVED 10/6/20

N         20/03251/TR  T1 SYCAMORE AND T2 ALDERWOOD – 5 METRE CROWN LIFT AND CLEAR ANY DEAD WOOD, TREES ARE BECOMING CLOSER AND CLOSER TO THE PROPERTY AND COVERING THE GARDEN:  23A BRIDGE COURT (ELMFIELD).

N         20/03272/TR  T1 CHERRY – REMOVE DUE TO DAMAGED CAUSED BY THE ROOT PLATE AS THIS IS LIFT5ING THE FOOT PATH.  T2 CHERRY – REDUCE BY 1M, LEAVING THE TREE 5M HIGH:  11 WINDERS DALE (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 11/6/20

N         20/03089  TWO STOREY SIDE EXTENSION INCORPORATING DOUBLE GARAGE AND BALCONY TO REAR; SINGLE STOREY EXTENSION AND ALTERATIONS TO EXISTING CONSERVATORY TO OTHER SIDE; WIDEN EXISTING VEHICLE ACCESS TO FRONT: TREE TOPS, 37 DEWSBURY ROAD (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 18/6/20

O         20/03318  CONSTRUCTION OF FOUR DETACHED DWELLINGS INCLUDING PRIVATE ACCESS ROAD:  LAND NEAR CRANK COTTAGE, STATION ROAD (TOPCLIFFE).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds the access from the development onto Albert Road which members considered would be problematic with obscured sight lines.  MTC has no objection in principle to the development.

RECEIVED 23/6/20

O         20/01149  CONVERSION OF GARAGE TO HABITABLE ROOM:  9 THE GALLOPS (ELMFIELD).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of a lost parking place on a cul-de-sac with several properties with smaller drives.

RECEIVED 25/6/20

N         20/03542  DORMER WINDOW TO FRONT:  50 MANOR FARM DRIVE (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 29/6/20

N         20/03571  SINGLE STOREY REAR/SIDE EXTENSION:  24 UPPER GREEN WAY (WOODKIRK).

N         20/03066/TR  T1 OAK TREE – REDUCE HEIGHT FROM 18FT TO 12FT TO PREVIOUS PRUNING POINTS:  71 IBBETSON OVAL (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 1/7/20

N         20/03320  RETROSPECTIVE APPLICATION FOR DETACHED GARAGE AND STORE: 137 NEW BANK STREET (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 3/7/2020

N         20/03737/TR  T1 AND T2 SCYAMORE – CROWN LIFT/TRIM RIM LOWER 2 METRES DUE TO EXCESSIVE SHADING AND OVERHANGING GARDEN AREA.  REMOVE DEAD WOOD FROM WITHIN.  T3 SYCAMORE – FELL BECAUSE OF EXCESSIVE SHADING DUE TO EXCESSIVE HEIGHT.  RISK OF FALLING IN WINDS CANOPY.  HAPPY TO REPLANT ANOTHER TREE IN PLACE.  I WILL NEED SOME ADVICE REGARDING REPLANTING:  21 SANDMEAD CROFT (SCATCHERD).

N         20/03699  ERECTION OF 1.8 METRE HIGH CLOSE BOARDED FENCE AND INCREASE IN HEIGHT OF INTERNAL STORAGE BAYS TO 3 METRES: ETERNAL HOMES LTD WORKSHOP ADJACENT TO VICTORIA FILLING STATION, BRUNTCLIFFE ROAD (TEALE).

O         20/02448  VARIATION OF CONDITION 2 (APPROVED PLANS) AND CONDITION 22 (SOFT LANDSCAPING TO BE RETAINED) OF APPROVAL 18/00251/FU TO AMEND APPROVED PLANS TO LAYOUT AND PLOT SUBSTITUTION (PLOTS 69 AND 77-87):  LAND AT SNITTLES FARM, GELDERD ROAD (HOLBECK).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of limited infrastructure with an impact on the already congested roads together with lack of places at the local schools, doctors and dentists.

RECEIVED 7/7/20

N         20/03773  SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION:  4 ROOMS WAY (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 8/7/20

N         20/04040/TR  1 X ASH TREE WITHIN G1 SECTION, REQUIRES TOPPING APPROXIMATELY 4M FROM THE PEAK AS IT BLOCKS NATURAL LIGHT:  OAKDENE, ST ANDREWS AVENUE (TEALE).

RECEIVED 15/7/20

20/03873  DETACHED GARAGE TO FRONT:  25A HARWILL AVENUE (CHURWELL).

The above decisions made under Town Clerk’s delegated authority, were noted.

7.         TO RECEIVE ITEMS OF CORRESPONDENCE (items for information only)

a)     Email dated 23/3/20 updated Key Cases for Morley North & Morley South Wards.

b)     Email dated 28/4/20 from Suzi Help, Whptelecoms re: pre-planning consultation letter with attachments for site LDS11053, proposed 5G telecommunications installation for H3GUK.

c)     Letter dated 7/5/20 from Jonathan Carr, Head of Development Management, LCC re. planning application 17/08262/OT/S land off Haigh Moor Road and Westerton Road, West Ardsley for consideration at City Plans Panel on 21/5/20.

d)     Email dated 17/5/20 from Suzi Help, Whptelecoms re: pre-planning consultation letter with attachments for site LDS12211, proposed 5G telecommunications installation for H3GUK.

e)     Letter dated 26/5/20 from Jonathan Carr, Head of Development Management, LCC re. appeal against refusal of planning application 19/07905/FU, 10 Church Lane, Tingley (Woodkirk).

f)       Email dated 27/5/20 from Danica Swift, Compliance Officer, LCC re. planning application 17/03538, land of Topcliffe Lane (Topcliffe).

g)     Letter dated 27/5/20 from Jonathan Carr, Head of Development Management, LCC re. appeal against refusal of planning application 19/04496/FU, land adjacent to Romany Cottage, Howden Clough Road (Teale).

h)     Letter dated 11/6/20 from Jonathan Carr, Head of Development Management, LCC re. change to application 20/01392/FU, 2b Church Lane, Tingley (Woodkirk).

i)       Letter dated 23/7/20 from Jonathan Carr, Head of Development Management, LCC re. appeal against refusal of planning application 20/00118/FU, Egypt Cottage, Britannia Road (Elmfield).

All the above items of correspondence were noted.

8.         DATE AND TIME OF NEXT MEETING

The next scheduled meeting will take place on Tuesday, 22nd September 2020 at 7pm.

 

MINUTES OF PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING NO. 407

 HELD ON TUESDAY, 18^TH FEBRUARY 2020

1. TO RECORD ATTENDANCE

Present:  Councillors R Bell (Chairman), R Finnigan, J Sanders, A Rhodes, A Dalton, C Taylor, M Storey and P Bennett.  K Oakley – Town Clerk also attended.

2.         TO RECEIVE AND NOTE APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE AND CONSIDER REASONS GIVEN FOR NON-ATTENDANCE

There were no apologies.

3.  DECLARATIONS OF DISCLOSABLE PECUNIARY AND OTHER INTRESTS

Cllr R Finnigan declared an ‘other’ interest in any appropriate items, as he is a member of Leeds Plans Panel, LCC.

Cllr C Taylor declared an ‘other’ interest in appn 20/00538, as he knows the applicant.

4. TO APPROVE MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON 10/12/19

The minutes of the meeting held on 10/12/19 were agreed as a true and correct record.

5. CONSIDERATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS

Notation of Recommendations.

O = Objection

N = No Objection

NC = No Objection (with comments)

D = Deferred

RECEIVED 7/1/20

NC       19/07911  CONSTRUCTION OF A TWO-PLATFORM RAILWAY STATION, INCLUDING TWO STATION BUILDINGS, NEW VEHICULAR AND PEDESTRIAN ACCESS, ASSOCIATED INFRASTRUCTURE, LANDSCAPING AND WORKS: LAND ADJACENT TO WHITE ROSE OFFICE PARK AND MILLSHAW INDUSTRIAL PARK, MILLSHAW PARK LANE (CHURWELL).

MTC had no objection in principle but suggests that there should be significant TRO’s put in place to stop parking on the spine road (apart from disabled parking) and consideration be given to “residents only” parking permits on roads in close proximity that may be affected by people using the station. It is also felt that the applicant should make a contribution towards enforcement and TRO’s.  We also note that Cottingley station will remain open.

RECEIVED 30/1/20

N         20/00455  ALTERATIONS TO AN INDUSTRIAL BUILDING TO INSTALL VENTS AND CHIMNEYS TO ROOF: ARCHBOLD HOUSE, ALBERT ROAD (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 7/2/20

N         20/00617  DEMOLITION OF EXISTING WAREHOUSE AND CREATION OF 7 NO. DWELLINGS: 4 OAK ROAD (TEALE).

RECEIVED 10/2/20

O         20/00626  CHANGE OF USE OF LAND TO FORM ALLOTMENTS WITH NEW PARKING AND ACCESS: LAND OFF SCOTCHMAN LANE (TEALE).   MTC objected to this appn as it was felt there would be significant highways safety issues as Scotchman Lane currently has a 40mph speed limit and the proposed access to the allotments is very narrow.

RECEIVED 11/2/20

N         20/00538  CHANGE OF USE OF LAND TO FORM MENAGE WITH FENCING: LAND OFF SCOTCHMAN LANE (TEALE).

The above planning applications were considered by all members of the Planning Committee present.

It was agreed that any comments be submitted via ‘Public Access’. 

6. TO NOTE PLANNING APPLICATIONS WITH DECISIONS MADE UNDER DELEGATED AUTHORITY TO TOWN CLERK – STANDING ORDER 15(c) (APPLICATIONS RECEIVED THAT DID NOT APPEAR ON 10/12/19 AGENDA)

RECEIVED 4/12/19

O         19/7265  CONVERSION OF PART SECOND-FLOOR TO FIVE SELF-CONTAINED FLATS INCLUDING CHANGE OF USE OF PART FIRST-FLOOR AND SECOND-FLOOR TO OFFICES (B1) AND ADDITION OF ROOF LIGHT TO SOUTH-WEST ELEVATION: QUARRY COURT, HIGH STREET (ELMFIELD).  MTC objected to this appn as flat size breaches minimum size policy, there would be inadequate parking and an unacceptable clash of children’s centre and flats.

RECEIVED 6/12/19

N         19/7336  CHANGE OF USE OF PART GROUND-FLOOR FROM A5 TO RESIDENTIAL AND TWO-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: CRAGG LEA, SYKE ROAD, TINGLEY (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 12/12/19

N         19/7486  SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 16 DAISY HILL CLOSE (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 17/12/19

N         19/7587  SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 81 HARWILL RISE (CHURWELL).

N         19/7360  FIRST-FLOOR REAR EXTENSION: 114-116 QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 20/12/19

N         19/7673  TWO-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 5 LISTER WALK (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 3/1/20

N         19/7880  ALTERATIONS INCLUDING; TWO-STOREY SIDE EXTENSION; SINGLE-STOREY FRONT AND REAR EXTENSION; DORMER WINDOW TO REAR: 23 WOODLANDS DRIVE (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 7/1/20

N         19/7905  TWO-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 10 CHURCH LANE (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 9/1/20

N         20/00082  SINGLE-STOREY FRONT EXTENSION: 1 SANDMEAD CROFT (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 13/1/20

NC       20/00133  CONVERSION OF GARAGE TO HABITABLE ROOMS; SINGLE-STOREY SIDE EXTENSION; SINGLE-STOREY INFILL EXTENSION TO SIDE; BI-FOLDING DOORS TO REAR: 5 FARM HILL MEWS (SCATCHERD).  MTC has no objection in principle, however, members would like a condition applied that residents’ vehicles be parked on the drive.

RECEIVED 14/1/20

N         20/00095  SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 51 BRUNTCLIFFE LANE (TEALE).

NC       20/00158  USE OF EXISTING VEHICLE RECOVERY OPERATION AS A 24-HOUR 7 DAYS A WEEK SERVICE: VICTORIA WORKS, BRUNTCLIFFE ROAD (TEALE).  MTC has no objection in principle to this application.  However, it is suggested that a one-year temporary planning permission be granted and to review any noise issues after 12 months.

N         20/00138  CONSERVATORY TO REAR; SINGLE-STOREY EXTENSION TO SIDE TO FORM STORE; EXTENSION TO GABLE AND DORMER WINDOW TO REAR: 43 BRUNTCLIFFE LANE (TEALE).

RECEIVED 15/1/20

N         20/00019  VARIATION OF CONDITION 2 (APPROVED PLANS) OF APPROVAL 18/00707/FU TO INCREASE FLOORSPACE TO CREATE A LARGER SALES AREA; CREATION OF AN ENTRANCE/EXIT LOBBY: CHARTISTS WAY (ELMFIELD).

N         19/07853  CONSTRUCTION OF SMOKING SHELTER, NEW TIMBER FENCE, LANDSCAPING WORKS AND RETROSPECTIVE APPLICATION FOR TWO CONTAINERS TO CAR PARK:  VILLAGE HOTEL, CAPITAL BOULEVARD (TOPCLIFFE).

N         20/00027  T1 OAK – REMOVE EPICORMIC GROWTH, CROWN LIFT TO GIVE 2 METRES CLEARANCE OVER GARAGE ROOF.  DRAW BACK BRANCHES TO GIVE 2 METRES CLEARANCE FROM NEIGHBOURING PROPERTY AND DRAW IN ON OPPOSITE SIDE TO BALANCE THE CROWN – LIGHT AND NUISANCE TO NEIGHBOUR AND GOOD TREE MANAGEMENT. 108 IBBETSON OVAL (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 16/1/20

N         20/00118  CHANGE OF USE AND ALTERATIONS INCLUDING FIRST-FLOOR EXTENSION ABOVE GARAGE TO FORM ADDITIONAL FLAT: EGYPT COTTAGE, BRITANNIA ROAD (ELMFIELD).

O         19/07886  ONE NEW DWELLING IN EXISTING GARDEN AND DEMOLITION OF GARAGE:

12 MARSHALL CRESCENT (ELMFIELD).  MTC objects to this application due to overdevelopment of the site, impact on the street scene and removal of 2 off-street parking spaces.

RECEIVED 20/1/20

N         19/07706  CHANGE OF USE OF RETAIL SHOP (A1) TO WINE BAR (A4) WITH ASSOCIATED EXTERNAL AND INTERNAL ALTERATIONS: 6-8 CHEAPSIDE (SCATCHERD).

O         20/00027  CONVERSION OF GARAGE INTO HABITABLE ROOM: 18 PICCOLO ROW (CHURWELL).  MTC objects to this application due to there being insufficient parking space for 2 cars off road.

RECEIVED 21/1/20

N         20/00272  DETACHED NEW GARAGE TO FRONT: 25A HARWILL AVENUE (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 27/1/20

N         20/00259  SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION AND GARAGE CONVERSION:  17 ARKWRIGHT WALK (SCATCHERD).

N         20/00193  SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION; DEMOLITION OF EXISTING CONSERVATORY: 9 STONECHAT RISE (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 28/1/20

N         20/00548/TR  5 DAY NOTICE: T1 – FELL, DUE TO TREE BEING DANGEROUS AND FULL OF INFECTION; T2 – REMOVAL OF BOTTOM BRANCH OVERHANGING THE ROAD AS BRANCH IS OBSTRUCTIVE TO LARGE VEHICLES: 1 DAFFIL GRANGE WAY (CHURWELL).

O         20/00268  CHANGE OF USE OF PART BASEMENT, PART GROUND AND UPPER FLOORS OF SHOP TO THREE FLATS AND ALTERATIONS INCLUDING DORMER WINDOW, EXTRACTION FLUE AND NEW SHOP FRONT: 22 CHAPEL HILL (SCATCHERD).  MTC objects to this application on the grounds of over-development of the property and concerns around the parking of vehicles.

The above decisions made under Town Clerk’s delegated authority, were noted.

7. TO RECEIVE ITEMS OF CORRESPONDENCE (items for information only)

• Letter dated 9/12/19 from Planning Services, LCC, re. Planning Appeal; GJB Sand Mile Ltd, Land Off Troy Road, Morley LS27 8JG; Four dwellings (Two pairs of semi-detached); App/N4720/W/19/3238699.
• Letter dated 16/12/19 from Planning Services, LCC, re. Planning Appeal; Mr K Poppleton, 2a William Street, Churwell, Morley LS27 7RE (Retrospective application for garage to rear with raised decking area above garage); App/N4720/D/19/3239366.
• Copy of letter dated 16/12/19 from Cllr T Leadley to Chief Planning Officer, LCC, re. ‘Planning Appn No. 19/01988RM: Persimmon Homes & Priestgate Morley Ltd: 511 Homes with School Site: Laneside Farm, A643 Elland Road/Victoria Road, Morley.
• Letter dated 19/12/19 from Planning Services, LCC, re. notification of hearing of planning application 17/08262/OT/S, Land off Haigh Moor Road and Westerton Road, West Ardsley at Plans Panel meeting on 6/1/20.
• Letter dated 2/1/20 from Planning Services, LCC, re. Appn 17/08262/OT/S – At Land Off Haigh Moor Road and Westerton Road, West Ardsley.
• Letter dated 22/1/20 from J Carr, Head of Dev Management, LCC Planning Services, re. Appn 17/08262/OT – At Land off Haigh Moor Road and Westerton Road, West Ardsley; Outline Planning application for a residential development with all matters reserved save for the two principle accesses off Westerton Road and Haigh Moor Road (but not to include access within the site), three points of access at Upper Green Avenue, Sandringham Drive and Hill Top Lane, associated works, public open space provision and accessibility and qualitative improvements to local greenspace.
• Updated Key Cases for Morley North & Morley South Wards.

All of the above items of correspondence were noted.

8. DATE AND TIME OF NEXT MEETING

The next scheduled meeting will take place on Tuesday, 17^th March 2020 at 7pm.

 

MINUTES OF PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING NO. 406

HELD ON TUESDAY, 10TH DECEMBER 2019

1.         TO RECORD ATTENDANCE

Present:  Cllrs R Finnigan (Deputy Chairman), A Rhodes, C Taylor, M Storey and A Dalton.

W Maynard-Light (Deputy Town Clerk) also attended.

2.         TO RECEIVE AND NOTE APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE AND CONSIDER REASONS GIVEN FOR NON-ATTENDANCE
Apologies were received from Cllr R Bell and H Evans and reasons given for absence were noted.

3.         DECLARATIONS OF DISCLOSABLE PECUNIARY AND OTHER INTRESTS

Cllr R Finnigan declared an ‘other’ interest in any appropriate items as he is on Plans Panel, LCC.

4.         TO APPROVE MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON 17/919

The Minutes of the meeting held on 16/7/19 were agreed as a true and correct record.

5.         CONSIDERATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS

Notation of Recommendations.
O = Objection
N = No Objection
NC = No Objection (with comments)
D = Deferred

RECEIVED 27/11/19

O         1988  RESERVED MATTERS APPLICATION FOR THE LAYOUT, SCALE, APPEARANCE AND LANDSCAPING FOR 511 NEW HOMES, PURSUANT TO OUTLINE APPLICATION 16/02988/OT:

LANESIDE FARM, VICTORIA ROAD (CHURWELL).  MTC objects to this planning application.  Members agreed the amount of land allocated (1.8 hectares) for the proposed primary school is insufficient for a two-form entry.  No traffic impact assessment has been undertaken to consider the impact of a two-form entry primary school has on the vehicle movements from the rest of the estate.  Also, it was viewed that the siting of the proposed school is in the wrong location within the centre of the site.  There is an over-intensity of buildings compared with the two adjacent boundary communities, Croft Houses and Harwill estates.  The room sizes are inadequate and do not comply with recent adopted policy.  The public open spaces, in particular the area under the electricity pylon is not a usable area and the other public open spaces are not readily accessible to all.

RECEIVED 3/12/19

NC       7004  INSTALLATION OF HAND CAR WASH TO CAR PARK WITH CABIN, CANOPY AND ANPR CAMERA: ASDA, HOWLEY PARK ROAD (ELMFIELD).  MTC has no objections in principle to this planning application.  Members do, however, wish a condition be placed on the application regarding the operating hours on Sunday to be in line with the store opening hours.

RECEIVED 4/12/19

N         7349  LISTED BUILDING APPLICATION FOR REPLACEMENT OF ONE NON-ILLUMINATED SIGN: HSBC BANK PLC, BANK CHAMBERS, QUEET STREET (CENTRAL).

The above planning applications were considered by all members of the Planning Committee present.  It was agreed that any comments be submitted via ‘Public Access’.

6.         TO NOTE PLANNING APPLICATIONS WITH DECISIONS MADE UNDER DELEGATED AUTHORITY TO TOWN CLERK – STANDING ORDER 15(c) (APPLICATIONS RECEIVED THAT DID NOT APPEAR ON 17/09/19 AGENDA)

RECEIVED 17/9/19

N         5743  TWO-STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 5 LISTER WALK (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 23/9/19

N         5841  TWO-STOREY REAR EXTENSION, SINGLE-STOREY SIDE EXTENSION, CONVERSION OF GARAGE TO HABITABLE ROOM WITH NEW DOOR AND WINDOW TO SIDE: ROCKWOOD, SCOTCHMAN LANE (TEALE).

N         5677  RETROSPECTIVE APPLICATION FOR A SINGLE-STOREY FRONT EXTENSION: THE OLD BAKERY, BRITANNIA ROAD (ELMFIELD).

RECEIVED 25/9/19

NC       5874  RESERVED MATTERS APPLICATION FOR ONE DWELLING: 44 INGLE AVENUE (SCATCHERD).  MTC has no objections in principle to this planning application, a comment was made that the Highways Authority needs to be satisfied that the proposed access/egress is safe and complies with all relevant highways guidance.

RECEIVED 26/9/19

N         5697  TWO DETACHED STORAGE CONTAINERS: UNIT 1 UNION WORKS, BRIDGE STREET (ELMFIELD).

RECEIVED 14/10/19

N         6357/TR  T1 ROWAN – TO TRIM TREE ALL ROUND BY 1 METRE, REASON – HANGING OVER THE CAR PARK AND TO MAINTAIN THE SHAPE OF THE TREES: FLAT 10, 158 FOUNTAIN STREET (TEALE).

RECEIVED 15/10/19

N         6354/TR  T1 HORSE CHESTNUT – CROWN LIFT TO 4 METRES; T2 LIME – REMOVE EPICORMIC GROWTH; T3 BEECH – PRUNE BACK LATERAL OVER-HANGING BRANCHES AWAY FROM PROPERTY TO APPROXIMATELY 2 METRES.  ALL WORK IS TO ALLOW MORE LIGHT INTO THE PROPERTY: 9 CALIFORNIA MEWS (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 28/10/19

N         5832  CONVERSION OF GARAGE TO HABITABLE ACCOMMODATION AND ADDITION OF BAY WINDOW TO FRONT: 1 BEECH STREET (TEALE).

RECEIVED 29/10/19

N         6431  ONE NEW DWELLING WITH GARAGES TO SIDE: 1111 DEWSBURY ROAD (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 31/10/19

NC       6664  SINGLE-STOREY SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION: 147 GLEN ROAD (TOPCLIFFE).

MTC had no objection but suggests the gap needs to be sufficient for wheelie bins to fit through.

N         6662  ALTERATION INCLUDING NEW GROUND-FLOOR DOOR TO SIDE AND SINGLE-STOREY SIDE/REAR EXTENSION WITH STEPS TO REAR: 2 GREENSHANK MEWS (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 5/11/19

N         6774/TR  T1 ASH – DRAWBACK FROM THE BUILDING BY 2 TO 3M TO SUITABLE GROWTH POINTS.  REMOVE EPICORMIC GROWTH FROM THE MAIN STEM.  DEADWOOD. DRAWBACK THE LOWER LIMBS BY 1 TO 2M THAT OVERHANG THE PUB CAR PARK TO HELP REDUCE THE RISK OF ANY BRANCHES FALLING: BONHAM COURT, 108A QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

O         6743/TR  T2, T3, T4 SYCAMORE – REMOVE DUE TO BEING RESPONSIBLE FOR ROOT INDUCED CLAY SHRINKAGE SUBSIDENCE DAMAGE.  REPLACE PLANTING OF STANDARD SIZE TREES WILL BE FUNDED BY INSURERS SUBJECT TO PLANTING LOCATION TO BE AGREED: CASTLE CROFT, 47 ROOMS LANE (SCATCHERD).  MTC felt that the trees are unlikely to be causing the damage stated.

N         6826/TR  T1 ASH – FELL DUE TO IT BEING VERY UNHEALTHY; T2 LIME – TIDY EPICORMIC SHOOTS ON THE LOWER TRUNK; T5 ASH – REMOVE 2 LOWER LIMBS TO BALANCE; T7 ASH – REMOVE 2 LOWER LIMBS OVER BUILDING (NEIGHBOURS PROPERTY): JW BINKS & SONS FUNERAL DIRECTORS, PARK HOUSE, 51B QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 12/11/19

N         6633  CONVERSION OF GARAGE TO HABITABLE ROOM SPACE: 7 FAIRFIELD RISE (CHURWELL).

N         6945  TWO-STOREY SIDE EXTENSION INCORPORATING AN INTEGRAL GARAGE; JULIET BALCONY TO REAR: TREE TOPS, 37 DEWSBURY ROAD (WOODKIRK).

N         6907  FOUR-STOREY SIDE EXTENSION FOR NEW OFFICE FLOORSPACE (USE CLASS B1), LANDSCAPING WORKS, ENHANCEMENTS TO THE WHITE ROSE OFFICE PARK ACCESS ROAD AND ASSOCIATED WORKS: PERFORM MEDIA SERVICES LTD; 1 WHITE ROSE OFFICE PARK, MILLSHAW PARK LANE (CHURWELL).

N         6903  RETROSPECTIVE APPLICATION FOR CONVERSION OF GARAGE TO HABITABLE ACCOMMODATION: 14 SHIRE CLOSE (ELMFIELD).

RECEIVED 13/11/19

O         6962  VARIATION OF CONDITION 11 (LANDSCAPING) OF PREVIOUSLY APPROVED PLANNING APPLICATION 17/07072/FU TO AMEND THE SOFT LANDSCAPING REQUIREMENTS: VICTORIA FILLING STATION, BRUNTCLIFFE ROAD (TEALE).  MTC objects to the removal of the condition as there is no good reason to its removal.

RECEIVED 20/11/19

N         7152  PART TWO-STOREY AND PART SINGLE-STOREY EXTENSION TO SIDE; NEW PITCHED ROOF TO EXISTING SINGLE-STOREY REAR: 64 REIN ROAD (ELMFIELD).

RECEIVED 21/11/19

N         7180/TR  T1 SYCAMORE – REMOVE 2 LOWEST BRANCHES TO GIVE CLEARANCE OVER GARAGE ROOF TO PREVENT DAMAGE TO TREE AND GARAGE: 27 BANTAM GROVE LANE (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 25/11/19

N         7084  RETROSPECTIVE APPLICATION FOR ANPR CAMERAS TO CAR PARK: B&M BARGAINS, PEEL STREET (CENTRAL).

N         7150  CHANGE OF USE OF VACANT RETAIL UNIT (A1) TO LOUNGE BAR (A4) INCLUDING EXTERNAL SEATING AREA: 108 QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

N         7143  ALTERATIONS INCLUDING RAISING ROOF HEIGHT AND TWO-STOREY AND SINGLE-STOREY REAR/SIDE EXTENSION: SCHOOL HOUSE, APPLEBY WAY (CENTRAL).

The above decisions made under Town Clerk’s delegated authority, were noted.

7.         TO DISCUSS AND AGREE PLANNING COMMITTEE BUDGET SUBMISSION FOR

2020/21 (for referral to the Finance, GP & Strategic Committee).  It was proposed and agreed the budget for 2020/21 be £1,000.

8.         TO RECEIVE ITEMS OF CORRESPONDENCE (items for information only)

(a)   Email and attachment dated 24/9/19 from Martin Elliot, Group Manager, Policy & Plans LCC re. Leeds Local Plan – Leeds Core Strategy Selective Review Adoption and copy of Adoption Statement Sept 2019 Final.

(b)   Letter dated 25/9/19 from Jonathan Carr, Head of Development Management, LCC re. appeal against refusal of planning application 18/03843/OT, 18 Church Lane, Tingley (Woodkirk).

(c)   Email 21/10/19 M Elliott, Head of Strategic Planning, LCC, re. ‘Leeds Review of Statement of Community Involvement: Have Your Say’.

(d)   Updated key planning enforcement cases for Morley North & Morley South Wards.

The above items of correspondence (a) to (d) were noted.

9.         DATE AND TIME OF NEXT MEETING

The next scheduled meeting will take place on Tuesday, 14th January 2020 at 7pm.

 

MINUTES OF PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING NO. 405

HELD ON TUESDAY, 17^TH SEPTEMBER 2019 

1. TO RECORD ATTENDANCE                                                                                                                                                                                                            Present:  Cllrs R Bell (Chairman), A Rhodes, C Taylor, R Finnigan, J Sanders, H Evans, M Storey and A Dalton (late arrival).  K Oakley – Town Clerk also attended.

2.         TO RECEIVE AND NOTE APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE AND CONSIDER REASONS GIVEN FOR NON-ATTENDANCE

Apologies were received from Cllr P Bennett and reason given for absence was noted.     

3. DECLARATIONS OF DISCLOSABLE PEXUNIARY AND OTHER INTERESTS          Cllr R Finnigan declared an ‘other’ interest in any appropriate items as he is on Plans Panel, LCC.

Cllr A Rhodes declared a ‘pecuniary’ interest in appn 3891 – Tingley Common (Topcliffe), as he owns the development company involved in the conversion.  As determination on this appn had previously been dealt with under Town Clerk’s delegated authority, and no further consideration or discussion took place, it was not necessary for Cllr Rhodes to leave the meeting.

4. TO APPROVE MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON 16/7/19

The Minutes of the meeting held on 16/7/19 were agreed as a true and correct record.

5. CONSIDERATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS

Notation of Recommendations.

O = Objection

N = No Objection

NC = No Objection (with comments)

D = Deferred

RECEIVED 30/8/19

N         5226  CHANGE OF USE OF STORAGE OR DISTRIBUTION (B8) TO LIGHT INDUSTRY (B1(c)), GENERAL INDUSTRIAL (B2) AND STORAGE OR DISTRIBUTION (B8) WITH ANCILLARY OFFICES (B1(a)): UNIT 9, BRUNTCLIFFE AVENUE (SCATCHERD).

Cllr A Dalton arrived at this point.

RECEIVED 2/9/19

N         5204  CHANGE OF USE FROM RETAIL UNIT (CLASS USE A1) TO DRINKING ESTABLISHMENT (CLASS USE A4): 6 STATION ROAD (CENTRAL).

Cllr H Evans left the meeting and returned during discussions on the above application.

N         5318  SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 24 IBBETSON OVAL (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 4/9/19

NC       5170  CONVERSION OF EXISTING INTEGRAL GARAGE TO FORM HABITABLE ROOM; SINGLE-STOREY REAR AND SIDE EXTENSION: 50 MARSTON AVENUE (ELMFIELD).

MTC recommends a condition be applied that a second parking place in front of the property should be created.

RECEIVED 11/9/19

N         5507  RECONFIGURATION OF EXISTING CAR PARKS; PROVISION OF ADDITIONAL PARKING SPACES AND ASSOCIATED WORKS: WHITE ROSE SHOPPING CENTRE, DEWSBURY ROAD (CHURWELL).

N         5506  RESERVED MATTERS APPLICATION FOR LAYOUT, ACCESS, SCALE, APPEARANCE AND LANDSCAPING OF PHASES 2 AND 3 PURSUANT TO APPROVAL 15/00363/OT: WHITE ROSE SHOPPING CENTRE, DEWSBURY ROAD (CHURWELL).

N         5534  DORMER WINDOW TO FRONT: 33 SCOTCHMAN LANE (TEALE).

The above planning applications were considered by all members of the Planning Committee present.  It was agreed that any comments be submitted via ‘Public Access’.

6. TO NOTE PLANNING APPLICATIONS WITH DECISIONS MADE UNDER DELEGATED AUTHORITY TO TOWN CLERK – STANDING ORDER 15(c) (APPLICATIONS RECEIVED THAT DID NOT APPEAR ON 16/07/19 AGENDA)

 RECEIVED 12/7/19

N         4177  SINGLE-STOREY EXTENSION WITH RAISED DECKING AREA AND STEPS TO REAR:   12 DUNLIN CLOSE (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 15/7/19

O         4311 TWO-STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 75 WYNYARD DRIVE (TEALE).

MTC objected to this application due to impact on the street scene as there are no similar extensions in the locality.

RECEIVED 18/7/19

N         3891  CONVERSION OF EXISTING BUILDING TO 11 DWELLINGS; DEMOLITION OF EXISTING BUILDINGS TO REAR; CONSTRUCTION OF THREE DWELLINGS TO REAR WITH ASSOCIATED ACCESS: TINGLEY COMMON (TOPCLIFFE).

N         4374  FIRST-FLOOR EXTENSION TO REAR AND NEW JULIET BALCONY TO GROUND FLOOR TO REAR: FIELD VIEW, SCOTCHMAN LANE (TEALE).

RECEIVED 24/7/19

N         3555  DEMOLITION OF EXISTING COMMERCIAL GARAGE UNITS, NEW DETACHED WORKSHOPS AND MOT-TESTING FACILITIES; ASSOCIATED WORKS INCLUDING INTERNAL ROADWAY, ENTRANCE GATES TO DEWSBURY ROAD ENTRANCE: ME AUTOS CAR AND LIGHT COMMERCIAL LTD, 1242 DEWSBURY ROAD, TINGLEY (WOODKIRK).

NC       4495  DORMER WINDOW TO REAR: 7 SHIRE CLOSE (ELMFIELD).

MTC has no objection in principle to this planning application, however, members recommend that the rear dormer should have a pitched roof.

RECEIVED 30/7/19

N         4323  SINGLE-STOREY FRONT EXTENSION: 3 WESTWOOD CLOSE (CHURWELL).

N         4573  REPLACE DORMER TO FRONT WITH NEW DORMER WINDOWS TO FRONT/REAR AND SINGLE-STOREY SIDE EXTENSION WITH ROOF LIGHTS TO FRONT: 83 RYEDALE WAY (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 1/8/19

N         3996  SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 8 GRANGE PARK DRIVE (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 2/8/19

N         4114  RETROSPECTIVE APPLICATION FOR TWO CONTAINERS AND A SMOKING SHELTER TO CAR PARK: VILLAGE HOTEL, CAPITOL BOULEVARD (TOPCLIFFE).

N         4615  SUBSTITUTION OF HOUSE TYPE (ON PREVIOUS APPROVAL 18/01725/FU) – PLOT 16 REPLACING ONE 3-STOREY END TERRACE UNIT WITH NEW 2.5-STOREY END TERRACE UNIT ON HOUSING DEVELOPMENT: 16 CARSON GROVE (TEALE).

N         4634/TR  SYCAMORE TREES (SIDE OF THE HOUSE AND PUB) – CROWN LIFT AND CROWN THINNING UP TO 20% TO CUT BRANCHES AWAY FROM HOUSE AS THE BRANCHES ARE BANGING ON THE ROOF IN HIGH WINDS AND SQUIRRELS GAINING ACCESS TO THE ROOF: 15 BRIDGE COURT (ELMFIELD).

RECEIVED 5/8/19

N         4616  CONSTRUCTION OF 22 NO. HOUSES: TINGLEY MILLS, BRIDGE STREET (ELMFIELD).

N         4522  INSTALLATION OF DIESEL BACK-UP GENERATOR: ASDA STORE, HOWLEY PARK ROAD (ELMFIELD).

RECEIVED 6/8/19

 N         4691/TR  T1 SILVER BIRCH – REDUCE BY 3 TO 4 METRES OVER THE TOTAL CROWN AREA TO HELP WITH THE LIGHT TO A NEIGHBOURING GARDEN; T2 PEAR – FELL DUE TO AFFECTING NEIGHBOURING HOUSE WITH NO REPLACEMENT: PROSPECT HOUSE, 16B VICTORIA GRANGE DRIVE (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 7/8/19 

N         4770  CHANGE OF USE FROM A2 (FINANCIAL AND PROFESSIONAL SERVICES) TO D2 (LEISURE USE) WITH ANCILLARY KITCHEN AND BAR: THE POINT, WHITE ROSE SHOPPING CENTRE, DEWSBURY ROAD (CHURWELL). 

N         4899: SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 31 MILLSIDE WALK (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 13/8/19

N         4496  NEW DETACHED DWELLING TWO-STOREY WITH GARAGE TO REAR: ROMANY COTTAGE, HOWDEN CLOUGH ROAD (TEALE).

RECEIVED 20/8/19

O         5105  TWO-STOREY AND SINGLE-STOREY FRONT, SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION:     6 TINGLEY CRESCENT (WOODKIRK).

MTC objected to this application on the grounds of the impact on the street scene to front.  Impact on residential amenity on rear extension.

RECEIVED 27/8/19

N         5158  LISTED BUILDING APPLICATION FOR THE INSTALLATION OF NEW COUNTER POSITIONS; REMOVAL OF MODERN PARTITIONING; MAKING GOOD OF MODERN SUSPENDED CEILING AND FLOORING FINISHES; ONE EXTERNAL NOTICE TO FRONT; ONE EXTERNAL NOTICE TO REAR:  HSBC BANK, QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 28/8/19

N         5084/TR  T1 – WHITE BEAM – REMOVE; T2 WHITE BEAM – REMOVE; T3 FRUIT TREE – REMOVE; T4 – WHITE BEAM – REMOVE: 137 SPRINGFIELD ROAD (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 9/9/19

N         5517/TR  5 x LIME – REMOVE EPICORMIC GROWTH: 58A BRIDGE STREET (CENTRAL).

The above decisions made under Town Clerk’s delegated authority, were noted.

7. TO CONSIDER INFORMATION CONTAINED IN EMAIL DATED 2/9/19 RE: CORE STRATEGY REVIEW

            The content of the email dated 2/9/19 was noted.

8. TO NOTE INFORMATION CONTAINED IN EMAIL DATED 6/9/19 FROM S SPENCE, YLCA, RE. ‘CONSULTATION ON PROPOSED REFORMS TO PERMITTED DEVELOPMENT RIGHTS TO SUPPORT THE DEPLOYMENT OF 5G AND EXTEND MOBILE COVERAGE AND CONSIDER TOWN COUNCIL RESPONSE (IF ANY); RESPONSES REQUIRED BY 18/10/19

The content of the email dated 6/9/19 was noted. 

9. TO CONSIDER INFORMATION CONTAINED IN EMAIL DATED 5/9/19 FROM WHP TELECOMS LTD RE. ‘52997(B) MORLEY TOWN COUNCIL UPGRADE PRE-CON 5G’

The content of the email dated 5/9/19 was noted.

10. TO RECEIVE ITEMS OF CORRESPONDENCE (items for information only)

• Email and attachments dated 22/7/19 from WHP Telecoms Ltd re. ‘Pre-Planning Consultation’ for Proposed Rooftop Installation Upgrade at CTIL 109397 Morley Fire Station, Corporation Street, Morley.
• Email dated 30/7/19 from Martin Elliot, Group Manager, Policy & Plans, LCC re. Leeds Local Plan – Site Allocations Plan Adoption, with attached statement. Responses, if any, required no later than 21/8/19.
• Email dated 31/7/19 from Martin Elliot, Group Manager, Policy & Plans, LCC re. Tall Buildings Design Guide Supplementary Planning Document, advising on public consultation for eight weeks until 5pm 30/9/19.
• Email 1/8/19 Cllr T Leadley to Chief Planning Officer re. Appn 19/03973 – Snittles Farm, Off Gelderd Road (Morley North).
• Email 1/8/19 Cllr T Leadley to Chief Planning Officer re. Appn 19/01988 – Laneside Farm, Victoria Road.
• Letter 13/8/19 Leeds Planning Services to Town Clerk re. Appeal No. 103812 by Candore Developments Ltd, Morley United Services Club, High Street, Morley LS27 9AL (Planning Inspectorate Ref: APP/N4720/W/19/3234225).
• Updated key planning enforcement cases for Morley North & Morley South Wards.
• The Town Clerk tabled an email dated 14/9/19 with attachment from the Chair of the Tong and Fulneck Valley Association re. ‘Objections to Green Belt Incursion’.

The above items of correspondence (a) to (h) were noted.

11. DATE AND TIME OF NEXT MEETING

The next scheduled meeting will take place on Tuesday, 15^th October 2019 at 7pm.

 

MINUTES OF PLANNING COMMITTEE NO. 404

HELD ON TUESDAY, 16TH JULY 2019

1.         TO RECORD ATTENDANCE

Present:  Cllrs R Bell (Chairman), H Evans, R Finnigan, C Taylor, P Bennett, M Storey, J Sanders and A Dalton.  W Maynard-Light (Deputy Town Clerk) also attended.

2.         TO RECEIVE AND NOTE APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE AND CONSIDER REASONS GIVEN FOR NON-ATTENDANCE
There were no apologies.

3.         DECLARATIONS OF DISCLOSABLE PECUNIARY AND OTHER INTERESTS

Cllr R Finnigan declared an ‘other’ interest in any appropriate items, as he is a member of Leeds Plans Panel, LCC.

4.         TO APPROVE MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON 18/6/19

The minutes of the meeting held on 18/6/19 were agreed as a true and correct record.

5.         CONSIDERATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS
Notation of Recommendations.
O = Objection
N = No Objection
NC = No Objection (with comments)
D = Deferred

RECEIVED 28/6/19

N         3790  SINGLE-STOREY EXTENSION TO REAR: 25 BITTERN RISE (TOPCLIFFE).

O         3622  OUTLINE APPLICATION FOR RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT OF NINE HOUSES INCLUDING FORMATION OF A NEW ACCESS: LAND ADJACENT HORSFALL FARM, HORSFALL STREET (SCATCHERD).  MTC objected to this application due to highways safety issues, land not allocated for housing, i.e. green field/belt, designs do not fit in with the street scene and development is very near the motorway.  Potential over-development of the site.

RECEIVED 2/7/19

N         3875  DORMER WINDOW TO FRONT: 7 BEDALE (WOODKIRK).

N         3953  SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 18 MEADOWBROOK COURT (TEALE).

RECEIVED 3/7/19

N         3628  FORMATION OF A RAMPED ACCESSIBLE ENTRANCE AND OTHER ASSOCIATED ALTERATIONS TO DOCTOR’S SURGERY: SHENSTONE HOUSE, ELLAND ROAD (CHURWELL).

NC       3086  CHANGE OF USE FROM A3 TO A3/A5 WITH ALTERATIONS TO SITE LAYOUT AND ELEVATIONS; INSTALLATION OF DRIVE-THRU LANE WITH TWO CUSTOMER ORDER DISPLAYS WITH ASSOCATED WORK; PART-DEMOLITION OF EXISTING BUILDING AND CREATION OF CORRAL AREA TO BACK OF HOUSE: FORMER WHITE ROSE HARVESTER, WIDE LANE (TOPCLIFFE).  MTC request that a condition be applied under Sec 106 Agreement that only local people be employed.

RECEIVED 4/7/19

O         3838  RESERVED MATTERS APPLICATION FOR A DETACHED HOUSE: LAND ADJACENT LANESIDE HOUSE, VICTORIA ROAD (CHURWELL).   MTC objected to this application as Laneside is the only access road and is already serving several properties.  Alternative access should be sought.

Cllr A Dalton left the meeting at this point.

RECEIVED 5/7/19

O         3812  DETACHED BLOCK OF TWO OFFICES WITH ATTACHED WORKSHOP TO VACANT SITE: 19A BRUNTCLIFFE ROAD (TEALE).  MTC objected to this application due to access being from an unadopted road, commercial premises being in the middle of a residential area and no appropriate parking provision.

N         3805  SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 20 HARRIER WAY (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 8/7/19

NC       4075  EXTENSION TO EXISTING GARAGE: 18 IBBETSON COURT (CHURWELL).

MTC requests a condition be applied that the garage should not be used as living space.

RECEIVED 9/7/19

NC       3973  VARIATION OF CONDITION 2 (APPROVED PLANS) OF PLANNING APPROVAL 18/00251/FU TO ALLOW MINOR AMENDMENTS TO THE LAYOUT AND SOME HOUSE TYPES: LAND AT SNITTLES FARM, GELDERD ROAD (HOLBECK).

MTC requests a condition be applied that designs must comply with room size obligations.

The above Planning applications were considered by all members of the Planning Committee present.  It was agreed that any comments be sent via ‘Public Access’.

6.         TO NOTE PLANNING APPLICATIONS WITH DECISIONS MADE UNDER DELEGATED AUTHORITY TO TOWN CLERK – STANDING ORDER 15(c) (APPLICATIONS RECEIVED THAT DID NOT APPEAR ON 18/06/19 AGENDA)

RECEIVED 17/6/19

N         3432  CHANGE OF USE OF VACANT LAUNDERETTE TO HAIRDRESSERS: 60A MIDDLETON ROAD (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 18/6/19

N         2776  REPLACEMENT AIR-CONDITIONING SYSTEM: HSBC BANK PLC BANK CHAMBERS, QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

N         2777  LISTED BUILDING APPLICATION FOR REPLACEMENT AIR-CONDITIONING SYSTEM: HSBC BANK PLC BANK CHAMBERS, QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

N         3291  ONE NEW DWELLING: LAND ADJACENT 157 HIGH STREET (ELMFIELD).

RECEIVED 24/6/19

O         3625  PART TWO STOREY PART SINGLE STOREY SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION: 18 SUNNYSIDE AVENUE (WOODKIRK).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of over-development of the site and insufficient parking for two vehicles.

RECEIVED 25/6/19

O         18/02783  LISTED BUILDING APPLICATION FOR THE CHANGE OF USE FROM OFFICE, STORAGE AND WORKSHOP TO 8 NO. FLATS WITH ASSOCIATED LANDSCAPING; INTERNAL AND EXTERNAL ALTERATIONS INCLUDING NEW WINDOWS AND DOORS, INSTALLATION OF NEW FLOORS: CHURWELL HOUSE, 65 ELLAND ROAD (CHURWELL).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of over-development of the site with too many flats.

O         18/02782  CHANGE OF USE FROM OFFICE, STORAGE AND WORKSHOP TO 8 NO. FLATS WITH ASSOCIATED LANDSCAPING: CHURWELL HOUSE, 65 ELLAND ROAD (CHURWELL).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of over-development of the site with too many flats.

RECEIVED 26/6/19

N         3628  FORMATION OF A NEW RAMPED ACCESSIBLE ENTRANCE AND OTHER ASSOCIATED ALTERATIONS TO DOCTOR’S SURGERY: SHENSTONE HOUSE, ELLAND ROAD (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 2/7/19

O         3573/TR  T1: SYCAMORE – FELL: 23 WOODCROSS GARTH (CHURWELL).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds that there is no rood reason to remove this tree.

The above decisions made under Town Clerk’s delegated authority, were noted.

7.         TO RECEIVE ITEMS OF CORRESPONDENCE (items for information only)

(a)        Copies of representations made (if any) since last meeting held on 18/6/19.

(b)        Email dated 25/6/19 from Martin Elliot, Group Manager (Policy & Plans), LCC re. Site Allocations Plan: Inspectors Report.

(c)        This item of correspondence was tabled.  Email and attachment from Clerk HPVC re. ‘Holme Valley Draft Neighbourhood Development Plan Regulation 14 Consultation’.

The above items of correspondence were noted.

8.         DATE AND TIME OF NEXT MEETING

It was agreed to cancel the next scheduled meeting on Tuesday, 20th August 2019 at 7pm.  The next scheduled meeting will take place on Tuesday, 17th September 2019 at 7pm.

 

MINUTES OF PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING NO. 403

HELD ON TUESDAY, 18TH JUNE 2019

1.         TO RECORD ATTENDANCE

Present:  Councillors H Evans (Deputy Chairman), J Sanders, M Storey, A Dalton and R Finnigan.

W Maynard-Light (Deputy Town Clerk) also attended.

2.         TO RECEIVE AND NOTE APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE AND CONSIDER REASONS GIVEN FOR NON-ATTENDANCE
Apologies were received from Councillors R Bell and reason given for absence was noted.

3.         Declarations of Disclosable Pecuniary and Other Interests

Cllr R Finnigan declared an ‘other’ interest as a Leeds City Councillor and a member of Plans Panel.

4.         TO APPROVE MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON 28/5/19

The minutes of the meeting held on 28/5/19 were agreed as a true and correct record.

5.         CONSIDERATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS

Notation of Recommendations.
O = Objection
N = No Objection
NC = No Objection (with comments)
D = Deferred

RECEIVED 5/6/19

N         3304  SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 18A REIN ROAD (ELMFIELD).

N         2839  CHANGE OF USE OF PART OF DWELLING TO TAXI BUSINESS:

60 SPRINGFIELD AVENUE (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 7/6/19

N         3532  SINGLE-STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 15 THE OAKS (CHURWELL).

The above Planning applications were considered by all members of the Planning Committee present.  It was agreed that any comments made be sent via Public Access’.

6.         TO NOTE PLANNING APPLICATIONS WITH DECISIONS MADE UNDER DELEGATED AUTHORITY TO TOWN CLERK – STANDING ORDER 15(c) (APPLICATIONS RECEIVED THAT DID NOT APPEAR ON 19/03/19 AGENDA)

RECEIVED 24/5/19

N         3034  SINGLE-STOREY EXTENSION TO REAR AND CONVERSION OF GARAGE TO HABITABLE ACCOMMODATION: 11 UPPER GREEN WAY (WOODKIRK).

N         2742  RETROSPECTIVE APPLICATION FOR GARAGE TO REAR WITH RAISED DECKING AREA ABOVE GARAGE: 2A WILLIAM STREET (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 28/5/19

N         3028  CHANGE OF USE OF PUBLIC HIGHWAY TO CREATE AN EXTERNAL SEATING AREA: PICTURE HOUSE, 117A QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

N         3099  SINGLE-STOREY SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION: 2 PETREL WAY (TOPCLIFFE).

N         1498  AMENDMENTS TO APPN 19/01498/FU: SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION; SINGLE-STOREY FRONT EXTENSION; DORMER TO REAR AND ROOF LIGHTS TO FRONT: 9 SEVEN HILL CLOSE (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 7/6/19

N         3522  T1 SILVER BIRCH – REMOVE DUE TO TREE BEING IN DECLINE; T2 AND T3 ELM – REDUCE BACK TO PREVIOUS REDUCTION POINTS TO ALLOW LIGHT INTO GARDEN: BRIGHTON HOUSE, GLADSTONE TERRACE (TEALE).

The above decisions made under Town Clerk’s delegated authority, were noted.

7.         TO DISCUSS AND AGREE TOWN COUNCIL RESPONSE (IF ANY), TO THE CORE STRATEGY REVIEW CONSULTATION

Following a discussion, it was agreed the Town Council would make no response.

8.         TO RECEIVE ITEMS OF CORRESPONDENCE (items for information only)

(a)        Copies of representations made (if any) since last meeting held on 28/5/19

(b)        Copy of Adoption Statement re. ‘The Hot Food Takeaway Supplementary Planning Document (SPD)’ dated 24th April 2019.

(c)        Copy of letter dated 4th June 2019 from Cllr T Leadley to Chief Planning Officer re. Planning Appn 19/01988: Persimmon Homes & Priestgate Morley Ltd: Housing & School Site: Laneside Farm, Victoria Road, Morley.

(d)        Various emails regarding former Harvester site, Wide Lane, Morley.

(e)        Email 10/6/19 from a resident re. ‘Planning Permission and use of dwelling on Bridge Street’.

9.         DATE AND TIME OF NEXT MEETING

The next scheduled meeting will take place on Tuesday, 16th July 2019 at 7pm.

 

MINUTES OF PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING NO. 402

 HELD ON TUESDAY, 28TH MAY 2019

1.         TO RECORD ATTENDANCE

Present:  Councillors R Bell (Chairman), J Sanders, M Storey, A Rhodes and R Finnigan.

W Maynard-Light (Deputy Town Clerk) also attended.

2.         TO RECEIVE AND NOTE APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE AND CONSIDER REASONS GIVEN FOR NON-ATTENDANCE
Apologies were received from Councillors A Dalton, H Evans and C Taylor and reasons given for absence were noted.

3.         Declarations of Disclosable Pecuniary and Other Interests

Cllr R Finnigan declared an ‘other’ interest as a Leeds City Councillor and a member of Plans Panel.

4.         TO APPROVE MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON 16/4/19

The minutes of the meeting held on 16/4/19 were agreed as a true and correct record.

5.         CONSIDERATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS

Notation of Recommendations.
O = Objection
N = No Objection
NC = No Objection (with comments)
D = Deferred
RECEIVED 17/4/19

O         1988  RESERVED MATTERS APPLICATION FOR THE LAYOUT, SCALE, APPEARANCE AND LANDSCAPING FOR 526 NEW HOMES, PURSUANT TO OUTLINE APPLICATION 16/02988/OT AND THE CONSENT, AGREEMENT OR APPROVAL REQUIRED BY CONDITIONS 2, 8-11, 13, 21-24, 28, 29, 33 AND 34: LANESIDE FARM, VICTORIA ROAD (SCATCHERD).

MTC objects to this planning application on the grounds that the proposed development is not sustainable, the public open space situated under the electricity pylons is unacceptable for the safety of families, in particular children.  The increased traffic disruptions to the local road together with the impact on the already congested inner ring road plus the number of vehicles accessing and exiting the proposed development which will be increased with the proposed two-form entry primary school.  Members considered there were insufficient 2-3 bedroomed properties planned to deal with local housing needs and too many 1-bedroomed apartments.

N.B.  Cllr Finnigan abstained from voting on the above application.

RECEIVED 10/5/19

O         2653  DORMER WINDOW TO FRONT: 16 MARSHALL STREET (CENTRAL).

MTC objects to this planning application on the grounds of the impact on the street scene with no other such developments in the immediate proximity.

RECEIVED 14/5/19

N         2761  ALTERATIONS AND ENLARGEMENT OF EXISTING OUTSIDE SEATING AREA INCLUDING HARD LANDSCAPING WORK TO FRONT, DOUBLE GATES AND FENCE TO YARD AREA: THE BRITISH OAK, 407 WESTERTON ROAD (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 15/5/19

N         2308  CHANGE OF USE AND ALTERATIONS INCLUDING FIRST FLOOR EXTENSION OF GARAGE OF RESIDENTIAL RENTAL ACCOMMODATION PREMISES TO FORM ADDITIONAL FLAT: EGYPT COTTAGE, BRITANNIA ROAD (ELMFIELD).

RECEIVED 16/5/19

N         2809  TWO STOREY AND SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION AND SINGLE STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 14 DAILY HILL CLOSE (SCATCHERD).

N         2824  DEMOLITION OF EXISTING DETACHED GARAGE; CONSTRUCTION OF THREE STOREY SIDE EXTENSION WITH NEW ROOF AND ROOFLIGHTS: 6 SPRINGWOOD COURT (ELMFIELD).

O         2560  FOUR DWELLINGS (TWO PAIRS OF SEMI-DETACHED): LAND OFF TROY ROAD (CENTRAL).

MTC objects to this planning application on the grounds of lack of clarity on the proposed dwellings, no formal plans of the proposed dwellings.

N         2797  AMENDMENT TO PLANNING PERMISSION 18/06492/FU INVOLVING EXTENSIONS TO WAREHOUSE: HOWLEY PARK ROAD EAST (ELMFIELD).

The above Planning applications were considered by all members of the Planning Committee present.  It was agreed that any comments made be sent via Public Access.

6.         TO NOTE PLANNING APPLICATIONS WITH DECISIONS MADE UNDER DELEGATED AUTHORITY TO TOWN CLERK – STANDING ORDER 15(c) (APPLICATIONS RECEIVED THAT DID NOT APPEAR ON 19/03/19 AGENDA)

RECEIVED 12/4/19

N         2067  CONVERSION OF GARAGE TO STORE: 17 WOODCROSS FOLD (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 16/4/19

N         1973  ASSISTED LIVING FACILITY OF TWO BUNGALOWS AND TEN FLATS: BANK STREET AND CHAPEL HILL (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 17/4/19

N         2109  VARIATION OF CONDITION 2 (APPROVED PLANS) AND REMOVAL OF CONDITION 5 (PROPOSED WINDOWS AND DOORS) OF APPROVAL 10/03317/FU TO CREATE BASEMENT, CHANGE EAST ELEVATION DOOR TO WINDOW, REMOVE CENTRAL GROUND FLOOR WINDOW TO NORTH ELEVATION AND ADDITION OF BALUSTRADE TO ESCAPE WINDOWS IN BASEMENT ON SOUTH ELEVATION: COTTAGE TO REAR IN SAVILES SQUARE, QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 1/5/19

O         2436  PART TWO-STOREY PART SINGLE-STOREY FRONT, SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION:  6 TINGLEY CRESCENT (WOODKIRK).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of the impact on the street scene and residential amenities, both at the front and rear of the property, together with over-development of the plot and significant reduction of garden space.  Members requested this application be referred to Plans Panel.

N         2119  REPLACEMENT WINDOWS TO APARTMENTS: FAIRFIELD HOUSE, 51 SCATCHERD LANE (TEALE).

RECEIVED 8/5/19

N         2469  SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 26 CROFT HOUSE GARDENS (SCATCHERD).

N         2473  PART TWO-STOREY PART SINGLE-STOREY SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION: 64 REIN ROAD (ELMFIELD).

RECEIVED 9/5/19

N         2702  SINGLE-STOREY EXTENSION TO SIDE: 1 TEAL DRIVE (TOPCLIFFE).

N         2676  SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION; FIRST-FLOOR FRONT EXTENSION:

88 DEWSBURY ROAD (WOODKIRK).

The above decision made under Town Clerk’s delegated authority, were noted.

7.         TO RECEIVE ITEMS OF CORRESPONDENCE (items for information only)

(a)        Copies of representations made (if any) since last meeting held on 16/4/19.

(b)        Updated key planning enforcement cases for Morley North & Morley South Wards.

The above items of correspondence were received and noted.

8.         DATE AND TIME OF NEXT MEETING

The next scheduled meeting will be 18th June 2019 at 7pm.

 

MINUTES OF PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING NO. 401

 HELD ON TUESDAY, 16^TH APRIL 2019 

1. TO RECORD ATTENDANCE

Present:  Councillors R Finnigan (Chairman), H Bell, H Evans and C Windle.  K Oakley – Town Clerk also attended.

2.         TO RECEIVE AND NOTE APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE AND CONSIDER REASONS GIVEN FOR NON-ATTENDANCE

Apologies were received from Councillors J Sanders, W Whitehead, J Foley and C Taylor and reasons given for absence were noted.

3. Declarations of Disclosable Pecuniary and Other Interests

None were declared.

4. TO APPROVE MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON 19/3/19

The minutes of the meeting held on 19/3/19 were agreed as a true and correct record.

5. CONSIDERATION OF PLANNING APPLICATION  

Notation of Recommendations.

O = Objection

N = No Objection

NC = No Objection (with comments)

D = Deferred

RECEIVED 1/4/19

N         1584  SINGLE-STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 9 PARKFIELD COURT (TEALE).

N         1738  SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION WITH PARAPET WALL: 49 NEW PARK STREET (TEALE).

N         1754  SINGLE-STOREY EXTENSION TO SIDE AND REAR: 18 LANESIDE FOLD (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 3/4/19

N         1812  VARIATION OF CONDITION 1 (APPROVED PLANS) OF PREVIOUSLY APPROVED APPLICATION 18/07729/FU TO AMEND THE PROPOSED ELEVATIONS TO INCLUDE ROOF LIGHTS: LAND AT JUNCTION OF ST PAUL’S STREET AND SOUTH QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 8/4/19

N         1789  CHANGE OF USE OF GUEST FLAT AND STORE TO FORM OFFICE: WARDEN’S HOUSE, 1 INGLE COURT (SCATCHERD).

O         1681  ALTERATIONS INCLUDING TWO-STOREY SIDE PART SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION; HIP TO GABLE ROOF EXTENSION WITH DORMER WINDOW TO REAR; DEMOLISHING OF EXISTING GARAGE; HARDSTANDING TO FRONT; REPLACEMENT OF BOUNDARY FENCE WITH TIMBER FENCE: 18 SUNNYSIDE AVENUE (WOODKIRK). MTC objected due to lack of parking space for second vehicle.

RECEIVED 10/4/19

N         2034  TWO-STOREY PART SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION AND DORMER TO REAR:  7 MIDDLETON TERRACE (TOPCLIFFE). 

The above Planning applications were considered by all members of the Planning Committee present.  It was agreed that any comments made be sent via Public Access’. 

6. TO NOTE PLANNING APPLICATIONS WITH DECISIONS MADE UNDER DELEGATED AUTHORITY TO TOWN CLERK – STANDING ORDER 15(c) (APPLICATIONS RECEIVED THAT DID NOT APPEAR ON 19/03/19 AGENDA)

RECEIVED 21/3/19

N         1628  RETROSPECTIVE APPLICATION FOR A DORMER WINDOW TO REAR:                     44 IBBETSON OVAL (CHURWELL).

N         1497  TWO-STOREY AND SINGLE-STOREY SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION:

106 SPRINGFIELD AVENUE (SCATCHERD).

N         1451  CONSERVATORY TO REAR: 44 CORPORATION STREET (CENTRAL).

N         1299TR  T1 OAK – REMOVE OVERHANGING BRANCHES BACK BY 3 METRES BACK TO BOUNDARY LINE.  T2 OAK – REMOVE OVERHANGING BRANCHES BY 5 METRES:  8 CLARK SPRING CLOSE (CHURWELL).

N         0863  CHANGE OF USE FROM VEHICLE WORKSHOP TO MOT TESTING STATION AND GARAGE: UNIT 1, HAWTHORN COURT, HOWLEY PARK ROAD (ELMFIELD).

N         1294  CHANGE OF USE FROM A2 (PROFESSIONAL SERVICES) TO A4 (WINE BAR):

135-137 QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 22/3/19

NC       1498  SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION; SINGLE-STOREY FRONT EXTENSION, DORMER WINDOW TO REAR AND ROOFLIGHTS TO FRONT: 9 SEVEN HILL CLOSE (SCATCHERD). MTC has no objection in principle, however, a condition should be applied that rear dormer should be pitched to match similar dormers on the estate.

RECEIVED 27/03/19

N         1687  SINGLE-STOREY SIDE/REAR EXTENSION: 15 THE ROUNDWAY (TEALE).

N         1703  SINGLE-STOREY EXTENSION TO SIDE AND REAR: 6 KESTREL GARTH TOPCLIFFE).

N         1902/TR  T1 COPPER BEECH – REDUCE THE CANOPY ALL ROUND BY APPROX 2 METRES BACK TO SUITABLE GROWTH POINTS, T2 BIRCH – REDUCE THE HEIGHT OF THE TALL BIRCH TREE BY APPROX 2-3 METRES TO MATCH THE HEIGHT OF THE COPPER BEECH TREE, T3 AND T4 MAPLE – REDUCE BOTH MAPLE TREES BY APPROX 2 METRES TO CLEAR THE STREET LIGHT COLUMN: LYNDHURST, 53 NEW PARK STREET (TEALE).

RECEIVED 1/4/19

NC       1932/TR  T1 SYCAMORE: THIS TREE LOCATED AT THE FRONT OF THE PROPERTY IS A DOMINANT FEATURE CAUSING SHADE TO ASHGARTH AND ADJACENT PROPERTIES.  WE WOULD LIKE TO REMOVE THIS TREE AND REPLACE IT WITH A STANDARD ENGLISH OAK: ASHGARTH, BRUNTCLIFFE ROAD (TEALE). MTC suggests a condition be applied that the replacement tree needs to be of a relevant size.

The above decisions made under Town Clerk’s delegated authority, were noted.

7. TO RECEIVE ITEMS OF CORRESPONDENCE (items for information only) 

(a)        Copies of representations made (if any) since last meeting held on 19/3/19

The above item(s) of correspondence were noted.

8. DATE AND TIME OF NEXT MEETING

The next scheduled meeting will be agreed at the Annual Full Council meeting to be held on

15^th May 2019.

 

MINUTES OF PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING NO. 400

HELD ON TUESDAY, 19TH MARCH 2019

1.         TO RECORD ATTENDANCE

Present:  Councillors R Finnigan (Chairman), C Windle, H Bell, A Rhodes, C Taylor (late arrival) and H Evans (late arrival).  W Maynard-Light (Deputy Town Clerk) also attended.

2.         TO RECEIVE AND NOTE APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE AND CONSIDER REASONS GIVEN FOR NON-ATTENDANCE
Apologies were received from Cllrs J Foley and W Whitehead.  The reason was accepted and noted.

 

3.         Declarations of Disclosable Pecuniary and Other Interests

There were no interests declared.

4.         TO APPROVE MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON 19/2/19

The minutes of the meeting held on 19/2/19 were agreed as a true and correct record.

5.         CONSIDERATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS
Notation of Recommendations.
O = Objection
N = No Objection
NC = No Objection (with comments)
D = Deferred

RECEIVED 20/2/19

NC       0915  CHANGE OF USE OF 8 PARKING SPACES TO HAND CAR WASH AND VALETING OPERATION INCLUDING INSTALLATION OF A CABIN AND CANOPY: ASDA, HOWLEY PARK ROAD (ELMFIELD).

MTC approved this planning application in principle.  Members requested a condition be placed on the application that the car wash did not open until 10 am on Sundays.

NOTE:  Planning Authority confirmed withdrawal of application on 12/3/19.

Cllr Taylor arrived during the above item.

RECEIVED 27/2/19

N         0932  CONVERSION OF GARAGE INTO HABITABLE ROOM: 1 IBBETSON COURT (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 28/2/19

N         0791  TWO NON-ILLUMINATED SIGNS: 1 WHITE ROSE OFFICE PARK, MILLSHAW PARK LANE (CHURWELL).

O         0596  DETACHED BLOCK OF TWO FLATS: LAND OFF ROOMS LANE (SCATCHERD).

MTC objected to this application on the grounds of over development of the site.

RECEIVED 1/3/19

N         0862  REMOVAL OF OLD FENCE AND CONSTRUCTION OF NEW TIMBER FENCE:

15 SISKIN COURT (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 5/3/19

NC       0747  FOUR DETACHED HOUSES: LAND OFF THE GALLOPS (ELMFIELD).

MTC approved this planning application in principle.  Members suggested plots 01 and 02 be moved backwards by 1 metre to create a lay-by parking area at the entrance for visitor parking, Concern were expressed on the collection of refuse and no provision of a turning circle.

RECEIVED 11/3/19

N         1200  SUBSTITUTION OF HOUSE TYPE TO PLOT 5 (PREVIOUS APP 16/04805/FU):

PLOT 5, OFF BAGHILL GREEN (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 12/3/19

NC       1127  CHANGE OF USE OF MOTOR VEHICLE AUCTION CENTRE (USE CLASS SUI GENERIS) TO HAULAGE YARD (SUI GENERIS): FORMER INDEPENDENT MOTOR AUCTIONS, BRUNTCLIFFE LANE (TEALE).

MTC approved this planning application in principle.  Members requested a condition be placed on the application regarding the operation times at the weekend, members suggested Saturday 7am to midnight, Sunday 7am to 9pm.

NC       1275  ALTERATIONS INCLUDING PART TWO-STOREY, PART SINGLE-STOREY SIDE   EXTENSION: 4 MILLBECK APPROACH (TOPCLIFFE).

MTC objected to this application on the grounds of overdevelopment of the site, loss of off-street parking and the impact on the street scene, there are no similar developments in the immediate area.

The above Planning applications were considered by all members of the Planning Committee present.  It was agreed that any comments made be sent via ‘Public Access’.

6.         TO NOTE PLANNING APPLICATIONS WITH DECISIONS MADE UNDER DELEGATED AUTHORITY TO TOWN CLERK – STANDING ORDER 15(c) (APPLICATIONS RECEIVED THAT DID NOT APPEAR ON 16/10/18 AGENDA)

RECEIVED 18/2/19

N         0560  ONE NON-ILLUMINATED SIGN: 70A QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 25/2/19

N         0956  FIRST-FLOOR SIDE EXTENSION WITH NEW TERRACE TO THE SIDE: FIELD VIEW, SCOTCHMAN LANE (TEALE).

RECEIVED 26/2/19

N         1005  SINGLE-STOREY SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION: 6 TOPCLIFFE AVENUE (TOPCLIFFE).

N         0413  LISTED BUILDING CONSENT TO REMOVE GROUND-FLOOR SIDE WINDOW, ENLARGE THE OPENING AND INSTALL REPLACEMENT DOUBLE DOOR: ST PETERS COTTAGE, ROOMS LANE (SCATCHERD).

The above decisions made under Town Clerk’s delegated authority, were noted.

7.         TO RECEIVE AND NOTE INFORMATION RE. ‘KIRKLEES LOCAL PLAN ADOPTION FEBRUARY 2019

Cllr Finnigan gave a verbal overview on the information, and this was received and noted.

8.         TO RECEIVE ITEMS OF CORRESPONDENCE (items for information only)

(a)          Copies of representations made (if any) since last meeting held on 19/2/19.

(b)        Report prepared by Cllr T Leadley (Morley North) to Town Clerk re. ‘Leeds City Council Local Development Framework Site Allocations Plan & Core Strategy Selective Review.’

The above items of correspondence were noted.

9.         DATE AND TIME OF NEXT MEETING

The next scheduled meeting will be held on Tuesday, 16th April 2019 at 7pm.

 

MINUTES OF PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING NO. 399

HELD ON TUESDAY, 19TH FEBRUARY 2019

1.         TO RECORD ATTENDANCE

Present:  Councillors R Finnigan (Chairman), J Sanders, W Whitehead, H Bell, C Taylor,

A Rhodes, H Evans and C Windle.

Two members of the public and W Maynard-Light (Deputy Town Clerk) also attended.

2.         TO RECEIVE AND NOTE APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE AND CONSIDER REASONS GIVEN FOR NON-ATTENDANCE
Apologies were received from Cllr J Foley and the reason was accepted and noted.

3.         Declarations of Disclosable Pecuniary and Other Interests

There were no interests declared.

4.         TO APPROVE MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON 27/11/18

The minutes of the meeting held on 27/11/18 were agreed as a true and correct record.

5.         CONSIDERATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS
Notation of Recommendations.
O = Objection
N = No Objection
NC = No Objection (with comments)
D = Deferred
RECEIVED 31/1/19

O         0470  REMOVAL OF CONDITION 7 (HIGHWAY IMPROVEMENTS) OF APPROVAL 15/07679/FU AS NO WORKS CAN BE CARRIED OUT ON THE LAND: EASTERGATE,

ELLAND ROAD (CHURWELL).

MTC objects to the removal of Condition 7 on the grounds of over-development of the site, increased usage of the unmade and narrow road, with no street lighting, with the increase traffic flow the development would generate, together with the increased traffic access due to the redevelopment of All Saints church into a Nursery and the established Doctor’s surgery, compromising highway safety.  Members requested this application be referred to Plans Panel.

The members of the public left the meeting at this point.

RECEIVED 1/2/19

O         0452  CHANGE OF USE OF REDUNDANT PUBLIC TOILET TO HOT FOOD TAKEAWAY AND NEW ROOF: PUBLIC CONVENIENCES, WESLEY STREET (CENTRAL).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of cumulative impact on the town centre with the number of established fast food take aways.  The development is too close to a primary school.  Impact on the highways with no available parking for either staff or customers, together with the impact on anti-social behaviour.   Members request that this application goes to Plans Panel.

RECEIVED 4/2/19

N         18/07624  DEMOLITION OF EXISTING SUNROOM AND CONSTRUCTION OF A TWO- STOREY REAR EXTENSION WITH JULIET BALCONY: 1111 DEWSBURY ROAD (WOODKIRK).

N         0563  SINGLE-STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 3 MEADOW WAY (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 5/2/19

O         0208  SINGLE DWELLING AND GARAGE WITH ASSOCIATED HIGHWAYS, DRAINAGE AND LANDSCAPING WORKS: LAND ADJACENT 18 STONECHAT RISE (TOPCLIFFE).

MTC objects to this planning application on the grounds of over-development of the site, together with the impact on vehicle parking.

RECEIVED 6/2/19

N         0487  single-storey extension to form enlarged reception: quarry court, High STREET (ELMFIELD).

The above Planning applications were considered by all members of the Planning Committee present.  It was agreed that any comments made be sent via ‘Public Access’.

6.         TO NOTE PLANNING APPLICATIONS WITH DECISIONS MADE UNDER DELEGATED AUTHORITY TO TOWN CLERK – STANDING ORDER 15(c) (APPLICATIONS RECEIVED THAT DID NOT APPEAR ON 16/10/18 AGENDA)

RECEIVED 23/11/18

N         6975  SUB-DIVISION OF EXISTING DWELLING TO 2 NO. DWELLINGS: 98 PEEL STREET (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 26/11/18

N         7063  REMOVE EXISTING MEZZANINE FLOOR AND ALL INTERNAL WALLS; INSTALL NEW MEZZANINE FLOOR; ALTERATIONS TO GROUND FLOOR LAYOUT; NEW RECEPTION DOOR TO MAIN WAREHOUSE BUILDING: UNIT 2, LITTLE FOUNTAIN STREET (TEALE).

RECEIVED 29/11/18

N         7240  SINGLE-STOREY SIDE EXTENSION; DORMER WINDOW TO REAR.  REPLACEMENT REAR WINDOW: THE PRESBYTERY, ST BRIGID’S CHURCH, ELLAND ROAD (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 3/12/18

N         7316  SINGLE-STOREY EXTENSION TO FRONT, BRICK PIER AND STONE CLADDING TO FRONT ELEVATIONS: 64 KING GEORGE AVENUE (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 5/12/18

N         7340  SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 9 DOTTEREL GLEN (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 7/12/18

NC       6180  CHANGE OF USE TO TATTOO STUDIO (SUI GENERIS) AND BAR (A4): 45 QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

MTC has no objection in principle to this planning application members requested a condition be placed on the application regarding opening times of the bar.  These should be restricted to 11.00 am until 10.00 pm.

RECEIVED 10/12/18

O         0251  87 DWELLINGS WITH ASSOCIATED ACCESS AND PUBLIC OPEN SPACE:  LAND AT SNITTLES FARM, GELDERD ROAD (WORTLEY).

MTC objects to this planning application on the grounds of noise pollution and health concerns with the proximity of the affordable housing to the adjacent M621 motorway.  There is a lack of infrastructure, with regard to local schools, which are already oversubscribed, together with pressure being placed on local doctors and dental surgeries.  The increase of congestion on the local roads and the inner ring road with the increase of vehicles.

RECEIVED 13/12/18

N         7435/TR  TI, T2 AND T3 HOLLY – CROWN LIFT OVER HANGING BRANCHES TO 8 FEET FROM BOUNDARY LINE OVER THE GARDEN OF 19 SHIRE CLOSE: 18 REIN ROAD (WOODKIRK).

N         7286  RETROSPECTIVE BOUNDARY FENCE AND GATE: 9 SEVEN HILL CLOSE (SCATCHERD).

N         7662/TR  T3 HORSE CHESTNUT TREE – CROWN LIFT TO GIVE 4 METRES GROUND CLEARANCE AND PULL BACK TO 2 METRES CLEARANCE FROM PROPERTY – GOOD TREE MANAGEMENT TO MAINTAIN AMENITY AND CAUSING NUISANCE TO NEIGHBOURS. T3 SYCAMORE TREE – CROWN LIFT TO GIVE 4 METRES GROUND CLEARANCE AND PULL BACK TO GIVE 2 METRES CLEARANCE FROM PROPERTY – GOOD TREE MANAGEMENT TO MAINTAIN AMENITY AND CAUSING NUISANCE TO NEIGHBOURS:  ATLANTIS FORWARDING LTD, LANESIDE MILLS (CHURWELL).

NC       7557  TWO-STOREY EXTENSION TO REAR; INCREASE IN ROOF HEIGHT TO REAR:

31 REIN ROAD (ELMFIELD).

MTC has no objection in principle to this planning application, however, members would like a condition placed on the application that the existing roof tiles be returned/reused on the extension.

N         7691/TR  EMERGENCY TREE WORK: T1 – SMBUCUS NIGRA – REMOVE: MORLEY LIBRARY, COMMERCIAL STREET (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 20/12/18

N         7650  SINGLE-STOREY SIDE/REAR EXTENSION: 147 GLEN ROAD (TOPCLIFFE)

RECEIVED 8/1/19

N         7829  CONVERSION OF LOFT SPACE TO HABITABLE LIVING: 19 GLADSTONE TERRACE (TEALE).

RECEIVED 11/1/19

N         7524  CHANGE OF USE OF VACANT LAND TO LANDSCAPE AREA AND DOMESTIC GARDEN SPACE: TINGLEY MILLS, BRIDGE STREET (ELMFIELD).

RECEIVED 14/1/19

N         0003  RETROSPECTIVE APPLICATION FOR A NEW GARAGE TO REAR: 49 OLD ROAD (CHURWELL).

N         0081  PART SINGLE-STOREY, PART TWO-STOREY SIDE/REAR EXTENSION; HIP TO GABLE EXTENSION; DORMER WINDOW TO REAR WITH JULIET BALCONY: 148 REIN ROAD (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 16/1/19

N         0107  SINGLE-STOREY SIDE/REAR EXTENSION: 21 DEWSBURY ROAD (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 18/1/19

N         0165  ALTERATIONS INVOLVING INSTALLATION OF SIX AIR-CONDITIONING UNITS, REPLACEMENT VENT COVER, INSTALLATION OF AN ADDITIONAL VENT, 2 REMOVABLE BOLLARDS AND ERECTION OF A 2.4M HIGH PALISADE FENCE ASSOCIATED WITH THE PROPOSED USE OF THE EXISTING BUILDING AS A DATA CENTRE (USE CLASS B8):

10 WIDE LANE (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 28/1/19

N         0143  REMOVAL OF WALL BETWEEN KITCHEN AND DINING ROOMS; MOVING OF ONE INTERNAL DOOR; REMOVAL OF MODERN FIREPLACE; REPLACEMENT OF MODERN INTERNAL DOOR AND WINDOW; REPLACE MODERN KITCHEN: 4 CHURCH STREET (SCATCHERD).

N         0056  PART TWO-STOREY PART SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 5 WESTWOOD CLOSE (CHURWELL).

The above decisions made under Town Clerk’s delegated authority, were noted.

7.         TO NOTE INFORMATION “COUNCIL DECISION MAKING ON PLANNING APPLICATIONS THAT ARE RECEIVED BETWEEN MEETINGS” ISSUED BY YLCA

This information was received and noted.

8.         TO RECEIVE ITEMS OF CORRESPONDENCE (items for information only)

(a)        Copies of representations made (if any) since last meeting held on 21/11/18

(b)       Letter dated 29/11/18 from Damian Hosker, Principal Planner for CTIL and Telefoncia UK Ltd re. proposed upgrade to base station installation at CTIL 112893, 109 Albert Road (Topcliffe).

(c)        Letter dated 30/11/18 from Damian Hosker, Principal Planner for CTIL and Telefoncia UK Ltd re. proposed upgrade to base station installation at CTIL 109397, Morley Fire Station, Corporation Street (Central).

(d)        Letter dated 10/12/18 from Damian Hosker, Principal Planner for CTIL and Telefoncia UK Ltd re. proposed upgrade to base station installation at CTIL 114659, TEF 068656 Broad Oaks Farm, off Elland Road (Churwell).

(e)        Email dated 21/12/18 from David Feeney, Head of Strategic Planning, LCC re. Leeds Core Strategy Selective Review.

(f)        Copy letter dated 10/12/18 from Cllr T Leadley, LCC to Helen Wilson, Programme Officer, LCC re. Speaking at Leeds Core Strategy review inquiry, February 2019.

(g)        Copy letter dated 8/12/18 from Cllr T Leadley, LCC to Planning Inspectorate in Bristol re. planning appeal APP/N4720/W/18/3213597 by Mr & Mrs M Cater, Land adjacent to Laneside House, Churwell.

(h)        Copy letter dated 10/12/18 from Cllr T Leadley, LCC to Ian Cyhanko, LCC re. Leeds Plan Panel South & West 22/11/18, appn 18/00251, Snittles Farm.

(i)         Email dated 21/1/19 from David Feeney, Head of Strategic Planning, LCC re. Leeds Site Allocations Plan – Consultation on Proposed Main Modifications.

(j)         Updated key planning enforcement cases for Morley North & Morley South Wards.

(k)        Letter dated 1/2/19 from Richard Hollinson, Policy Group Leader, Kirklees Council re. Kirklees Local Plan Inspector’s Report.

The above items of correspondence were noted.

8.         DATE AND TIME OF NEXT MEETING

The next scheduled meeting will be held on Tuesday, 19th March 2019 at 7pm.

 

MINUTES OF PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING NO. 398

HELD ON TUESDAY, 27^TH NOVEMBER 2018

 TO RECORD ATTENDANCE

Present:  Councillors R Finnigan (Chairman), H Bell, C Windle, C Taylor, H Evans.

2.         TO RECEIVE AND NOTE APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE AND CONSIDER REASONS GIVEN FOR NON-ATTENDANCE

            Cllrs J Foley, J Sanders and W Whitehead. Apologies were accepted and reasons for absence were noted. 

3. Declarations of Disclosable Pecuniary and Other Interests

There were no interests declared.

4. TO APPROVE MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON 16/10/18

The minutes of the meeting held on 16/10/18 were agreed as a true and correct record.

5. CONSIDERATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS

Notation of Recommendations.

O = Objection

N = No Objection

NC = No Objection (with comments)

D = Deferred

RECEIVED 8/11/18

N         6784  FIRST FLOOR SIDE EXTENSION: 31 FRESHAM AVENUE (ELMFIELD).

N         5714  PART RETROSPECTIVE APPLICATION FOR RAISED PLATFORM WITH STEPS AND BALUSTRADE ABOVE TO REAR:  7 BRITANNIA SQUARE (ELMFIELD).

RECEIVED 13/11/18

N         6653  FIRST FLOOR REAR EXTENSION: 37 HESKETH LANE (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 14/11/18

N         6917  SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 10 SANDMEAD WAY (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 15/11/18

N         6799  SINGLE STOREY SIDE/REAR EXTENSION: 6 DENHAM AVENUE (ELMFIELD).

The above Planning applications were considered by all members of the Planning Committee present.  It was agreed that any comments made be sent via ‘Public Access’.

6. TO NOTE PLANNING APPLICATIONS WITH DECISIONS MADE UNDER DELEGATED AUTHORITY TO TOWN CLERK – STANDING ORDER 15(c) (APPLICATIONS RECEIVED THAT DID NOT APPEAR ON 16/10/18 AGENDA) 

RECEIVED 10/10/18

NC       5962  FIRST FLOOR SIDE EXTENSION TO DENTAL PRACTICE INCLUDING INTERNAL ALTERATIONS TO FORM AN ADDITIONAL SURGERY: 13 WATSON STREET (ELMFIELD).

MTC members commented the application should have included a pitched roof.

RECEIVED 15/10/18

O         6272  DETACHED DWELLING TO SIDE: LAND AT 11 WILLIAM STREET (CHURWELL).

MTC objected to this planning application on the grounds of overdevelopment of the site and the impact on the street scene.

N         6143  SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION WITH NEW GLASS ROOF: 11 ASPEN COURT (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 16/10/18

N         6467  RETROSPECTIVE APPLICATION FOR OUTBUILDING AND BOUNDARY FENCE TO REAR: 1 ROOMS FOLD (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 18/10/18

N         6390  SINGLE STOREY FRONT, SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION; PORCH TO FRONT:

5 CROFT HOUSE VIEW (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 22/10/18

N         5883  REPLACEMENT WINDOWS AND DOORS TO SITE: VICTORIA COURT, VICTORIA MEWS (TEALE).

RECEIVED 30/10/18

N         6492 EXTENSIONS TO WAREHOUSE: HOWLEY PARK ROAD (ELMFIELD).

N         6664  SINGLE STOREY EXTENSION TO FRONT: 421 WESTERTON ROAD (WOODKIRK).

N         6662  SINGLE STOREY SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION: 47 CORPORATION STREET (TEALE).

RECEIVED  9/11/18

N         6950TR  T1 HAWTHORN – FELL; T2 OAK – CROWN REDUCTION OF 5M, FINISHED DIMENSIONS OF 10M BY 10M; T3 HAWTHORN – CROWN REDUCTION OF 2M, FINSIHED DEMENSIONS OF 4M BY 8M; T4 HAWTHORN – CROWN REDUCTION OF 2M, FINISHED DIMENSIONS OF 4M BY 8M: 2 DAFFIL GRANGE WAY (CHURWELL).

The above decisions made under Town Clerk’s delegated authority, were noted.

7. TO RECEIVE ITEMS OF CORRESPONDENCE (items for information only) 

(a)        Copies of representations made (if any) since last meeting held on 16/10/18.

(b)        Letter dated 10/10/18 from Jonathan Carr, Head of Development Manager, LCC re. appeal of planning appn 18/03207, 2B Church Lane (Woodkirk).

(c)        Letter dated 26/10/18 from Damian Hosker, Principal Planner, WHP Telecoms Ltd re. pre-consultation letter with associate drawings equipment upgrade, Rooms Lane (Scatcherd).

(d)        Email dated 1/11/18 from Mathias Franklin, Development Management Group Leader, Kirklees Council re. consultation on Kirklees draft Highway Design guide Supplementary Planning Document (SPD).

(e)        Letter dated 1/11/18 from Jonathan Carr, Head of Development Management, LCC re. planning appeal, planning application 18/03856, 5 Harwill Avenue (Churwell).

(f)        Letter dated 1/11/18 from Jonathan Carr, Head of Development Management, LCC re. planning appeal, planning application 18/04954, 11 Pawson Street (Teale).

(g)        Letter dated 13/11/18 from Jonathan Carr; Head of Development Management, LCC re. planning appeal, planning application 18/02407, land adjacent Laneside House (Churwell).

(h)        Letter dated 14/11/18 from Jonathan Carr, Head of Development Management, LCC re. 18/00251/FU/W Land at Snittles Farm, Gelderd Road (Wortley) to be heard at Plans Panel meeting on 22/11/18.

(i)     Email dated 20/11/18 from Helen Wilson, Programme Officer, LCC re: Leeds Core Strategy

Selective Review Examination with initial letter attached.

The above items of correspondence were noted. 

8. DATE AND TIME OF NEXT MEETING

The next scheduled meeting will be held on Tuesday, 18^th December 2018 at 7pm.

 

 

MINUTES OF PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING NO. 397

HELD ON TUESDAY, 16^TH OCTOBER 2018

1. TO RECORD ATTENDANCE

Present:  Councillors R Finnigan, C Windle, J Sanders, W Whitehead and C Taylor.

Cllr T Leadley (Morley North) (late arrival) also attended.

2.         TO RECEIVE AND NOTE APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE AND CONSIDER REASONS GIVEN FOR NON-ATTENDANCE

            Cllr J Foley and H Bell. Apologies were accepted and reasons for absence were noted.

3.  Declarations of Disclosable Pecuniary and Other Interests

There were no interests declared.

4. TO APPROVE MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON 17/7/18

The minutes of the meeting held on 17/7/18 were agreed as a true and correct record.

5. CONSIDERATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS

Notation of Recommendations.

O = Objection

N = No Objection

NC = No Objection (with comments)

D = Deferred

RECEIVED 14/9/18

NC       5586  RESERVED MATTERS APPLICATION FOR CONVERSION OF TINGLEY MILLS TO FORM 71 RESIDENTIAL UNITS WITH ASSOCIATED WORKS: TINGLEY MILLS, BRIDGE STREET (ELMFIELD).

MTC has no objections in principle to this application.  Members have, however, requested that the electricity sub-station be re-positioned away from the boundary with no. 117 Bridge Street.  The Viability Study requires to be robust.  Parking complies with the policy and that the number of two bedroomed flats is maximised.

RECEIVED 26/9/18

N         5971  SINGLE STOREY SIDE EXTENSION WITH PITCHED ROOF: HILLVIEW, 44 OLD ROAD (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 1/10/18

O         1725  RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT OF 210 DWELLINGS: LAND TO REAR OF VICTORIA RESERVOIR, BRUNTCLIFFE ROAD (TEALE).

MTC objects to this planning application on the grounds that the development is not sustainable and the position of affordable housing, which is mainly alongside the motorway, is not acceptable.  Members recommend that this application be referred to Plans Panel.

RECEIVED 5/10/19

N         5934  PART TWO STOREY, PART SINGLE STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 5 SISKIN COURT (TOPCLIFFE).

N         6118  T1 HAZEL COPPICE – FELL AND REMOVE, DUE TO POOR FORM, MULTI-STEMMED WITH HEAVY LEAN TOWARDS ADJACENT PROPERTY.  NO REPLANT AS REGENERATION FROM THE BASE WILL REMAIN AND TREE IS EXPECTED TO REGROW AS COPPICE FROM REMOVED STEM: 88 IBBETSON OVAL (CHURWELL).

N         6144  TWO STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 10 CHURCH LANE (WOODKIRK).

The above Planning applications were considered by all members of the Planning Committee present.  It was agreed that any comments made be sent via ‘Public Access’.

5. TO NOTE PLANNING APPLICATIONS WITH DECISIONS MADE UNDER DELEGATED AUTHORITY TO TOWN CLERK – STANDING ORDER 15(c) (APPLICATIONS RECEIVED THAT DID NOT APPEAR ON 19/6/18 AGENDA)

RECEIVED 12/7/17

N         4211  SINGLE STOREY EXTENSION TO FRONT: 14 CAMBRIDGE COURT (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 16/7/18

N         4191  LISTED BUILDING APPLICATION FOR NEW REAR ENTRANCE DOORWAY AND INTERNAL ALTERATIONS TO ENABLE INCLUSIVE ACCESS: LLOYDS TSB BANK PLC, 44 QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

N         4190  NEW REAR ENTRANCE DOORWAY: LLOYDS TSB BANK PLC, 44 QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

O         4301  PART SINGLE STOREY, PART TWO STOREY SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION:

292 WESTERTON ROAD (WOODKIRK).

MTC objects to this planning application on the grounds of the impact on the street scene and the impact on the residential amenity of number 290.

N         4305  PART THREE STOREY, PART TWO STOREY AND PART SINGLE STOREY FRONT/SIDE EXTENSION; SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION; EXTEND EXISTING DRIVEWAY TO FRONT: 13 SYKE GARDENS (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 18/7/18

N         4396  FIRST FLOOR SIDE EXTENSION: 56 SHIRE ROAD (ELMFIELD).

RECEIVED 23/7/18

N         4308  T1 – REMOVE AND REPLACE; T2 – REMOVE AND REPLACE: CROFT HOUSE, RODS MILLS LANE (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 27/7/18

O         4601  REMOVAL OF CONDITION 3 (ALTERATION/CONVERSION OF GARAGE) OF PLANNING PERMISSION 23/379/03/FU (ATTACHED GARAGE TO SIDE):  14 PEMBROKE CLOSE (SCATCHERD).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds the development would have insufficient off-street parking with available space remaining for one vehicle.

RECEIVED 1/8/18

O         3843  NEW DWELLING: 18 CHURCH LANE (WOODKIRK)

MTC objects to this application on the grounds of the over development of the site and the impact on the street scene, together with the impact on the safety of the highways.

RECEIVED 6/8/18

NC       4762  FIRST FLOOR SIDE EXTENSION: 92 NEW BANK STREET (SCATCHERD).

MTC has no objections in principle to this application but would request a condition be placed on the application that vehicles should be park off-road.

RECEIVED 8/8/18

N         4828  TWO STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 4 CHESTNUT VIEW (SCATCHERD).

O         0251  87 DWELLINGS WITH ASSOCIATED ACCESS AND PUBLIC OPEN SPACE: LAND AT SNITTLES FARM, GELDERD ROAD (WORTLEY).

MTC objects to this planning application on the grounds of the over development of the site with a single spine access road.  Affordable housing situated nearest to M621 and the lack of infrastructure, with local schools, doctors and dentists already over subscribed in the area.

RECEIVED 10/8/18

N         4875  ALTERATIONS TO ENLARGE EXISTING REAR DORMER WINDOW INCLUDING JULIET BALCONIES: 38 RYEDALE WAY (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 14/8/18

O         4863  CHANGE OF USE OF BUFFER ZONE LAND TO DOMESTIC LAND; REDUCTION OF REAR FENCE HEIGHT: LAND TO REAR OF 9 SEVEN HILL CLOSE (SCATCHERD).

MTC objections to this application on the ground that the buffer zone is a feature of the original management plan, therefore, should be kept as such.

N         4948  CONSERVATORY TO REAR OF PROPERTY: 15 PROSPECT PLACE (SCATCHERD).

N         4954  DORMER TO REAR: 11 PAWSON STREET (TEALE).

RECEIVED 16/8/18

N         4994  AMENDMENT TO PREVIOUS APPROVAL 12/04275/CLE FOR SUBSTITUTION OF HOUSE TYPE TO PLOT 6: SWEET BRIAR, 6 MANOR GRANGE (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 20/8/18

N         5045  SINGLE STOREY SIDE/REAR EXTENSION: 26 HARWILL AVENUE (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 21/8/18

N         5100  VARIATION OF CONDITION 2 (APPROVED PLANS) OF PREVIOUS APPROVAL 17/03314/FU TO ALLOW ELEVATION CHANGES: UNIT 2, HIGHCLIFFE INDUSTRIAL ESTATE, BRUNTCLIFFE LANE (TEALE).

RECEIVED 23/8/18

N         4736  RAISED DECKING TO REAR WITH NEW ACCESS DOOR; SINGLE STOREY FRONT EXTENSION; INSERTION OF ROOFLIGHTS TO FRONT AND REAR:

19 GLADSTONE TERRACE (TEALE).

N         5384/TR  T1 ASH – FELL: OAKDENE, ST ANDREWS AVENUE (TEALE).

RECEIVED 28/8/18

N         5231  DORMER WINDOW TO FRONT: 33 SCOTCHMAN LANE (TEALE).

RECEIVED 29/8/18

NC       4980  CHANGE OF USE OF GROUND FLOOR OFFICE (USE CLASS B1) TO ORTHODONTIST PRACTICE (USE CLASS D1): GROUND FLOOR SUITE, 1 CHURCH COURT (SCATCHERD).

MTC has no objections in principle to this application, members have requested a condition be placed on the application that all parking for staff and clients be within the designated parking area on the property and not on-street parking.

RECEIVED 3/9/18

N         5513/TR  G1 – ASH X 4 – FELL: 28 VICTORIA MEWS (TEALE).

N         5351  SINGLE STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 113 SPRINGFIELD ROAD (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 4/9/18

N         5462/TR  T1 & T2 – ALDER TREES – REDUCE IN HEIGHT BY 2M LEAVING APPROXIMATELY 5M IN HEIGHT: 1 KAY CLOSE (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 6/9/18

N         5305  TWO STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 2 TURNBERRY CLOSE (WOODKIRK).

N         5177    SINGLE STOREY EXTENSIONS TO BOTH SIDES AND REAR INCORPORATING NEW RAISED DECKING AREA AND ALTERATIONS TO EXISTING DECKING AREA TO SIDE/REAR: 94 IBBETSON OVAL (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 12/9/18

N         5461  INSTALLATION OF NEW DRAINAGE SYSTEM TO GRASS PLAYING FIELDS:  WOODKIRK ACADEMY, REIN ROAD (WOODKIRK).

N         5502  SINGLE STOREY SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION: 15 CROMPTON DRIVE (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 13/9/18

N         5615  SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 4 KESTREL GARTH (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 14/9/18

O         5769/TR  T1 OAK – FELL: 4 DAFFIL GRANGE MEWS (CHURWELL).

MTC objects to this application on the grounds that the tree should be preserved.

N         5597  SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 2 EARLSMERE DRIVE (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 21/9/18

N         5797  DETACHED GARAGE TO REAR: 4 HARWILL CROFT (CHURWELL).

N         5798  TWO STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 148 REIN ROAD (WOODKIRK).

N         5811  CONSERVATORY TO REAR: 19 KINGFISHER MEWS (TOPCLIFFE).

            The above decisions made under Town Clerk’s delegated authority, were noted.

7. TO RECEIVE ITEMS OF CORRESPONDENCE (items for information only)

(a)        Copies of representations made (if any) since last meeting held on 17/7/18.

(b)        Updated key planning enforcement cases for Morley North & Morley South Wards.

(c)        Letter dated 8/8/18 from J Carr, Head of Development Management, LCC, re. Appn 18/01506 – Vaynol Gate, Rooms Lane (Scatcherd), to be considered at Plans Panel meeting on 16/8/18

(d)        Email dated 14/8/18 from David Feeney, Head of Strategic Planning, LCC re. Leeds Site Allocations Plan – Seeking Comments on Sustainability Appraisal of Identified Sites (HG1 sites).

Cllr T Leadley gave members an overview of the current position of the Site Allocation process.

(e)        Emails dated 20/8/18 from consult@objective.co.uk re. Kirklees Council consultation period 20/8/18 to 1/10/18.

(f)         Letter dated 24/8/18 from Jonathan Carr, Head of Development Manager, LCC re. appeal of planning appn APP/N4720/D/183209485, 56 Shire Road (Elmfield).

(g)        Letter dated 5/9/18 from Mary Bradshaw, Planning Appeals, LCC re. appeal of planning appn APP/N4720/D/18/3208034, 12 Watson Street (Elmfield).

(h)        Updated key planning enforcement cases for Morley North & Morley South Wards received 24/9/18.

(i)          Letter dated 25/9/18 from Jonathan Carr, Planning Services, LCC re. appeal of planning appn/18/03505922, 100 Fountain Street (Teale).

(j)         Letter dated 25/9/18 from Jonathan Carr, Planning Services, LCC re. appeal of planning appn 18/03210350, 4 Millbeck Approach (Topcliffe).

The above items of correspondence were noted. 

8. TO DISCUSS AND AGREE PLANNING COMMITTEE BUDGET SUBMISSION FOR

2019-20 (for referral to the Finance, GP & Strategic Committee).

Following a discussion, it was proposed and agreed the for 2019-20 be set at £1,000.

 9.  DATE AND TIME OF NEXT MEETING

The next scheduled meeting will be held on Tuesday, 27^th November at 7pm.

 

MINUTES OF PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING NO. 396

HELD ON TUESDAY, 17TH JULY 2018

1.         ATTENDANCE AND APOLOGIES

Present:  Councillors R Finnigan, A Rhodes, H Bell, J Jackson, J Sanders, W Whitehead and C Windle.  K Oakley – Town Clerk and Cllr T Leadley (Morley North) (late arrival) also attended.

Apologies were received from Cllr C Taylor.

2.         Declarations of Disclosable Pecuniary and Other Interests

None were declared.

3.         TO APPROVE MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON 19/6/18

The minutes of the meeting held on 19/6/18 were agreed as a true and correct record.

4.         CONSIDERATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS
Notation of Recommendations.
O = Objection
N = No Objection
NC = No Objection (with comments)
D = Deferred
RECEIVED 27/6/18

O         3736  DEVELOPMENT OF A FUEL FILLING STATION WITH ASSOCIATED ROADSIDE SERVICES: FORMER THE WHITE BEAR, DEWSBURY ROAD (WOODKIRK).  Members objected due to the access from Bradford Road considered to be dangerous, significant impact on local residential amenity and cause of further congestion off Junction 28 of the M62.

Councillor T Leadley arrived during discussions on the above application.

RECEIVED 27/6/18

N         2723  CONVERSION OF INTEGRAL GARAGE: 8 HAROLD GARDENS (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 28/6/18

N         3828  ALTERATIONS INVOLVING SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION AND PART-CONVERSION OF GARAGE TO UTILITY ROOM: 20 GRANGE PARK DRIVE (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 2/7/18

N         4125  SINGLE-STOREY SIDE/REAR EXTENSION: 74 IBBETSON OVAL (CHURWELL).

O         3856  SINGLE-STOREY SIDE/REAR AND TWO STOREY FRONT EXTENSION:

5 HARWILL AVENUE (CHURWELL).  Members objected due to significant impact on the existing street scene, specifically the front elevation.

RECEIVED 3/7/18

NC       4048  SINGLE-STOREY EXTENSION TO SIDE AND REAR AND FIRST-FLOOR EXTENSION TO FRONT: 26 ASPEN COURT, TINGLEY (WOODKIRK).  Members had no objection in principle, however, condition should be applied that cars are parked off the street as there is very little pavement.

RECEIVED 10/7/18

N         4155  FIRST FLOOR SIDE EXTENSION OVER EXISTING INTEGRAL GARAGE; SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 9 BRIDGE COURT (ELMFIELD).

RECEIVED 11/7/18

O         4197  TWO STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 32 CAMBRIDGE COURT (CENTRAL).  Members objected as proposed extension will have a significant impact on residential amenity of neighbouring properties, and there will be no access to the back of the house.

O         4041  DETACHED DWELLING TO SIDE: LAND AT 11 WILLIAM STREET (CHURWELL).

Members objected due to significant loss of useful garage space and unsympathetic design to existing street scene.

The above Planning applications were considered by all members of the Planning Committee present.  It was agreed that any comments made be sent via ‘Public Access’.

5.         TO NOTE PLANNING APPLICATIONS WITH DECISIONS MADE UNDER DELEGATED AUTHORITY TO TOWN CLERK – STANDING ORDER 15(c) (APPLICATIONS RECEIVED THAT DID NOT APPEAR ON 19/6/18 AGENDA)

RECEIVED 14/6/18

N         3491  ONE ILLUMINATED SIGN: SANTANDER, UNIT 5, 91 QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 20/6/18

O         3594  DORMER WINDOW TO REAR: 4 MILLBECK APPROACH (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 5/7/18

N         3989/TR   WORKS TO PROTECTED TREES:   T1 – CHESTNUT TREE – REMOVAL OF TREE DUE TO LOW AMENITY VALUE AND WEAKENED STRUCTURE DUE TO PARTIAL DECAY AND LARGE LIMB HAS FALLEN OFF THE TREE RECENTLY.  T2 – SYCAMORE 25% THIN TO ALLOW MORE LIGHT ONTO THE DRIVE WAY, AND CROWN LIFT TO 2M OVER THE PAVEMENT AND CLEAR AROUND THE STREET LIGHT.  T3 SYCAMORE – REDUCE HEIGHT BY 5M AND WIDTH BY 1M LEAVING THE TREE AT A HEIGHT OF 10M AND A WIDTH OF 5M, TO REDUCE EXCESSIVE SHADING ON THE CORNER OF THE HOUSE. ALSO CROWN LIFT TO 2M OVER THE PAVEMENT.  T4 SYCAMORE – REDUCE HEIGHT BY 5M AND WIDTH BY 1M LEAVING THE TREE AT A HEIGHT OF 10M AND A WIDTH OF 5M, TO REDUCE EXCESSIVE SHADING ON THE CORNER OF THE HOUSE. ALSO CROWN LIFT TO 2M OVER THE PAVEMENT.  G1 MIXED HEDGE ROW, CONSISTING OF HOLLY, CHERRY, HAWTHORN – REDUCE HEDGE ROW BACK BY 2M TO ALLOW THE PASSING OF HIGH SIDED VEHICLES, AND CROWN LIFE 2M ABOVE THE PAYMENT.  T5 SYCAMORE – REDUCE BY 2M LEAVING THE TREE AT A HEIGHT OF 15M AND 8M WIDE. THIN TREE BY 20%. THE TREE HAS A SEVERE LEAN TOWARDS THE HOUSE, DOING THE WORK TO REDUCE WEIGHT ON THE ROOT STRUCTURE: 1 BEACON LODGE, TEXAS STREET (TOPCLIFFE).

The above decisions made under Town Clerk’s delegated authority, were noted.

6.         TO RECEIVE ITEMS OF CORRESPONDENCE (items for information only)

(a)        Copies of representations made (if any) since last meeting held on 19/6/18 (copies

attached).

(b)        Email dated 28/6/18, Elizabeth Humphrey, Planning Inspectorate re. Dunningley Lane Planning Inquiry 3169594.  Cllr Leadley had produced a written report dated 14/7/18, a copy of which had previously been given to the Town Clerk.  Copies were tabled to members and Cllr Leadley gave a brief overview of the outcome of the appeal.

The Chairman requested it be minuted that thanks be expressed to Councillor T Leadley and Councillor J Aveyard for all their had work in respect of the Dunningley appeal.

(c)        Email dated 2/7/18, Jonathan Carr, Head of Development Management LCC re: appeal appn 17/07246/FU, Mrs Samantha Cook, Veejays, 69 Queen Street, Morley (Central).

(d)        Letter 12/7/18 to J Dunbavin from Secretary of State, The Planning Inspectorate Report to the Secretary of State.  Relating to item 6(b) above, these items were tabled, for information.

(e)        Examination of the Leeds Site Allocations Plan dated 16/7/18 in respect of the East Leeds and Garforth area.  This item was tabled, for information.

7.         DATE AND TIME OF NEXT MEETING

It was agreed that no meeting be held in August 2018 and that any applications are dealt with under Town Clerk’s delegated authority.  The next scheduled meeting will be held on Tuesday, 18th September 2018 at 7pm.

 

MINUTES OF PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING NO. 395

HELD ON TUESDAY, 19^TH JUNE 2018

1.         ATTENDANCE AND APOLOGIES

Present: Cllr R Finnigan (Chairman), C Taylor, A Rhodes, J Jackson, H Bell, C Windle,

J Sanders (late arrival) and W Whitehead (late arrival).

Four members of the public, Cllr T Leadley (LCC) and W Maynard-Light (Deputy Town Clerk) also attended.

There were no apologies.

2.         Declarations of Disclosable Pecuniary and Other Interests

None.

3.         TO APPROVE MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON 29/5/18

The Minutes of the meeting held on 29/5/18 were agreed as a true and correct record.

4.         CONSIDERATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS
Notation of Recommendations.
O = Objection
N = No Objection
NC = No Objection (with comments)
D = Deferred

The Chairman brought forward planning application 1506

RECEIVED 5/6/18

O         1506  LAYING OUT OF ACCESS ROAD AND CONSTRUCTION OF THREE DETACHED HOUSES TO GARDEN; TWO-STOREY FRONT EXTENSION, ALTERATIONS AND PARTIAL DEMOLITION OF EXISTING HOUSE: VAYNOL GATE, ROOMS LANE (SCATCHERD).

Members objected to this planning application on the ground of the impact on residential amenities.  The over development of the site is intense with a negative impact on the street scene and the impact this development would have on neighbouring properties, in particular Woodcross Fold.  Members recommended that any future plans should be for a lesser number of properties with the number of bedrooms reflecting current demand.

Members stressed their previous request that this application be referred to Plans Panel.

Cllrs Sanders and Whitehead arrived during the above item.

Four members of the public left the meeting at this point.

RECEIVED 31/5/18

O         0251  87 DWELLINGS WITH ASSOCIATED ACCESS AND PUBLIC OPEN SPACE: LAND AT SNITTLES FARM, GELDERD ROAD, WORTLEY (not in Town Council area).

Members object to the application on the grounds of the impact the development will have on the ring road with increased traffic generated by the development.  The impact on the local infrastructure with one entrance/exit on the development, the impact on the oversubscribed local schools, doctors and dental surgeries, together with the noise pollution from the nearby motorway and railway line.

RECEIVED 4/6/18

NC       3096  CREATION OF A NEW VEHICULAR EGRESS ROUTE FROM BRITANNIA QUARRY TO HOWLEY PARK ROAD (ELMFIELD).

Members have no objections in principle to this application.  Members have requested that conditions are placed on the application that wheel washing and dust suppression plans are in place.  Road sweeping is carried out, twice daily, between Howley Park Road and Britannia Road and return.

NC       3098  PROPOSED QUARRY ACCESS ONTO REIN ROAD (ELMFIELD).

Members have no objections in principle to this application.  Members have requested that conditions are placed on the application that wheel washing and dust suppression plans are in place.  Road sweeping is carried out, twice daily along Rein Road and HGVs are restricted from using the Rein Road access.

RECEIVED 8/6/17

N         3392  FIRST-FLOOR SIDE EXTENSION: 31 FRENSHAM AVENUE (ELMFIELD).

O         3436  PART TWO-STOREY PART FIRST-FLOOR SIDE EXTENSION, PITCHED ROOF TO BAY WINDOW AT FRONT: 33 DARTMOUTH AVENUE (ELMFIELD).

Members object to this application on the grounds of the impact on the street scene, there are no other development of this design on Dartmouth Avenue or nearby surrounding area.

N         3320  OUTLINE APPLICATION FOR ONE DWELLING: LAND ADJOINING 4A SYKE ROAD, TINGLEY (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 11/6/18

O         3466  SINGLE-STOREY SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION: 29 BRUNTCLIFFE DRIVE (TEALE).

Members object to this application on the grounds of the over development of the site, the impact this extension will have on the neighbour’s residential amenities.  Parking restrictions this will have on the property by shortening the drive and significantly reducing the available parking space.

RECEIVED 12/6/18

N         3618/TR  T1 CHERRY – REMOVE: 9 WESTFIELD PLACE (CENTRAL).

O         3437  CONVERSION OF BASEMENT TO A  TWO BEDROOM APARTMENT, DEMOLITION OF EXISTING GARAGES AND REPLACEMENT WITH NEW GARAGE BLOCK WITH BIO MASS BOILER HOUSE AND SUMMER HOUSE, FORMATION OF NEW ACCESS, GATES AND RAILINGS AND PARTIAL ROOF SPACE CONVERSION WITH DORMER WINDOW AND ROOF LIGHTS: CRANBOURNE, ST ANDREW’S AVENUE (TEALE).

Members object to this application on the grounds of the impact the development will have on the Conservation Area, over development of the property and insufficient parking available for the number of dwellings being created.

  The above Planning applications were considered by all members of the Planning Committee present.  It was agreed that any comments made be sent via ‘Public Access’.

5. TO NOTE PLANNING APPLICATIONS WITH DECISIONS MADE UNDER DELEGATED AUTHORITY TO TOWN CLERK – STANDING ORDER 15(c) (APPLICATIONS RECEIVED THAT DID NOT APPEAR ON 17/4/18 AGENDA)

RECEIVED 16/5/18

N         2829  ALTERATIONS INCLUDING THREE NEW DORMER WINDOWS TO REAR:

6 CHESTNUT VIEW (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 22/5/18

N         2898  SINGLE-STOREY SIDE/REAR EXTENSION: 20 PEREGRINE AVENUE (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 24/5/18

N         3004  SINGLE-STOREY SIDE/REAR EXTENSION: 102 NEW BANK STREET (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 25/5/18

N         3131  FIRST-FLOOR SIDE EXTENSION OVER EXISTING GARAGE, SINGLE-STOREY FRONT AND REAR EXTENSION: MANOR HOUSE FARM: BAGHILL GREEN, TINGLEY (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 30/5/18

N         2913  SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 19 SANDMEAD CROFT (SCATCHERD)

RECEIVED 1/6/18

N         3391  T1 – CARRY OUT 10% CROWN THIN AND 1.5M DRAWBACK OF THE CANOPY ON THE BUILDING SIDE OF THE T2 SYCAMORE. REMOVE ALL DEADWOOD AND CARRY OUT A 5% THIN ON T3 ASH: 24 AND 25 OAK ROAD (TEALE).

The above decisions made under Town Clerk’s delegated authority, were noted.

Cllr Rhodes left the meeting at this point.

6. TO RECEIVE ITEMS OF CORRESPONDENCE (items for information only)

 (a)        Copies of representations made (if any) since last meeting held on 29/5/18.

(b)        Letter dated 31/5/18 from Cllr Leadley (LCC) re: Leeds Site Allocations Plan: Appearances at Public Hearings July 2018.

Cllr Leadley gave a verbal update on this item.

(c)        Letters dated 11/6/18 from Cllr T Leadley (Morley North Ward) to H Wilson, Programme Officer re. ‘Leeds Site Allocations Plan Inquiry: Inspectors’ Matters and Issues’, together with ‘Stage 2 Draft Hearings Programme’.

Cllr Leadley gave a verbal update on this item.

The above items of correspondence were noted.

7. DATE AND TIME OF NEXT MEETING

The next scheduled meeting will be held on Tuesday, 17^th July 2018 at 7pm.

 

 

MINUTES OF PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING NO. 394

HELD ON TUESDAY, 29TH MAY 2018

1.         ATTENDANCE AND APOLOGIES

Present: Cllr R Finnigan (Chairman), C Taylor, J Sanders, W Whitehead, H Evans, H Bell and C Windle.

There were no apologies.

2.         Declarations of Disclosable Pecuniary and Other Interests

None.

3.         TO APPROVE MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON 17/4/18

The Minutes of the meeting held on 17/4/18 were agreed as a true and correct record.

4.         CONSIDERATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS

Notation of Recommendations.
O = Objection
N = No Objection
NC = No Objection (with comments)
D = Deferred
RECEIVED 18/4/18

N         2185  NEW INDUSTRIAL UNIT: HOWLEY PARK TRADING ESTATE, HOWLEY PARK ROAD EAST (ELMFIELD).

RECEIVED 9/5/18

NC       2704  SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION AND GARAGE TO SIDE/REAR: 12 KITSON STREET (WOODKIRK).

Members did not object in principle, however, it was felt that a condition should be applied to ensure that the new garage must be used for parking cars to avoid on-street parking.

RECEIVED 14/5/18

N         2774  SINGLE STOREY EXTENSION WITH RAISED PATIO AREA TO REAR, DORMER WINDOW TO REAR AND NEW STEPS WITH BALUSTRADE ABOVE TO FRONT: MANOR FARM DRIVE (CHURWELL).

O         2407  OUTLINE APPLICATION FOR SINGLE DWELLING: LAND ADJACENT LANESIDE HOUSE (CHURWELL).  MTC objected due to significant over-development of the site; it was also felt that this would be a house not a single-storey dwelling, however, a bungalow may be acceptable.

RECEIVED 15/5/18

O         2782  CHANGE OF USE FROM OFFICE, STORAGE AND WORKSHOP TO 10 FLATS WITH ASSOCIATED LANDSCAPING AND 2783/LI (tabled): CHURWELL HOUSE, 65 ELLAND ROAD (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 23/5/18

O         2783  LISTED BUILDING APPLICATION FOR THE CHANGE OF USE FROM OFFICE, STORAGE AND WORKSHOP TO 10 FLATS WITH ASSOCIATED LANDSCAPING; INTERNAL AND EXTERNAL ALTERATIONS INCLUDING NEW WINDOWS AND DOORS, INSTALLATION OF NEW FLOORS: CHURWELL HOUSE, 65 ELLAND ROAD (CHURWELL).

This application was tabled and considered along with appn 2782 above.

MTC objected as it was felt that 10 1-bed flats is excessive over-development and there could be significant parking issues as well as problems with entrance to and exit from the site.

RECEIVED 16/5/18

2829  ALTERATIONS INCLUDING THREE NEW DORMER WINDOWS TO REAR: 6 CHESTNUT VIEW (SCATCHERD).

This application was not presented for consideration and will be dealt with under delegated authority.

RECEIVED 18/5/18

O         2607  ONE NEW DWELLING: LAND ADJACENT 18 STONECHAT RISE (TOPCLIFFE).

Members objected due to significant over-development of the site and this would have a significant impact on the streetscene.

RECEIVED 21/5/19

N         2816  SINGLE STOREY NURSERY BUILDING TO REAR OF EXISTING NURSERY SITE AND CREATION OF 8 DROP OFF PARKING SPACES: TWINKLES DAY NURSERY, WHITE ROSE OFFICE PARK, MILLSHAW PARK LANE (CHURWELL).

N         2818  REMOVAL OF CONDITION 6 OF APPROVAL 13/0542/FU (NO LESS THAN 80% OF THE NURSERY’S PLACES SHALL BE PROVIDED TO CHILDREN WHO HAVE AT LEAST ONE PARENT OR GUARDIAN EMPLOYED AT THE WHITE ROSE OFFICE PARK) TO ALLOW UNFETTERED USE OF THE EXISTING NURSERY BUILDING BY CHILDREN WITH PARENTS AND/OR GUARDIANS EMPLOYED OFF-SITE AND AT THE WHITE ROSE OFFICE PARK AND ALLOCATION OF UP TO 50% OF PLACES TO THE LOCAL COMMUNITY: TWINKLES DAY NURSERY, WHITE ROSE OFFICE PARK, MILLSHAW PARK LANE (CHURWELL).

O         2976  DORMER WINDOWS TO FRONT AND REAR: 12 WATSON STREET (ELMFIELD).

MTC objected due to potential significant impact on the streetscene as there are currently no other dormers and approval could set a precedent.  There would be no objection to a dormer at the back.

NC       2906  CANOPY TO FOOTBALL PITCH: SEVEN HILLS PRIMARY SCHOOL, APPLEBY WAY (CENTRAL).

Members had no objection to the proposal, however, comments were made that it was hoped it could be used as a community facility.

N         2979  DORMER WINDOW TO FRONT: 3 VICTORIA DRIVE (CHURWELL).

NC       2510  TWO-STOREY AND SINGLE-STOREY SIDE/REAR EXTENSION: 18 SUNNYSIDE AVENUE, TINGLEY (WOODKIRK).

Members did not object to this appn, however, it was felt that a condition should be applied that this remains a single dwelling.

RECEIVED 22/5/18

N         2935  TWO STOREY EXTENSION WITH RAISED PATIO AREA AND BALUSTRADE ABOVE TO REAR; FIRST FLOOR FRONT/SIDE EXTENSION INCLUDING NEW WINDOW TO SIDE; CONVERSION OF INTEGRAL GARAGE TO FORM A HABITABLE ROOM AND STORE: 25 WOODCROSS GARTH (CHURWELL).

The above Planning applications were considered by all members of the Planning Committee present.  It was agreed that any comments made be sent via ‘Public Access’.

5.         TO NOTE PLANNING APPLICATIONS WITH DECISIONS MADE UNDER DELEGATED AUTHORITY TO TOWN CLERK – STANDING ORDER 15(c) (APPLICATIONS RECEIVED THAT DID NOT APPEAR ON 17/4/18 AGENDA)

RECEIVED 12/4/18

N         2178  FIRST-FLOOR SIDE EXTENSION: 56 SHIRE ROAD (ELMFIELD).

RECEIVED 13/4/18

N         2195  CONSERVATORY TO FRONT: 39 NEW BANK (SCATCHERD).

N         1970  SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 6 ADELAIDE AVENUE (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 17/4/18

N         2172  CHANGE OF USE AND ALTERATIONS TO HOUSE INCLUDING DORMER WINDOW TO REAR TO FORM TWO HOUSES: 40 TROY ROAD (CENTRAL).

N         1761  CHANGE OF USE OF FIRST-FLOOR FLAT TO FORM TWO FLATS AND EXTERNAL ALTERATIONS: ACKROYD STREET WMC, SCHOOL STREET (CENTRAL).

N         2276  ALTERATIONS INCLUDING NEW ENTRANCE TO FRONT: 7 IBBETSON COURT (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 19/4/18

N         2293  SINGLE-STOREY EXTENSION AND PEDESTRIAN ACCESS WITH GATE TO FRONT: THE BUNGALOW, ASHFIELD ROAD (TEALE).

RECEIVED 24/4/18

N         2021  SINGLE-STOREY INFILL EXTENSION TO FRONT: 25A HARWILL AVENUE (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 25/4/18

N         2450  DEMOLITION OF EXISTING DETACHED CONCRETE SECTIONAL GARAGE/WORKSHOP, ERECTION OF NEW PROFILE STEEL WORKSHOP/GARAGE TO EXISTING FOOTPRINT: 1242 DEWSBURY ROAD (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 26/4/18

N         2484  NEW SHOPFRONT: 15 WINDSOR COURT (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 27/4/18

N         2497  PART SINGLE-STOREY AND PART TWO-STOREY SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION: 1 MARINA CRESCENT (TEALE).

RECEIVED 1/5/18

N         2500  TWO-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 17 WOODCROSS FOLD (CHURWELL).

N         2212  DORMER WINDOW TO FRONT AND REAR: 100 FOUNTAIN STREET (TEALE).

RECEIVED 2/5/18

N         2616  CHANGE OF USE OF VACANT LAUNDERETTE TO BEAUTY SALON: 60A MIDDLETON ROAD (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 3/5/18

N         2651  SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 17 PARTRIDGE CLOSE (TOPCLIFFE).

N         2613  SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 9 SANDMEAD WAY (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 8/5/18

O         2522  TWO-STOREY AND SINGLE-STOREY SIDE/REAR EXTENSION:  63 DENSHAW DRIVE (TOPCLIFFE).

MTC objects on the grounds of the impact on the streetscene, as there are no other similar extensions currently on Denshaw Drive.

The above decisions made under Town Clerk’s delegated authority, were noted.

6.         TO DISCUSS LETTER AND ATTACHED DOCUMENTS DATED 9TH MAY 2018 FROM

H WILSON, PROGRAMME OFFICER, RE. ‘REVISED LEEDS SITE ALLOCATIONS PLAN EXAMINATION’

The information contained in the above documents, was noted.

7.         TO RECEIVE ITEMS OF CORRESPONDENCE (items for information only)

(a)        Copies of representations made (if any) since last meeting held on 17/4/18.

(b)        Updated key planning enforcement cases for Morley North & Morley South Wards.

The above items of correspondence were noted.

8.         DATE AND TIME OF NEXT MEETING

The next scheduled meeting will be held on Tuesday, 19th June 2018 at 7pm.

 

 

MINUTES OF PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING NO. 393

HELD ON TUESDAY, 17TH APRIL 2018

1.         ATTENDANCE AND APOLOGIES

Present:  Cllrs R Finnigan (Chairman), J Sanders, W Whitehead, H Bell, C Hill, J Jackson and C Windle (late arrival).  W Maynard-Light (Deputy Town Clerk) and two members of the public also attended.

Apologies were received from Cllr C Taylor.

2.         DECLARATIONS OF DISCLOSABLE PECUNIARY AND OTHER INTERESTS

Cllr Finnigan declared an ‘other’ interest as a Leeds City Councillor and declared that he had previously had a meeting with the two members of the public who are in attendance with regards planning application 1506.

Cllr C Windle arrived during the above item.

3.         TO APPROVE MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON 20/3/18

The minutes of the meeting held on 20/3/18 were agreed as a true and correct record.

4.         CONSIDERATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS

Notation of Recommendations.
O = Objection
N = No Objection
NC = No Objection (with comments)
D = Deferred
The Chairman brought forward planning application 1506

RECEIVED 4/4/18

O         1506  VAYNOL DEVELOPMENTS LTD: LAYING OUT OF ACCESS ROAD AND CONSTRUCTION OF THREE DETACHED HOUSES TO GARDEN; TWO-STOREY FRONT EXTENSION, ALTERATIONS AND PARTIAL DEMOLITION OF EXISTING HOUSE: VAYNOL GATE, ROOMS LANE (SCATCHERD).

Members objected to this planning application on the ground of the impact on residential amenities.  The over development of the site is intense with a negative impact on the street scene and the impact this development would have on neighbouring properties, in particular Woodcross Fold.  Members recommended that any future plans should be for a lesser number of properties with the number of bedrooms reflecting current demand.   Members requested this application should be referred to Plans Panel.

The members of the public left the meeting at this point.

RECEIVED 27/3/18

NC       1716  MR D JAMES: OUTLINE APPLICATION TO ERECT ONE DWELLING:  44 INGLE AVENUE (SCATCHERD).

Members have no objection in principle to this application, a request was made for a condition to be placed on the application that vehicles are parked off-road.

N         1801  MRS C SPURR: SINGLE-STOREY EXTENSION TO BOTH SIDES AND REAR:  1 REIN GARDENS (WOODKIRK).

NC       1725  BARRATT HOMES:  RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT OF 210 DWELLINGS: LAND TO REAR OF VICTORIA RESERVOIR, BRUNTCLIFFE ROAD (TEALE).  Members have no objection in principle to this application but requested that planners considered a larger proportion of affordable homes and a specific scheme for ‘over 55’s’ accommodation.

RECEIVED 4/4/18

O         1617  MR K CAWOOD: TWO-STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 2B CHURCH LANE (WOODKIRK).  Members objected to this application on the ground that the extension would create insufficient parking space for two vehicles.

N         2102  MR V MAZZOCCHIO: ALTERATIONS TO SHOP-FRONT INCLUDING MOVING ATM AND NEW POST BOX: SANTANDER UK PLC, 91 QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

The above Planning applications were considered by all members of the Planning Committee present.  It was agreed that any comments made be sent via ‘Public Access’.

5.         TO NOTE PLANNING APPLICATIONS WITH DECISIONS MADE UNDER DELEGATED AUTHORITY TO TOWN CLERK – STANDING ORDER 15(c) (APPLICATIONS RECEIVED THAT DID NOT APPEAR ON 20/3/18 AGENDA)

RECEIVED 21/3/18

NC       1206  MR I GARSIDE: CHANGE OF USE OF EXISTING BUSINESS PREMISES TO THREE APARTMENTS: 74A ELLAND ROAD (CHURWELL).   No objection in principle, subject to condition that all parking is off-street, using car park at rear.

The above decision made under Town Clerk’s delegated authority, was noted.

6.         TO CONSIDER CONSULTATION ON ‘NATIONAL PLANNING POLICY FRAMEWORK – DELIVERING THE RIGHT HOMES IN THE RIGHT PLACES’ DATED 5/3/18

Members agreed to make a response by Thursday, 10th May 2018

7.         TO RECEIVE ITEMS OF CORRESPONDENCE (items for information only)

(a)        Copies of representations made (if any) since last meeting held on 20/3/18.

(b)        Letter dated 9/4/18 with attached timetable from The Planning Inspectorate re. ‘Appeal by The Sir Robert Ogden Partnership: Land at Tingley Station, West of A654 Thorpe Lane, North of M62 and east of A653, Leeds WF3 1SJ’.

8.         DATE AND TIME OF NEXT MEETING

The date and time of the next meeting will be agreed at the Annual Full Council meeting on 9/5/18.

 

MINUTES OF PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING NO. 391

HELD ON TUESDAY, 20^TH FEBRUARY 2018

1. ATTENDANCE AND APOLOGIES

Cllrs R Finnigan (Chairman), C Taylor, J Sanders, W Whitehead, A Rhodes, J Jackson, C Windle and H Bell (late arrival).

Cllr T Leadley (Morley North Ward) (late arrival) and W Maynard-Light (Deputy Town Clerk), also attended.

Apologies were received from Cllr H Evans.

2. Declarations of Disclosable Pecuniary and Other Interests

Cllr R Finnigan declared an ‘other’ interest in any matters relating to Leeds City Council as he is a Morley North Ward member.

3. TO APPROVE MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON 9/1/18

The minutes of the meeting held on 9/1/18 were agreed as a true and correct record.

4. CONSIDERATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS

Notation of Recommendations.

O = Objection

N = No Objection

NC = No Objection (with comments)

D = Deferred

RECEIVED 3/1/18

N         8190  CROSSHALL DEVELOPMENTS (LEEDS) LTD: DEMOLITION OF CENTRE AND CONSTRUCTION OF EIGHT DWELLINGS, ASSOCIATED LANDSCAPING AND PARKING: PEEL STREET COMMUNITY CENTRE, MELBOURNE STREET (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 17/1/18

O    7818  MR R HOUGH: OUTLINE APPLICATION TO DEMOLISH PUBLIC HOUSE AND ERECT RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT: SHOULDER OF MUTTON, HOWDEN CLOUGH ROAD (TEALE).

MTC objected to this planning application due to the impact this development would have on the street scene, overdevelopment of the site and insufficient parking spaces for the proposed number of flats.

RECEIVED 18/1/18

O         8262  WEST ARDSLEY DEVELOPMENT CONSORTIUM: OUTLINE PLANNING APPLICATION FOR THE ERECTION OF UP TO 299 DWELLINGS WITH ALL MATTERS RESERVED (SAVE FOR THE TWO PRINCIPLE ACCESSES OFF WESTERTON ROAD AND HAIGH MOOR ROAD, BUT NOT TO INCLUDE ACCESS WITHIN THE SITE), THREE POINTS OF ACCESS AT UPPER GREEN AVENUE, SANDRINGHAM DRIVE AND HILL TOP LANE, ASSOCIATED WORKS, PUBLIC OPEN SPACE PROVISION AND ACCESSIBILITY AND QUALITATIVE IMPROVEMENTS TO LOCAL GREENSPACE: LAND OFF HAIGH MOOR ROAD AND WESTERTON ROAD, WEST ARDSLEY.

NOTE: PART OF THIS SITE FALLS WITHIN THE WOODKIRK WARD, MORLEY TOWN COUNCIL AREA.

MTC objected to this planning application due to premature release of the land.  The outline application is considered not sustainable with adverse impact on the infrastructure, in particular the over-subscribed local schools, doctors and dentists, together with the impact on the highways and junction 27 of the M62.

Cllr Leadley arrived during the above item.

RECEIVED 24/1/18

O         0251  BERKELEY DEVEER: 87 DWELLINGS WITH ASSOCIATED ACCESS AND PUBLIC OPEN SPACE: LAND AT SNITTLES FARM, GELDERD ROAD (CHURWELL).

MTC objected to this planning application due to premature release of the land, the impact on the infrastructure, increase in traffic on the adjacent Ring Road, in particular, only one road as access in/out of the development together with the impact this will have on the already oversubscribed local schools, doctors and dentists.

RECEIVED 31/1/18

O         0532  MR A WALKER:  ALTERATIONS INVOLVING RE-MODELLING OF EXISTING GROUND FLOOR WORKSHOP, DEMOLITION OF TWO-STOREY LINK BUILDING AND CHANGE OF USE OF FIRST AND SECOND-FLOOR TO FIVE FLATS:  THE OLD MILL, STATION ROAD (SCATCHERD).

MTC objected to this planning application due to over-development of the site and, in particular, no off-street parking available.

RECEIVED 2/2/18

N         0239  MR P DALE: ALTERATIONS TO REAR SHOP FRONT: UNITS 65 AND 66 WHITE ROSE SHOPPING CENTRE, DEWSBURY ROAD (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 6/2/18

N         0629  MR D FOX: TWO-STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 11 NEPSHAW LANE (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 12/2/18

N         0707  ALDI STORES LTD: DEMOLITION OF EXISTING BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION OF A CLASS A1 FOOD STORE, TOGETHER WITH CAR PARKING, LANDSCAPING AND ASSOCIATED WORKS: CHARTISTS WAY (ELMFIELD).

The above Planning applications were considered by all members of the Planning Committee present.  It was agreed that any comments made be sent via ‘Public Access’.

5. TO NOTE PLANNING APPLICATIONS WITH DECISIONS MADE UNDER DELEGATED AUTHORITY TO TOWN CLERK – STANDING ORDER 15(c) (APPLICATIONS RECEIVED THAT DID NOT APPEAR ON 19/12/17 AGENDA)

RECEIVED 3/1/18

N         8317  MR A ROSS: CONVERSION OF EXISTING GARAGE TO HABITABLE ROOM AND STORE: 7 IBBETSON COURT (CHURWELL).

N         8271  MR B FRENCH, CORPORATE REAL ESTATE: ERECTION OF 2 AIR-CONDITIONING CONDENSER UNITS TO ROOF: HSBC, ARLINGTON BUSINESS CENTRE, MILLSHAW PARK LANE (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 4/1/18

N         8185  MR P MCALEER, RIVERMOUTH DEVELOPMENTS LTD: CHANGE OF USE FROM SOCIAL CLUB (D2) TO OFFICES (B1): ACKROYD STREET WMC, SCHOOL STREET (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 8/1/18

N         8417  MR R WOOD, SAINSBURYS SUPERMARKETS LTD: INSTALLATION OF MEZZANINE FLOOR AND FOUR AIR-CONDENSER UNITS TO ROOF: UNIT H1, WHITE ROSE SHOPPING CENTRE, DEWSBURY ROAD (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 9/1/18

N         8398  MS S DANIEL: CHANGE OF USE OF GROUND-FLOOR OF UNIT 10 FROM BUSINESS (USE CLASS B1) TO PHYSIOTHERAPY AND REHABILITATION TREATMENT (USE CLASS D1): 10 CLIFFE PARK WAY (TEALE).

N         8405  MR S WARREN: DETACHED GARAGE TO SIDE: 20 PARKLAND AVENUE (TEALE).

RECEIVED 10/1/18

O         8466  MR J GIBBONS: CHANGE OF USE FROM ONE DWELLING TO TWO: 14-16 FLORENCE TERRACE (CENTRAL).  MTC objected to this appn as it was felt that the  impact the proposed dormer would have on the street scene would be significant.  Concerns were also raised about the impact on the ‘on-street parking’ situation.

RECEIVED 11/1/18

N         18/00019  MR J SINGH: CONVERSION OF GARAGE TO HABITABLE ROOM; PART SINGLE-STOREY, PART TWO-STOREY SIDE EXTENSION TO BOTH LYNWOOD & HART LEA: LYNWOOD AND HART LEA, VICTORIA ROAD (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 15/1/18

N         7291  MRS MACFARLANE: GABLE EXTENSION TO SIDE, PITCHED ROOF TO EXISTING SIDE EXTENSION: 17 BRUNTCLIFFE LANE (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 16/1/18

N         18/00171  MR R YOUNG: SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 71 WATSON STREET (ELMFIELD).

RECEIVED 18/1/18

N         18/00134  MR T CARVILL: SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 5 SEVEN HILL WAY (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 24/1/18

N         0274  MR S T ALI: CHANGE OF USE FROM FINANCIAL AND PROFESSIONAL (A2) TO FORM CAFÉ (A3) WITH EXTRACTION FLUE TO REAR: 65 QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

N         0293  MR W KNOWLES: SINGLE-STOREY SIDE EXTENSION AND EXTENSION OF EXISTING DORMER TO FRONT: 2 WEST LEA CRESCENT (WOODKIRK).

N         17/07707  MR G MCKENNA: DETACHED SINGLE-STOREY GARAGE: LAND OPPOSITE 58 TROY ROAD (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 29/1/18

N         0536  MR & MRS BOYES: FIRST-FLOOR FRONT EXTENSION: 1 FLEXBURY AVENUE (TOPCLIFFE).

N         0568  MRS T CROSSLEY: PART SINGLE-STOREY, PART TWO-STOREY SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION: 6 CORPORATION STREET (TEALE).

RECEIVED 1/2/18

N         18/00462/TR  PARKS & COUNTRYSIDE, LCC: REMOVAL OF T1 MATURE CHERRY TREE IN CLOSE PROXIMITY TO PROPOSED FOOTPATH WORKS: DARTMOUTH PARK, ST ANDREW’S AVENUE (TEALE).

All of the above decisions made under Town Clerk’s delegated authority, were noted.

6. TO DISCUSS ‘LEEDS SITE ALLOCATIONS PLAN – CONSULTATION ON REVISED SUBMISSION DRAFT PLAN’ AND TO APPROVE MORLEY TOWN COUNCIL REPRESENTATION – ‘SUMMARY OF THE SITE ALLOCATIONS PLAN REVISED SUBMISSION DRAFT AMENDMENTS WITHIN EACH HOUSING MARKET CHARACTERISTIC AREA (HMCA)’ COPY OF DOCUMENT ATTACHED; ALSO ATTACHED IS ‘DRAFT’ REPRESENTATION PREPARED BY CLLR T LEADLEY

            Cllr Leadley gave a verbal report on this item.  Following a discussion, it was proposed and agreed to send a letter similar to Cllr Leadley’s.

7. TO DISCUSS LEEDS CORE STRATEGY SELECTIVE REVIEW – CONSULTATION

Cllr Leadley gave a verbal report on this item.           

8. TO RECEIVE AND NOTE CONTENT OF CLOSING STATEMENT MADE BY CLLR T LEADLEY FOR RULE 6(6) PARTY MORLEY TOWN COUNCIL TO DUNNINGLEY PUBLIC INQUIRY

            Cllr Leadley gave members a verbal update on this item; there is the possibility of no decision until Summer. 

9. TO CONSIDER REQUEST REGARDING FINANCIAL CONTRIBUTION OF £500 TO CHIDSWELL ACTION GROUP FOR LEGAL REPRESENTATION

It was proposed and agreed that a financial contribution of £500 be provided to Chidswell Action Group. 

10. TO RECEIVE ITEMS OF CORRESPONDENCE (items for information only)

(a)        Copies of representations made (if any) since last meeting held on 9/1/18

(b)        Email 19/1/18 Kathryn Moran, Principal Planning Officer, LCC, re. 17/08262 – Land off Westerton Road and Haigh Moor Road.

(c)        Email 5/2/18 Mark Rochford, Senior Planning Compliance Officer, LCC, re. Properties on Top of High Street and South Queen Street.

(d)        Email 7/2/18 John Finnigan, Tong & Fulneck Valley Association re. Agenda for Trustee Meeting on 15/2/18.

(e)        Representation from Cllr T Leadley to Chief Planning Officer, LCC, re. Appn 18/00251 – Berkeley Deveer, 87 houses, Snittles Farm, off New Village Way, Churwell (Farnley & Wortley).

All of the above items of correspondence were noted.

11. DATE AND TIME OF NEXT MEETING

The next meeting is scheduled for Tuesday, 20^th March 2018 at 7pm.

 

 

MINUTES OF PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING NO. 390

MEETING HELD ON TUESDAY, 9TH JANUARY 2018

1.         ATTENDANCE AND APOLOGIES

Cllrs R Finnigan (Chairman), C Taylor, H Bell, J Sanders, W Whitehead and H Evans.

Cllr T Leadley (Morley North Ward) and K Oakley – Town Clerk, also attended.

Apologies were received from Cllrs J Jackson and C Windle.

2.         Declarations of Disclosable Pecuniary and Other Interests

Cllr R Finnigan declared an ‘other’ interest in any matters relating to Leeds City Council as he is a Morley North Ward member.

3.         TO APPROVE MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON 19/12/17

It was pointed out that the date in minute 3 should read 21/11/17 and not 17/10/17, as stated.   Subject to the above amendment, the minutes of the meeting held on 19/12/17 were agreed as a true and correct record.

4.         CONSIDERATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS

Notation of Recommendations.
O = Objection
N = No Objection
NC = No Objection (with comments)
D = Deferred

RECEIVED 14/12/17

N         6442  MR M HARTY, BIFFA WASTE SERVICES: RETENTION OF EXISTING GENERATING COMPOUND AND PROVISION OF GAS STORAGE TANKS, GAS CONDITIONING UNIT, ONE COMPRESSED NATURAL GAS GENERATING ENGINE:  TIP, HOWDEN CLOUGH ROAD (TEALE).

RECEIVED 21/12/17

N         8186  MISS N WOOD: TWO-STOREY AND SINGLE-STOREY SIDE/REAR EXTENSION INCLUDING ALTERATIONS TO EXISTING REAR EXTENSION: 92 REIN ROAD (WOODKIRK)

The above Planning applications were considered by all members of the Planning Committee present.  It was agreed that any comments made be sent via ‘Public Access’.

5.         TO NOTE PLANNING APPLICATIONS WITH DECISIONS MADE UNDER DELEGATED AUTHORITY TO TOWN CLERK – STANDING ORDER 15(c) (APPLICATIONS RECEIVED THAT DID NOT APPEAR ON 19/12/17 AGENDA)

RECEIVED 13/12/17

N         8018  MR D HIRST: SINGLE-STOREY SIDE EXTENSION AND PITCHED ROOF TO EXISTING FRONT PORCH: 10 SCATCHERD GROVE (TEALE).

N         8058  MR K PATEL: SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 81 BIRK LANE (TEALE).

RECEIVED 19/12/17

NC       8082  MISS S BAADE: ALTERATIONS INVOLVING TWO-STOREY SIDE EXTENSION:

18 BECKSIDE VIEW (TOPCLIFFE).  MTC had no objection in principle, but felt that on-street parking should not be necessary as there is sufficient space for parking two cars.

All of the above decisions made under Town Clerk’s delegated authority, were noted.

6.         TO RECEIVE ITEMS OF CORRESPONDENCE (items for information only)

(a)        Copies of representations made (if any) since last meeting held on 19/12/17.

(b)        Email 14/12/17 A Booth: Minutes for South and West Plans Panel 7/12/17: Morley Items:  Appn 17/04308 – Land off Bradford Road, East Ardsley.

(c)        Email 27/12/17 from S Deegan, Senior Planner, Aldi, re. proposed new Aldi Store, Chartists Way, Morley and public exhibition on 11/1/18.

All of the above items of correspondence were noted.

7.         TO RECEIVE VERBAL UPDATE ON DUNNINGLEY INQUIRY AND FORTHCOMING CONSULTATIONS ON SITE ALLOCATIONS PLAN (SAP) AND CORE STRATEGY REVIEW (CSR) – CLLR T LEADLEY

Cllr Leadley provided a verbal update to members, for information, on the recent Dunningley Inquiry and two forthcoming consultations re. the Site Allocations Plan and Core Strategy Review.

Notes prepared by Cllr Leadley were passed to the Town Clerk, for information.

8.         DATE AND TIME OF NEXT MEETING

The next meeting is scheduled for Tuesday, 20th February 2018 at 7pm.

 

 

MINUTES OF PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING NO. 389

HELD ON TUESDAY, 19^TH DECEMBER 2017

1. ATTENDANCE AND APOLOGIES

Cllrs R Finnigan (Chairman), W Whitehead, J Sanders, A Rhodes, H Bell, H Evans (late arrival), C Windle (late arrival) and C Taylor (late arrival).  W Maynard-Light (Deputy Town Clerk) also attended.

Apologies were received from:  Cllr J Jackson.

2. Declarations of Disclosable Pecuniary and Other Interests

            Cllr Finnigan declared an ‘other’ interest as a member of Leeds City Council.

3. TO APPROVE MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON 21/11/17

The minutes of the meeting held on 21/11/17 were agreed as a true and correct record.

Cllrs H Evans and C Windle arrived at this point.

4. CONSIDERATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS

Notation of Recommendations.

O = Objection

N = No Objection

NC = No Objection (with comments)

D = Deferred

RECEIVED 28/11/17

O         7433  SCOTFIELD LTD: VARIATION OF CONDITION 2 OF PLANNING APPROVAL 13/00625/FU (APPROVED PLANS) FOR MINOR MATERIAL AMENDMENTS RELATING TO INCREASED FLOOR LEVEL TO PLOT 14: LAND OFF DAISY HILL CLOSE (SCATCHERD).

MTC objected to this planning application on the grounds of the significant impact on the residential amenities the increase in height will cause.

RECEIVED 29/11/17

N         6306  DR B SULAIMAN: RETROSPECTIVE APPLICATION FOR BOUNDARY TREATMENT: ‘KASTANDENE’, EAST PARK STREET (TEALE).

Cllr C Taylor arrived during discussions on the above item.

RECEIVED 1/12/17

N         7702  MR D MARTIN: CHANGE OF USE FROM RETAIL UNIT (CLASS USE A1) TO PUBLIC HOUSE (CLASS USE A4): TOWN END WORKS, WIDE LANE (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 6/12/17

NC       7745  MR R RODLEY: TWO-STOREY AND SINGLE-STOREY SIDE/REAR EXTENSION: 58 ROOMS LANE (SCATCHERD).

MTC in principle had no objection to this planning application.  Members requested a condition be placed on the application stating that vehicles should be parked off-street.

RECEIVED 7/12/17

N         7637  MR P NEWTON: FIRST FLOOR SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION: 92 NEW BANK STREET.

RECEIVED 8/12/17

O         7832  DONE BROTHERS (CASH BETTING) LTD: CHANGE OF USE OF VACANT RETAIL UNIT TO BETTING SHOP INCLUDING ALTERATIONS TO FRONTAGE: 86C QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

MTC objected to this application due to the impact this type of business genre will have on the town centre, as a whole, causing an imbalance to the layout and variation of businesses on the high street.

N         7782  MR CRAIG MURKINS: CHANGE OF USE FROM FINANCIAL AND PROFESSIONAL (CLASS USE A2) TO GYMOPHOBICS GYM (D2): 91 QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 11/12/17

N         8028  MRS A COLINS: SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 12 CROFT HOUSE LANE (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 13/12/17

 N         8055  MR M HARTILL: SINGLE-STOREY SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION: ‘DEEPDENE’, DEWSBURY ROAD (WOODKIRK).

O         8116/TR  MR M SINGH: T1- REMOVE: 14 STATION ROAD (CENTRAL).

MTC objected to this application on the grounds members felt it was unnecessary to remove a healthy tree.

N         7966  SQS DEVELOPMENTS LTD: VARIATION OF CONDITION 2 (APPROVED PLANS) OF APPROVAL 17/05238/FU FOR MINOR MATERIAL AMENDMENT TO ALTER INTERNAL HOUSE LAYOUTS, EXTERNAL SITE LAYOUT AND REVISED ELEVATIONS (CENTRAL).

The above Planning applications were considered by all members of the Planning Committee present.  It was agreed that any comments made be sent by ‘Public Access’.

5. TO NOTE PLANNING APPLICATIONS WITH DECISIONS MADE UNDER DELEGATED AUTHORITY TO TOWN CLERK – STANDING ORDER 15(c) (APPLICATIONS RECEIVED THAT DID NOT APPEAR ON 17/10/17 AGENDA).

RECEIVED 17/11/17

N         7246  MS S COOK: NEW SHOP FRONT: VEEJAYS, GROUND FLOOR, 69 QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 21/11/17

N         7487  MS C FERREIRA: SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION; PART SINGLE-STOREY AND PART TWO-STOREY SIDE EXTENSIONS: CONVERSION OF GARAGE TO HABITABLE ROOM; OUTBUILDING TO REAR: 6 ROSEATE GREEN (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 24/11/17

N         7559:  MR P FRYER: SINGLE-STOREY SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION WITH RAISED DECKING AREA: 10 CROFT HOUSE WALK (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 28/11/17

N         7580  MR P TEMPLE: DORMER WINDOW TO REAR: 17 SANDPIPER APPROACH (TOPCLIFFE).

All of the above decisions made under Town Clerk’s delegated authority, were noted.

6.   TO RECEIVE ITEMS OF CORRESPONDENCE (items for information only)

(a)        Copies of representations made (if any) since last meeting held on 21/11/17

(b)        Updated key planning enforcement cases for Morley North & Morley South Wards.

(c)        Letter dated 17/11/17 Head of Dev Management to Town Clerk re. planning appeal by Mr S Ahmed re. Morley Manor, Brunswick Street (Teale) – Planning Inspectorate Ref: APP/N4720/W/17/3189143.

All of the above items of correspondence were noted.

7. DATE AND TIME OF NEXT MEETING

The next meeting is scheduled for Tuesday, 9th January 2018 at 7pm.

 

 

MINUTES OF PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING NO. 387

 HELD ON TUESDAY, 17^TH OCTOBER 2017

1. ATTENDANCE AND APOLOGIES

Cllrs R Finnigan (Chairman), C Taylor, J Jackson, J Sanders, W Whitehead, C Windle and

H Bell (late arrival). Cllr T Leadley (LCC) and W Maynard-Light (Deputy Town Clerk) also attended.

There were no apologies received.

2. Declarations of Disclosable Pecuniary and Other Interests

Cllr Finnigan declared an ‘other’ interest as a member of Leeds City Council.

3. TO APPROVE MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON 19/9/17

The minutes of the meeting held on 19/9/17 were agreed as a true and correct record.

4. CONSIDERATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS

Notation of Recommendations.

O = Objection

N = No Objection

NC = No Objection (with comments)

D = Deferred

RECEIVED 27/9/17

N         6277  MR M PRICE: SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION AND DETACHED GARAGE TO SIDE: 3 MEADOW WAY, TINGLEY (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 28/9/17

N         6167  MR G SEPHTON: TWO-STOREY AND SINGLE-STOREY EXTENSION WITH CANOPY TO SIDE/REAR; NEW PARKING AREA TO FRONT: 10 MARSHALL CRESCENT (ELMFIELD).

Cllr H Bell arrived during the discussion of the above item.

RECEIVED 29/9/17

N         6293  MRS M CASINELLI: TWO-STOREY AND SINGLE-STOREY SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION: 8 MARSHALL CRESCENT (ELMFIELD).

RECEIVED 2/10/17

N         6295  MR R JHA: TWO-STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 4 BAKER ROAD (ELMFIELD).

N         5364  MR H CHEEMA: TWO-STOREY EXTENSION AND ALTERATIONS TO EXISTING DETACHED GARAGE TO FORM GRANNY ANNEXE: 1167 DEWSBURY ROAD (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 3/10/17

N         4474  RBS: LISTED BUILDING APPLICATION TO CARRY OUT ALTERATIONS INVOLVING INSTALLATION OF WIRELESS INTERNET ACCESS POINTS: 89A QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

RECEIVED 4/10/17

N         5406  MR F IMRAN ISSA: CHANGE OF USE AND ALTERATIONS OF FIRST TO FOURTH FLOOR OF FORMER THEATRE/RESTAURANT TO FORM 14 FLATS, ALTERATIONS TO RESTAURANT/FUNCTION ROOM AT GROUND AND LOWER GROUND LEVEL: NEW PAVILION BUILDINGS, HIGH STREET (CENTRAL).

The above planning applications were considered by all members of the Planning Committee present.  It was agreed that any comments made be sent via ‘Public Access’.

5. TO NOTE PLANNING APPLICATIONS WITH DECISIONS MADE UNDER DELEGATED AUTHORITY TO TOWN CLERK – STANDING ORDER 15(c) (APPLICATIONS RECEIVED THAT DID NOT APPEAR ON 15/8/17 AGENDA).

RECEIVED 13/9/17

O         5682  MS M DUNN: CHANGE OF USE OF GROUND AND FIRST FLOOR OFFICES TO CHILDREN’S DAY NURSERY: QUARRY COURT, HIGH STREET (CENTRAL).

MTC objected to this application due to issues around parking in the area.  Also, the building appears to be mixed use which may not be ideal and the Town Council requests that this be referred to Plans Panel.

RECEIVED 15/9/17

N         6021  MRS N GANLEY: SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION, DEMOLITION OF EXISTING CONSERVATORY TO REAR: 25 MALLARD WAY (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 19/9/17

N         0769  WOODKIRK STONE SALES LTD: WEIGHBRIDGE AND OFFICE (RETROSPECTIVE); BRITANNIA QUARRY, HOWLEY PARK ROAD EAST (ELMFIELD).

RECEIVED 21/9/17

O         5887  MR A HEWITT: TWO-STOREY FRONT EXTENSION; SINGLE-STOREY SIDE/REAR EXTENSION: 5 HARWILL AVENUE (CHURWELL).

MTC objected to this application due to the impact on the street scene and parking issues.

N         5805  PINSTRIPE: EXTERNAL ALTERATIONS COMPRISING COLOUR CHANGE TO CLADDING, WINDOW AND DOOR OPENINGS AND NEW AIR-CONDITIONING UNITS: ADWALTON HOUSE, BRUNTCLIFFE AVENUE (TEALE).

O         5974  MR T ELSE: TWO-STOREY AND SINGLE-STOREY SIDE, REAR AND FRONT EXTENSION, DORMER WINDOWS TO SIDE AND REAR: 76 SCOTCHMAN LANE (TEALE).

MTC objected to the application due to the impact on the street scene and issues with parking.

RECEIVED 22/9/17

N         6178  TWO-STOREY AND SINGLE-STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 92 REIN ROAD (WOODKIRK).

RECEIVED 26/9/17

N         6247  MR M H SAHIB: ALTERATIONS INVOLVING FIRST-FLOOR EXTENSION TO CARE HOME: FERNDALE CARE HOME: BRITANNIA ROAD (ELMFIELD).

N         5802  MR H PEARCEY: NEW FENCING AND GATES TO FRONT AND SIDE: 9 MARSTON AVENUE (ELMFIELD).

RECEIVED 27/9/17

N         5998  MR G BUTTERWORTH: TWO-STOREY BLOCK OF TWO 2-BEDROOM FLATS: LAND TO REAR OF 25 HIGH STREET (CENTRAL).

All the above decisions made under Town Clerk’s delegated authority, were noted.

6. TO RECEIVE ITEMS OF CORRESPONDENCE (items for information only)

(a)        Copies of representations made (if any) since last meeting held on 19/9/17 (copies attached).

(b)        Letter dated 15/9/17 from S Butler, Dev Management, LCC, re. appeal against refusal APPN/N4720/D/17/3/3180560, 58 Rooms Lane (Scatcherd).

(c)        Updated key Planning enforcement cases for Morley North & Morley South wards.

(d)        Email 21/9/17 from Tong & Fulneck Valley Association re. Agenda for AGM on 12/10/17.

(e)        Copy of letter dated 27/9/17 from Cllr T Leadley to H Wilson, Programme Officer, Leeds SAP Examination re. ‘Leeds City Council Position Statement: Core Strategy Selective Review’.

(f)        Email 6/10/17 from David Feeney, Head of Strategic Planning LCC, re. Leeds Site Allocations Plan (SAP) update October 2017.

(g)        Letter 9/10/17 from Steve Butler, Head of Development Management LCC, re. appeal against refusal, Planning application 16/07926/FU, 14 Stubley Farm Mews.

All the above decisions made under Town Clerk’s delegated authority, were noted.

7. TO RECEIVE VERBAL REPORT ON LEEDS SITE ALLOCATIONS PLAN (SAP) EXAMINATION – CLLR T LEADLEY

            Cllr Leadley tabled his report and gave a verbal overview of the contents.

8. TO DISCUSS AND AGREE PLANNING COMMITTEE BUDGET SUBMISSION FOR 2018-19 (for referral to the Finance, GP & Strategic Committee).

            Following a discussion, a budget of £1,000 for 2018-19 was agreed.

9. DATE AND TIME OF NEXT MEETING

The next meeting is scheduled for Tuesday, 21^st November 2017 at 7pm.

 

 

MINUTES OF PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING NO. 386

HELD ON TUESDAY, 19TH SEPTEMBER 2017

1.         ATTENDANCE AND APOLOGIES

Cllrs R Finnigan (Chairman), J Sanders, W Whitehead, H Bell, H Evans and A Rhodes.

Apologies were received from Cllrs C Taylor and C Windle.

2.         Declarations of Disclosable Pecuniary and Other Interests

None were declared.

3.         TO APPROVE MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON 15/8/17

The minutes of the meeting held on 15/8/17 were agreed as a true and correct record.

4.         CONSIDERATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS

Notation of Recommendations.
O = Objection
N = No Objection
NC = No Objection (with comments)
D = Deferred
RECEIVED 29/8/17

O         5238  SQS DEVELOPMENTS LTD: DEMOLITION OF FORMER BAKERY AND ERECTION OF BLOCK OF SIX TERRACE HOUSES: LAND AT JUNCTION OF ST PAUL’S STREET AND SOUTH QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

Members objected to this application as it is felt that the site will be over-developed by 1 unit and the number of units should be reduced to 5 to allow for more parking spaces.  Also there is inadequate garden space at Unit 5.

RECEIVED 8/9/17

N         5892  MR M CHAVDA: CHANGE OF USE OF EXISTING CAFÉ TO FOOD PREPARATION AND CATERING FACILITY: 78 FOUNTAIN STREET (CENTRAL).

The above planning applications were considered by all members of the Planning Committee present.  It was agreed that any comments made be sent via ‘Public Access’.

5.         TO NOTE PLANNING APPLICATIONS WITH DECISIONS MADE UNDER DELEGATED AUTHORITY TO TOWN CLERK – STANDING ORDER 15(c) (APPLICATIONS RECEIVED THAT DID NOT APPEAR ON 15/8/17 AGENDA).

RECEIVED 10/8/17

N         4882  MRS S BROWN: SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 12 GUILLEMOT APPROACH (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 14/8/17

N         5072  MR & MRS WINTERBURN: CHANGE OF USE OF FORMER METHODIST CHURCH TO DWELLING WITH SINGLE STOREY EXTENSION AND DETACHED GARAGE TO REAR: BACK GREEN (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 24/8/17

N         5334  MR & MRS LAWSON: REMOVAL OF CONDITION 9 (LANDSCAPING SCHEME) OF APPROVAL 16/02597/FU: 9 STONECHAT RISE (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 29/8/17

N         5319  MRS J MANUEL: TWO-STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 53 BIRK LANE (TEALE).

N         5351/LI  RBS: LISTED BUILDING APPLICATION TO INSTALL NEW WIRELESS ACCESS POINTS WITHIN THE BRANCH TO PROVIDE INTERNET ACCESS: NAT WEST, 89 QUEEN STREET (CENTRAL).

All the above decisions made under Town Clerk’s delegated authority, were noted.

6.         TO RECEIVE ITEMS OF CORRESPONDENCE (items for information only)

(a)        Copies of representations made (if any) since last meeting held on 15/8/17.

(b)        Letter dated 15/8/17 from S Butler, Dev Management, LCC, re. appeal, appn 17/01834/FU – 17 Teal Drive.

(c)        Letter dated 4/9/17 from S Butler, Dev Management, LCC, re. appeal against refusal APPN/N4720/W/17/3180023 – 60 Middleton Road.

7.         DATE AND TIME OF NEXT MEETING

The next meeting is scheduled for Tuesday, 17th October 2017 at 7pm.

 

 

MINUTES OF PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING NO. 385

HELD ON TUESDAY, 15TH AUGUST 2017

1.         ATTENDANCE AND APOLOGIES

Present:  Cllrs R Finnigan (Chairman), J Sanders, W Whitehead and C Windle.  K Oakley – Town Clerk and Cllr R Bell also attended.

Apologies were received from Cllrs H Evans, H Bell and C Taylor.

2.         Declarations of Disclosable Pecuniary and Other Interests

Cllr R Finnigan declared an ‘other’ interest in any appropriate items, as a Leeds City Council Morley North Ward Member.

3.         TO APPROVE MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON 18/7/17

The minutes of the meeting held on 18/7/17 were agreed as a true and correct record.

4.         CONSIDERATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS

Notation of Recommendations.
O = Objection
N = No Objection
NC = No Objection (with comments)
D = Deferred

RECEIVED 26/7/17

NC       1824  MR J GRUNFELD: REVISED PLANS – CHANGE OF USE AND ALTERATIONS OF EXISTING MILL BUILDINGS TO FORM 54 FLATS, NEW ACCESS, LANDSCAPING, CAR PARKING AND BOUNDARIES, DEMOLITION OF ATTACHED WORKSHOPS: TINGLEY MILLS, BRIDGE STREET (TOPCLIFFE).

MTC supported but condition should be applied that there is sufficient bin storage space to support number of units on site.

N         4582  MR G NASH: OUTLINE APPLICATION FOR FOUR DETACHED HOUSES TO VACANT LAND: LAND OFF THE GALLOPS (ELMFIELD).

N         4679  MR G CAMPBELL: SINGLE STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 15 BACK GREEN (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 27/7/17

N         4685  MS S DOBSON: SINGLE STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: 3 SUNNY BANK (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 28/7/17

N         4265  YORKSHIRE HOUSING: ALTERATIONS INVOLVING REPLACEMENT DOOR TO FLAT: FLAT 175, WIDE LANE (TOPCLIFFE).

N         4788  MR A ARIF: CHANGE OF USE FROM CAR-WRECKERS YARD TO HAND CAR WASH: LAND OFF MILL STREET (ELMFIELD).

RECEIVED 7/8/17

N         4971  MR & MRS ROBINSON: REMOVAL OF EXISTING REAR CONSERVATORY: CONSTRUCTION OF NEW SINGLE STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 15 WINDERS DALE (SCATCHERD).

RECEIVED 9/8/17

O         5287  MR J PATEL: SINGLE STOREY FRONT EXTENSION AND ALTERATIONS TO SHOP ALTERATIONS TO FORM TWO SELF CONTAINED FLATS TO FIRST FLOOR: 26 HORSFALL STREET (SCATCHERD).

MTC objected to this application due to significant impact on the streetscene, the proposed metal shutters are unacceptable, insufficient parking provision and there is a bus stop directly outside the premises.

The above planning applications were considered by all members of the Planning Committee present.  It was agreed that any comments made be sent via ‘Public Access’.

5.         TO NOTE PLANNING APPLICATIONS WITH DECISIONS MADE UNDER DELEGATED AUTHORITY TO TOWN CLERK – STANDING ORDER 15(c) (APPLICATIONS RECEIVED THAT DID NOT APPEAR ON 18/7/17 AGENDA).

RECEIVED 11/7/17

N         4332  MR HUNTER: SINGLE-STOREY SIDE AND REAR EXTENSION AND PORCH TO FRONT: 68 CORPORATION STREET (TEALE).

RECEIVED 12/7/17

N         4343  MR I ROBERTS: SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 3 DUNNOCK CROFT (TOPCLIFFE).

RECEIVED 13/7/17

N         4443  MR & MRS J HAWLEY: TWO-STOREY AND FIRST-FLOOR SIDE EXTENSION AND SINGLE-STOREY REAR EXTENSION: 1 BARNET GROVE (ELMFIELD).

N         4380  MR W THOMPSON: TWO-STOREY SIDE EXTENSION: PARK HOUSE, ELLAND ROAD (CHURWELL).

RECEIVED 19/7/17

N         3789  MISS MCLAUGHLIN: RETROSPECTIVE APPLICATION FOR RAISED PLATFORM WITH STEPS AND BALUSTRADE ABOVE TO REAR: 7 BRITANNIA SQUARE (ELMFIELD).

O         4504  MRS DAVIES: CONVERT PART OF INTEGRAL GARAGE TO HABITABLE ROOMS: 6 PEREGRINE AVENUE (TOPCLIFFE).

MTC objected due to proposal for second parking space to be on the pavement.

RECEIVED 25/7/17

N         4191  MR C WENHAM: SINGLE STOREY SIDE/REAR EXTENSION; DORMER WINDOWS TO FRONT AND REAR: 21 MANOR FARM DRIVE (CHURWELL).

N         4519  MR PLUNKETT: SINGLE STOREY CONSERVATORY TO REAR: 33 MILLBECK APPROACH (TOPCLIFFE).

All the above decisions made under Town Clerk’s delegated authority, were noted.

6.         TO RECEIVE ITEMS OF CORRESPONDENCE (items for information only)

(a)        Copies of representations made (if any) since last meeting held on 18/7/17.

(b)        Email dated 12/7/17 from R Hollinson, Local Development, Kirklees Council, re. ‘Kirklees Local Plan’.

(c)        Email dated 18/7/17 re. Minutes from South & West Plans Panel meeting 6/7/17, including Morley items: Appn 17/00983 – 2 Bramleigh Drive.

(d)        Updated key planning enforcement cases for Morley North & Morley South Wards.

(e)        Email 19/7/17 from resident of Birk Lane regarding Planning Appn 17/03852.

(f)        Copy letter dated 19/7/17 from Cllr T Leadley to Policy & Plans, LCC, re. ‘Leeds LDF Hot-Food Takeaway Supplementary Planning Document: Response to Formal Consultation’.  Members agreed to support this.

(g)        Letter dated 19/7/17 from H Wilson, Programme Officer, re. ‘Examination of the Leeds Site Allocations Plan’.

(h)        Letter dated 2/8/17 from Morley Town Council to Planning Inspectorate re. Statement of Case by Rule 6 Party APPN/N4720/W/17/3169594: Appeal by Sir Robert Ogden Partnership against Leeds City Council’s Failure to Determine an Outline Application for about 770 houses at Dunningley, West of A654, Thorpe Lane.  A copy had been distributed to members.

(i)            Letter dated 3/8/17 from SQS Developments Ltd, re. land at the junction of South Queen Street and St Paul’s Street.

The following item of correspondence was tabled:-

(j)         Email copy of response dated 11/8/17 from Cllr T Leadley to Ms H Wilson, Programme Officer, re. ‘Examination of Leeds Site Allocation Plan’ (see item 6(g) above).  Members agreed to support this.

The above items of correspondence were noted.

7.         LEEDS CORE STRATEGY SELECTIVE REVIEW: CONSULTATION RESPONSE MADE BY CLLR T LEADLEY.

This item was noted.

8.         DATE AND TIME OF NEXT MEETING

The next meeting is scheduled for Tuesday, 19th September 2017 at 7pm.